"Maadhav & Ganesh
Talking about bhajans, like GP most of the bhajans are cry of a devotee to the lord. If you listen to marathi abhangs like "Pathitha mee paapi" and its purely a cry of Tukaram to vittal . if you know "sadasiva brahmendra" who wrote "pibare ramasam" & Broohi mukundeti that is of a different order.
Maadhav
I disagree with your poitn that only saints can sing bhajan, when you sing truly in search for HIM anything is bhajan. "
Well Mr.Madhav i totally disagree with the very concept you have in your mind about other religions and about our religion too........firstly our religion doesnt teach us ..violence and revenge..our religion say's "FORGIVE"...our religion doest tell us to hate anybody....our religion say's spread "LOVE".....well u have criticised Gandhji...but i ask u for what?? because he wrote a verse "Raghupati Raghava Raja Ram........" well i ask u whats wrong in it??...i dont find it incorrect...he never told you or anybody to sing that verse in a temple or something like that....all he wanted is to make ppl like you and other anti-muslim and anti-hindu ,anti-sikh to understand that almighty God is one...it is senceless to fight with each other on his name..this is what he meant....
well if u think that singin this verse makes you or us coward ....its ur misconception....our religion belives in forgiving...
well u said this verse didnt helped us...let me ask u..how we got independence..how hindu-muslim-sikh got united.well Mr.Madhav it realy helped us to gain our independence..y did partition occured did u ever asked yourself ..why? it happened?...because ppl like you never belived in it(verse-: Raghupati raghava raja Ram.....)
most of the indians belived in this verse thats why our india is a secular nation
<<<and our knowing it does not stop us from being slaughtered by them. not a bit. we need to unite to teach them that they need to give up islam or give up bharat. there are non violent ways to do it too.>>>>
Well yes the Islamic rulers from afganistan slaughtered the hindu's...... i wanna ask u
so what are you going to do...slaughter 'em too... well i wanna ask you again ..who are you to punish 'em..are you God? who r you to judge Gandhiji...r u God??....its none of our business to judge or punish any human... your job is to see what u are? and what is your job on earth that god has given you.. The afganis suffered for their sin's ...you can see the shape of afganistan,Iraq,palestine....they are suffering for their sins...
<<<<any composition made by a non saint or non aachary is not a bhajan.
no saint or aachary has sung rabhupati raghav.
therefore, it is not a bhajan and should not be sung
in religious gatherings.>>>>
well "narasinha maheta, mirabai, tukaram " who were these peole ..were they God's???
i dont think so..Mira was a simple women...the bhajans which she use to sing has so much value ...why??...bcoz those bhajans came from true heart....who was kabir??? a simle man...y does.his dohas are considered so valuable...coz those words came from his trues heart..........same with Gandhiji why his verse is so valuable...bcoz it came from his true heart.. even Sri Sai Baba said "SAB KA MALIK EK HAI" whats the difference in SAI BABA'S VERSE and GANDHIJI's VERSE
well its senceless to say "any composition made by a non saint or non aachary is not a bhajan."
but rather let me put it in this way "any composition made by a human is not a bhajan unless it is true from your heart".
.where was sri prabhupada when indians were suffering due to britains??? well he remembered Ghandiji when we got the independence....he wanted to spread hinduta after independence.............y didnt he approached Gandhiji b4 independence to help him.????
Ghandiji has done so much for the people but he had nothing for himself....
well look at yourself..where are you right now...in "USA" look into urself b4 criticisng others.
look its so very easy to criticise a person...