Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

gurus and disciples

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Many people are now becoming familiar with such things as false gurus,

fallen gurus, etc. It has been going on forever. Growing up in India, one

runs across so many tricksters and magicians. It is true here too in the U.S

and other places as well. Psychic hotlines and people who can make you talk

to your dead uncle or great grandfather are now becoming common. I see it

sometimes on T.V. They are advertising these things because people love

that. Where there is a market for these services there will be providers as

well. There is no country, culture, religion or spiritual tradition which is

immune from mistaking illusion for Reality.

 

What is it that attracts people to such gurus who promise miracles and magic

and producing things out thin air, etc. Is it not something in them as well,

either material or spiritual greed? Such disciples and gurus need each other

and feed on each other. Water always finds its own level.

 

Of course, it seems like innocent people get hurt as well. What can be done?

This is the nature of such things.

 

A devotee who knows the Self cannot be fooled or taken in even by the

greatest magicians. His simplicity and perpetual freshness of

Self-Realization makes wonderful gifts and riches and promises and miracles

appear dry and without any meaning what so ever.

 

The beauty of Self-Realization lies in knowing the stillness with direct

clarity.

 

Once Sri Ramana was asked about the fate of disciples of a fallen guru

and/or the false guru himself. The Sage said, "Each according to their own

merit." That is the simple truth.

 

Love to all

Harsha

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Harsha --

 

Yes!

 

Not to mention ones who rather than simply *be* truth,

are invested in convincing people that

"I am being truth and will teach you how to be".

 

A subtle dynamic, the sometimes well-concealed

sense of investment in getting something

from a listener, follower, or devotee.

The distinction between being and obtaining.

 

This same distinction between "being"

and "seeking to obtain" applies in day to day

relationships and work of "ordinary folks".

 

I sense a difference in tone between

one who is simply being aware, and

one who is seeking to gain others' attention,

following, admiration, adoration.

 

And, many tricksters as well as charistmatic

teachers, leaders, speakers and writers fall into

that category.

 

Peace,

Dan

 

--- Harsha <harsha-hkl wrote:

> Many people are now becoming familiar with such

> things as false gurus,

> fallen gurus, etc. It has been going on forever.

> Growing up in India, one

> runs across so many tricksters and magicians. It is

> true here too in the U.S

> and other places as well. Psychic hotlines and

> people who can make you talk

> to your dead uncle or great grandfather are now

> becoming common. I see it

> sometimes on T.V. They are advertising these things

> because people love

> that. Where there is a market for these services

> there will be providers as

> well. There is no country, culture, religion or

> spiritual tradition which is

> immune from mistaking illusion for Reality.

>

> What is it that attracts people to such gurus who

> promise miracles and magic

> and producing things out thin air, etc. Is it not

> something in them as well,

> either material or spiritual greed? Such disciples

> and gurus need each other

> and feed on each other. Water always finds its own

> level.

>

> Of course, it seems like innocent people get hurt as

> well. What can be done?

> This is the nature of such things.

>

> A devotee who knows the Self cannot be fooled or

> taken in even by the

> greatest magicians. His simplicity and perpetual

> freshness of

> Self-Realization makes wonderful gifts and riches

> and promises and miracles

> appear dry and without any meaning what so ever.

>

> The beauty of Self-Realization lies in knowing the

> stillness with direct

> clarity.

>

> Once Sri Ramana was asked about the fate of

> disciples of a fallen guru

> and/or the false guru himself. The Sage said, "Each

> according to their own

> merit." That is the simple truth.

>

> Love to all

> Harsha

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

 

 

 

 

Get email alerts & NEW webcam video instant messaging with Messenger

http://im.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Harsha & Friends,

 

Well, Harsha, we can't always agree on everything, can we?

 

"A devotee who knows the Self cannot be fooled or taken in even by the

greatest magicians. His simplicity and perpetual freshness of

Self-Realization makes wonderful gifts and riches and promises and

miracles appear dry and without any meaning what so ever."

 

Isn't the devotee you are positing here, not a devotee at all, but

rather a Realized being? What devotee "knows the Self?" In my

estimation, all devotees "can be fooled or taken in even by the

greatest magicians". It is why we all, secretly, fear becoming a

devotee. We know that there is a world "out there", where we will be

taken advantage of simply because, in answer to the requests of

God/Guru we will be exposed in our desire to "see God in each other".

 

I don't think you are crediting "God" with the deviousness that is

truly God's due. It is always good to remember the truth; we seek God

because God hides himself/herself from us. If it were not so, god's

leela wouldn't inspire any "takers".

 

yours in the bonds,

eric

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

, "Harsha" <harsha-hkl@h...> wrote:

> Many people are now becoming familiar with such things as false

gurus,

> fallen gurus, etc. It has been going on forever. Growing up in

India, one

> runs across so many tricksters and magicians. It is true here too

in the U.S

> and other places as well. Psychic hotlines and people who can make

you talk

> to your dead uncle or great grandfather are now becoming common. I

see it

> sometimes on T.V. They are advertising these things because people

love

> that. Where there is a market for these services there will be

providers as

> well. There is no country, culture, religion or spiritual tradition

which is

> immune from mistaking illusion for Reality.

>

> What is it that attracts people to such gurus who promise miracles

and magic

> and producing things out thin air, etc. Is it not something in them

as well,

> either material or spiritual greed? Such disciples and gurus need

each other

> and feed on each other. Water always finds its own level.

>

> Of course, it seems like innocent people get hurt as well. What can

be done?

> This is the nature of such things.

>

> A devotee who knows the Self cannot be fooled or taken in even by

the

> greatest magicians. His simplicity and perpetual freshness of

> Self-Realization makes wonderful gifts and riches and promises and

miracles

> appear dry and without any meaning what so ever.

>

> The beauty of Self-Realization lies in knowing the stillness with

direct

> clarity.

>

> Once Sri Ramana was asked about the fate of disciples of a fallen

guru

> and/or the false guru himself. The Sage said, "Each according to

their own

> merit." That is the simple truth.

>

> Love to all

> Harsha

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...