Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Kali--Ramakrishna

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Thanks everybody

 

and particularly Mazie for the gorgeous Kalis.

 

A realized being suggested me to read the book:

 

"Kali's child. The mystical and the Erotic in the Life and teachings of Ramakrishna"

 

I am a little hesitant, though I will do it, trusting where the suggestion comes from.

 

Anybody knows this book?

 

in love

marifa

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I have read about this book before, here is a random pick from a quick search

Alan

Kali's Child: A Methodological NightmareKali's Child: The Mystical and

the Erotic in the Life and Teachings of Ramakrishna is, at its best,

an intellectual pornography designed at denigrating an outside

culture. Intellectual it certainly is, for it attempts to apply the

techniques of Freudian "science" to the field of mysticism, in order

to bring the deepest level of the human soul under the ken of

scientific enquiry. It is pornography, as the author dives in his

scientific mode into the mystic level, armed with the tools of

nudity, both the homo as well as the hetero-sexual varieties of it,

for a specific use in view, without any apparent respect for the

mystic process at all. -- Dr. Sitansu Sekhar Chakravarti, Ph.D.

Protest Letters for Kali's ChildThe book Kali's Child: The Mystical

and the Erotic in the Life and Teachings of Ramakrishna, by Jeffrey

Kripal was recently published by the University of Chicago Press. The

highly flawed book (based on an earlier Ph.D. thesis) has been most

disturbing to Hindus worldwide. The twisted conclusions and

derogatory ideas presented in the book are clearly intended as an

assault on Hinduism in general, and on Paramhansa Shree Rama Krishna,

in particular.-- Dr. Sitansu Sekhar Chakravarti, Ph.D. & Others

-

Emanuele De Benedetti

Monday, April 12, 2004 8:44 PM

Kali--Ramakrishna

Thanks everybody

and particularly Mazie for the gorgeous Kalis.

A realized being suggested me to read the book:

"Kali's child. The mystical and the Erotic in the Life and teachings of Ramakrishna"

I am a little hesitant, though I will do it, trusting where the suggestion comes from.

Anybody knows this book?

in love

marifa/join

"Love itself

is the actual form of God."Sri RamanaIn "Letters from Sri

Ramanasramam" by Suri Nagamma

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Dear Marifa,

 

"Kali's Child" is said to be somewhat critical of Sri

Ramakrishna. The Ramakrishna establishment has

denounced the book.

 

I myself haven't read it.

 

Have you read the Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna or The

Great Master? I think that they're both wonderul

books.

 

Warmest regards,

 

michael

 

--- Emanuele De Benedetti <e.debenedetti

wrote:

> Thanks everybody

>

> and particularly Mazie for the gorgeous Kalis.

>

> A realized being suggested me to read the book:

>

> "Kali's child. The mystical and the Erotic in the

> Life and teachings of Ramakrishna"

>

> I am a little hesitant, though I will do it,

> trusting where the suggestion comes from.

>

> Anybody knows this book?

>

> in love

> marifa

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

i would not recommend this book to anyone ..

 

specially those who have high regards for the Saint...

 

it is a sensation-mongering book - it talks about Sri ramakrishna in

a derogatory way - hinting he is a 'homo-sexual' ...

 

LOVE

 

PS i have nothing against 'homosexuals' but Shri ramakrishna is a

saint and hindus do not like these kind of accusations.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

-- In , Michael Bowes

<rmichaelbowes> wrote:

> Dear Marifa,

>

> "Kali's Child" is said to be somewhat critical of Sri

> Ramakrishna. The Ramakrishna establishment has

> denounced the book.

>

> I myself haven't read it.

>

> Have you read the Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna or The

> Great Master? I think that they're both wonderul

> books.

>

> Warmest regards,

>

> michael

>

> --- Emanuele De Benedetti <e.debenedetti@t...>

> wrote:

> > Thanks everybody

> >

> > and particularly Mazie for the gorgeous Kalis.

> >

> > A realized being suggested me to read the book:

> >

> > "Kali's child. The mystical and the Erotic in the

> > Life and teachings of Ramakrishna"

> >

> > I am a little hesitant, though I will do it,

> > trusting where the suggestion comes from.

> >

> > Anybody knows this book?

> >

> > in love

> > marifa

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Hullo Adi,

it is interesting to hear that, amongst Hindus, it is considered

insulting to suggest that someone might be gay.

That used to be the case in the West but over the last twenty years,

gays, and people of a generally friendly disposition, have managed

to destroy that stigma. Not entirely, of course, because there are

those who derive great pleasure from stereotyping certain groups and

making them objects of scorn. There are those who would rather give

up their children than give up their prejudices.

Let's hope that this stigma, and the immense suffering it causes, can

be progressively destroyed all over the world.

Love

Warwick

- adi_shakthi16 To:

Tuesday, April 13, 2004 9:20

AM Re: Kali--Ramakrishnai would not

recommend this book to anyone .. specially those who have high

regards for the Saint... it is a sensation-mongering book - it talks

about Sri ramakrishna in a derogatory way - hinting he is a

'homo-sexual' ... LOVE PS i have nothing against 'homosexuals' but

Shri ramakrishna is a saint and hindus do not like these kind of

accusations.

/join

"Love itself

is the actual form of God."Sri RamanaIn "Letters from Sri

Ramanasramam" by Suri Nagamma

Sponsor LinksTo visit your group on the

web, go to:/ To

from this group, send an email

to: Your use of

Groups is subject to the

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

dear warwick,

 

it is not so much the fact that hindus are against 'gays' but Shri

Ramakrishna is supposed to be a saint and ,devout hindus are not

interested in discussing his sexual orientation - no matter whether

he is homo or hetrosexual! He is supposed to have transcended

mundane 'sexuality'

 

love

 

ps i am not homo-phoboic - just to let you know!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

-- In , "Warwick Wakefield"

<formandsubstance@t...> wrote:

> Hullo Adi,

>

> it is interesting to hear that, amongst Hindus, it is considered

insulting to suggest that someone might be gay.

> That used to be the case in the West but over the last twenty

years, gays, and people of a generally friendly disposition, have

managed to destroy that stigma. Not entirely, of course, because

there are those who derive great pleasure from stereotyping certain

groups and making them objects of scorn. There are those who would

rather give up their children than give up their prejudices.

>

> Let's hope that this stigma, and the immense suffering it causes,

can be progressively destroyed all over the world.

>

> Love

> Warwick

>

> -

> adi_shakthi16

>

> Tuesday, April 13, 2004 9:20 AM

> Re: Kali--Ramakrishna

>

>

> i would not recommend this book to anyone ..

>

> specially those who have high regards for the Saint...

>

> it is a sensation-mongering book - it talks about Sri ramakrishna

in

> a derogatory way - hinting he is a 'homo-sexual' ...

>

> LOVE

>

> PS i have nothing against 'homosexuals' but Shri ramakrishna is a

> saint and hindus do not like these kind of accusations.

>

>

>

/join

>

>

>

>

>

> "Love itself is the actual form of God."

>

> Sri Ramana

>

> In "Letters from Sri Ramanasramam" by Suri Nagamma

>

>

> Sponsor

>

Links

>

>

> /

>

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

>From what I have read in the introduction,

the book is not necesseraly accusatory, in a moralistic way,

of Ramakrishna. My guess is that the book mantains that

Ramakrishna ecstasies were often triggered by the proximity of

a close disciple. And there was contact with his feet, or arms.

This doesn't mean that he was openly homosexual, and not even conscious

of any tendency.

As we all know the energy due to difference in polarity, if properly

channeled, can be used to reach higher states of consciousness,

and Ramakrishna had also a very good Tantra training with an enlightened

woman.

(more after I have read it)

 

What is important for a seeker of Truth is to seek Truth at any cost,

I don't think that a possible hidden homosexuality in Ramaksrihna

can diminish his giant stature of Kali's devotee.

Few years ago I had been reading, for almost two years continuosly, his

gospels,

and it is the maximum in devotion, but also there is a deep understanding of

non-duality.

Can homosexuality diminish my love and respect for such a being?

 

We have to be careful, when we search for Truth not to be attached

to our ideal of how reality should be, of our idea of right and wrong,

and I speak for myself too: Reality is much, much vaster than any of us can

perceive,

even for an enlightened being there is no end to the Mistery of

manifestation.

 

Many of us still live with the idea that a saint has gone beyond any

attachment:

for what I have lived in the last few years I could say that even

attachments

can be lived in freedom:

once the non-dual nature of our Self is revealed, the realisation has

happened,

but the body-mind conditionments not necesserely drop on their own:

does this mean that one is not fully realised?

Or it is just our ideas of how realisation should be?.

If I know, really know because I am it, that I don't exist as a person,

individual,

but that I am lived by Life itself through this body-mind,

does it really matter if there is any attachment?

When I am All, does it really matter whether My actions are performed by

this individual body-mind or another one?

So is this body a saint, but not my consciousness that embraces everything?

 

Sorry ladies and guys and gays, so many questions

that are still quite hot for many of us....

 

And of course I bow down to the difference in cultural background,

that make a hindu not interested in discussing these matters.

Osho was often saying that Freud is not for Hindus or Japanese,

if you tell them that they hate their father

and want to make love with their mother, they might kill you. :)

 

in love and provocation

and joy and fun

 

marifa

 

 

-

"adi_shakthi16" <adi_shakthi16

<>

Tuesday, April 13, 2004 1:20 AM

Re: Kali--Ramakrishna

 

> i would not recommend this book to anyone ..

>

> specially those who have high regards for the Saint...

>

> it is a sensation-mongering book - it talks about Sri ramakrishna in

> a derogatory way - hinting he is a 'homo-sexual' ...

>

> LOVE

>

> PS i have nothing against 'homosexuals' but Shri ramakrishna is a

> saint and hindus do not like these kind of accusations.

>

>

-- In , Michael Bowes

> <rmichaelbowes> wrote:

> > Dear Marifa,

> >

> > "Kali's Child" is said to be somewhat critical of Sri

> > Ramakrishna. The Ramakrishna establishment has

> > denounced the book.

> >

> > I myself haven't read it.

> >

> > Have you read the Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna or The

> > Great Master? I think that they're both wonderul

> > books.

> >

> > Warmest regards,

> >

> > michael

> >

> > --- Emanuele De Benedetti <e.debenedetti@t...>

> > wrote:

> > > Thanks everybody

> > >

> > > and particularly Mazie for the gorgeous Kalis.

> > >

> > > A realized being suggested me to read the book:

> > >

> > > "Kali's child. The mystical and the Erotic in the

> > > Life and teachings of Ramakrishna"

> > >

> > > I am a little hesitant, though I will do it,

> > > trusting where the suggestion comes from.

> > >

> > > Anybody knows this book?

> > >

> > > in love

> > > marifa

>

>

>

>

> /join

>

>

>

>

>

> "Love itself is the actual form of God."

>

> Sri Ramana

>

> In "Letters from Sri Ramanasramam" by Suri Nagamma

> Links

>

>

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Dear Adi and Warwick,

 

 

--- adi_shakthi16 <adi_shakthi16 wrote:

> dear warwick,

>

> it is not so much the fact that hindus are against

> 'gays' but Shri

> Ramakrishna is supposed to be a saint and ,devout

> hindus are not

> interested in discussing his sexual orientation

 

SNIP

 

Yes, I agree, the discussion of sexual orientation

need not be a part of transcendental philosophy and

discussion.

 

Warmest regards,

 

michael bowes

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

dear heart,

 

i have to state certain inaccuracies in your post...

 

you write ...

 

"My guess is that the book mantains that > Ramakrishna ecstasies were

often triggered by the proximity of > a close disciple. And there was

contact with his feet, or arms.

This doesn't mean that he was openly homosexual, and not even

conscious > of any tendency."

 

it is guess, i am afraid ...

 

i read the book long time ago and then i prohibited my son from

reading it...

 

Jerey kripal accuses Shri ramakrishna o 'playing' with young boys and

his attraction for them.

 

he also acxcuses Shriramakrishna of having 'sexual' feelings for his

disciple narendra, swami vivekananda

 

also, Shri ramakrishna often used to dress up in a gopi bhava like a

woman and act, walk and talk like a woman ... aTHIS WAS BECAUSE SHRI

RAMAKRSIHNAwanted to experience the 'madhura' bhava of the Gopis- and

Kripaul accused shri ramakrishna of 'cross dressing' and quoted this

to prove that the saint had homosexual tendencies

 

elsewhere in the book it was mentioned Shri Ramakrishna was so

attractive as a child , he was molested by women... all stories!

 

you state

> and Ramakrishna had also a very good Tantra training with an

enlightened woman.

 

yes, his tantrik guru was a woman named Brahmani Bhairavi ... but

ramakrishna practiced all the pancha makara sadhana with her

except "maithuna" -sexual intercourse

 

to have a female guru is considered the highest in tantra...

 

 

you go on to say

>> What is important for a seeker of Truth is to seek Truth at any

cost,

> I don't think that a possible hidden homosexuality in Ramaksrihna

> can diminish his giant stature of Kali's devotee.

> Few years ago I had been reading, for almost two years continuosly,

his> gospels,

> and it is the maximum in devotion, but also there is a deep

understanding of> non-duality.

> Can homosexuality diminish my love and respect for such a being?

 

no not at all

 

but the point is Shri ramakrishna transcended all sexuality,

homosexuality, hetrosexuality and bisexuality ....

 

so, why say something that is not true ...

 

it is like saying the Pope slept with madonna ! smiles ! that will a

good advertisement for madonna but bad for the Vatican! smiles,

again!

 

Dear heart, it is not about hindus or christians

 

how many will like to see or hear about this

 

that jesus christ and mary magdelene had something going?

 

christians will say we are being blasphemous ...

 

and GOddess can be worshipped in the 'vira' bhava which is unique to

hinduism... here only such tantriks who have conquered all pashu

bhava (lower animal nature) can worship goddess approaching her as a

lover using the pancha makara sadhana ( including erotic rituals)

 

it is hinduism which has given the world a book called Yoni Tantra (

yoni means -vagina)

 

take care

 

love and ((((((((((((((hugs))))))))))))))

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Dear friends in the Sangha:

 

I recall reading the Gospel of Ramakrishna but have not read this latest book

that is Adiji is commenting on.

 

Thank you to Sri Adishaktiji for bringing light to this topic and sangha. Her

knowledge of various scriptures and different philosophies and her commentary is

always enlightening.

 

I wanted to mention to the Sangha, that in the next volume of HS will focus very

heavily on yoga and tantra and the learned members such as Adiji and others

should consider contributing.

 

We have amassed an incredibly talented team of international editors for the

next volume and the plans are now moving forward for a ground breaking new

volume which will carry us forward.

 

I have been busy lately and unable to fully participate in the conversations but

am trying to read most of the posts. Some are really enjoyable.

 

As a cautionary note, please don't use the sangha to advocate political views,

advertise professional services, or post complete conversations you might have

had with someone to demonstrate your wisdom (Bindu, are you listening :-).

 

Long time members of Sangha have more discretion to bend the rules, but let's

not bend them too much :-).

 

Love to all

Harsha

 

 

 

 

> "adi_shakthi16" <adi_shakthi16

> 2004/04/13 Tue AM 11:21:42 EDT

>

> Re: Kali--Ramakrishna

 

 

dear heart,

 

and GOddess can be worshipped in the 'vira' bhava which is unique to hinduism...

here only such tantriks who have conquered all pashu bhava (lower animal nature)

can worship goddess approaching her as a lover using the pancha makara sadhana (

including erotic rituals)

 

it is hinduism which has given the world a book called Yoni Tantra ( yoni means

-vagina)

dear heart,

i have to state certain inaccuracies in your post...

you write ...

"My guess is that the book mantains that > Ramakrishna ecstasies were

often triggered by the proximity of > a close disciple. And there was

contact with his feet, or arms.

This doesn't mean that he was openly homosexual, and not even

conscious > of any tendency."

it is guess, i am afraid ...

i read the book long time ago and then i prohibited my son from

reading it...

Jerey kripal accuses Shri ramakrishna o 'playing' with young boys and

his attraction for them.

he also acxcuses Shriramakrishna of having 'sexual' feelings for his

disciple narendra, swami vivekananda

also, Shri ramakrishna often used to dress up in a gopi bhava like a

woman and act, walk and talk like a woman ... aTHIS WAS BECAUSE SHRI

RAMAKRSIHNAwanted to experience the 'madhura' bhava of the Gopis- and

Kripaul accused shri ramakrishna of 'cross dressing' and quoted this

to prove that the saint had homosexual tendencies

elsewhere in the book it was mentioned Shri Ramakrishna was so

attractive as a child , he was molested by women... all stories!

you state

> and Ramakrishna had also a very good Tantra training with an

enlightened woman.

yes, his tantrik guru was a woman named Brahmani Bhairavi ... but

ramakrishna practiced all the pancha makara sadhana with her

except "maithuna" -sexual intercourse

to have a female guru is considered the highest in tantra...

you go on to say

>> What is important for a seeker of Truth is to seek Truth at any

cost,

> I don't think that a possible hidden homosexuality in Ramaksrihna

> can diminish his giant stature of Kali's devotee.

> Few years ago I had been reading, for almost two years continuosly,

his> gospels,

> and it is the maximum in devotion, but also there is a deep

understanding of> non-duality.

> Can homosexuality diminish my love and respect for such a being?

no not at all

but the point is Shri ramakrishna transcended all sexuality,

homosexuality, hetrosexuality and bisexuality ....

so, why say something that is not true ...

it is like saying the Pope slept with madonna ! smiles ! that will a

good advertisement for madonna but bad for the Vatican! smiles,

again!

Dear heart, it is not about hindus or christians

how many will like to see or hear about this

that jesus christ and mary magdelene had something going?

christians will say we are being blasphemous ...

and GOddess can be worshipped in the 'vira' bhava which is unique to

hinduism... here only such tantriks who have conquered all pashu

bhava (lower animal nature) can worship goddess approaching her as a

lover using the pancha makara sadhana ( including erotic rituals)

it is hinduism which has given the world a book called Yoni Tantra (

yoni means -vagina)

take care

love and ((((((((((((((hugs))))))))))))))

/join

 

"Love itself is the actual form of God."

Sri Ramana

In "Letters from Sri Ramanasramam" by Suri Nagamma

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

harshaji ,

 

you did not miss a 'thing'

 

Enlightened persons like you will consider such books as 'thrash'

 

you praise me too much... i am not all that 'great' ... very siinmple

minded like simple simon! smiles !

 

"This is my simple religion. There is no need for temples; no need

for complicated philosophy. Our own brain, our own heart is our

temple; the philosophy is kindness." Dalai Lama

 

in loving kindness

 

ur friend

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Dear sir,

It is really heart rending to read this kind of posts.

Hey man why do you always think of sex and other negative things when

there are so many things other this could be learned.

There is a saying, when one has Yellow Jaundice the world looks yellow to him!

Ignore others fallicies try yourself to acheive the ultimate.

That great saint has already attained the ultimate,why speculate which you and I dont know.

Now it is your and my turn to attain the same,strive for it,dont get

sidelined by unnecessary things.

A mountain cannot be ashamed even if thousand dogs bark at him.With

best

regards,V.Rajnikanth.yogi_r (AT) eth (DOT) netyogi_or (AT) hotmail (DOT) comyogi_or (AT) (DOT) co.inefax

: 17734396237

-

adi_shakthi16

Tuesday, April 13, 2004 8:51 PM

Re: Kali--Ramakrishna

dear heart, i have to state certain inaccuracies in your post... you

write ... "My guess is that the book mantains that > Ramakrishna

ecstasies were often triggered by the proximity of > a close

disciple. And there was contact with his feet, or arms.This doesn't

mean that he was openly homosexual, and not even conscious > of any

tendency."it is guess, i am afraid ... i read the book long time ago

and then i prohibited my son from reading it... Jerey kripal accuses

Shri ramakrishna o 'playing' with young boys and his attraction for

them. he also acxcuses Shriramakrishna of having 'sexual' feelings

for his disciple narendra, swami vivekananda also, Shri ramakrishna

often used to dress up in a gopi bhava like a woman and act, walk and

talk like a woman ... aTHIS WAS BECAUSE SHRI RAMAKRSIHNAwanted to

experience the 'madhura' bhava of the Gopis- and Kripaul accused shri

ramakrishna of 'cross dressing' and quoted this to prove that the

saint had homosexual tendencies elsewhere in the book it was

mentioned Shri Ramakrishna was so attractive as a child , he was

molested by women... all stories! you state > and Ramakrishna had

also a very good Tantra training with an enlightened woman.yes, his

tantrik guru was a woman named Brahmani Bhairavi ... but ramakrishna

practiced all the pancha makara sadhana with her except "maithuna"

-sexual intercourse to have a female guru is considered the highest

in tantra... you go on to say >> What is important for a seeker of

Truth is to seek Truth at any cost,> I don't think that a possible

hidden homosexuality in Ramaksrihna> can diminish his giant stature

of Kali's devotee.> Few years ago I had been reading, for almost two

years continuosly, his> gospels,> and it is the maximum in devotion,

but also there is a deep understanding of> non-duality.> Can

homosexuality diminish my love and respect for such a being?no not at

all but the point is Shri ramakrishna transcended all sexuality,

homosexuality, hetrosexuality and bisexuality .... so, why say

something that is not true ... it is like saying the Pope slept with

madonna ! smiles ! that will a good advertisement for madonna but bad

for the Vatican! smiles, again! Dear heart, it is not about hindus or

christians how many will like to see or hear about this that jesus

christ and mary magdelene had something going? christians will say we

are being blasphemous ... and GOddess can be worshipped in the 'vira'

bhava which is unique to hinduism... here only such tantriks who have

conquered all pashu bhava (lower animal nature) can worship goddess

approaching her as a lover using the pancha makara sadhana (

including erotic rituals) it is hinduism which has given the world a

book called Yoni Tantra ( yoni means -vagina) take care love and

((((((((((((((hugs))))))))))))))/join

"Love itself is

the actual form of God."Sri RamanaIn "Letters from Sri Ramanasramam"

by Suri Nagamma

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

, "Emanuele De Benedetti"

<e.debenedetti@t...> wrote:

> From what I have read in the introduction,

> the book is not necesseraly accusatory, in a moralistic way,

> of Ramakrishna. My guess is that the book mantains that

> Ramakrishna ecstasies were often triggered by the proximity of

> a close disciple. And there was contact with his feet, or arms.

> This doesn't mean that he was openly homosexual, and not even

conscious

> of any tendency.

> As we all know the energy due to difference in polarity, if

properly

> channeled, can be used to reach higher states of consciousness,

> and Ramakrishna had also a very good Tantra training with an

enlightened

> woman.

> (more after I have read it)

 

Namaste,

 

There was a period in Ramakrishna's life when a certain behaviour

was preventing him from having visions of Kali. Once the behaviour

stopped the visions came back. It was my guess it had something to

do with some behaviour in the tantra..............ONS..Tony.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Dear Adishakti,

thanks for your loving answer.

 

As I said before, I wouldn't have choosen to read such a book,

but a realised being, with whom I am e-mail and consciousness

connected suggested me to do it saying that the book was scholarly

but with some deep intuition about the life of Ramakrishna.

As this is the only suggestion he gave me when I asked him

about non duality and ecstasy, I will read the book open

to whatever insight might come.

 

Thank you again to have received my letter

with such deep peacefulness.

 

in love

marifa

 

 

-

"adi_shakthi16" <adi_shakthi16

<>

Tuesday, April 13, 2004 5:21 PM

Re: Kali--Ramakrishna

 

> dear heart,

>

> i have to state certain inaccuracies in your post...

>

> you write ...

>

> "My guess is that the book mantains that > Ramakrishna ecstasies were

> often triggered by the proximity of > a close disciple. And there was

> contact with his feet, or arms.

> This doesn't mean that he was openly homosexual, and not even

> conscious > of any tendency."

>

> it is guess, i am afraid ...

>

> i read the book long time ago and then i prohibited my son from

> reading it...

>

> Jerey kripal accuses Shri ramakrishna o 'playing' with young boys and

> his attraction for them.

>

> he also acxcuses Shriramakrishna of having 'sexual' feelings for his

> disciple narendra, swami vivekananda

>

> also, Shri ramakrishna often used to dress up in a gopi bhava like a

> woman and act, walk and talk like a woman ... aTHIS WAS BECAUSE SHRI

> RAMAKRSIHNAwanted to experience the 'madhura' bhava of the Gopis- and

> Kripaul accused shri ramakrishna of 'cross dressing' and quoted this

> to prove that the saint had homosexual tendencies

>

> elsewhere in the book it was mentioned Shri Ramakrishna was so

> attractive as a child , he was molested by women... all stories!

>

> you state

>

> > and Ramakrishna had also a very good Tantra training with an

> enlightened woman.

>

> yes, his tantrik guru was a woman named Brahmani Bhairavi ... but

> ramakrishna practiced all the pancha makara sadhana with her

> except "maithuna" -sexual intercourse

>

> to have a female guru is considered the highest in tantra...

>

>

> you go on to say

>

> >> What is important for a seeker of Truth is to seek Truth at any

> cost,

> > I don't think that a possible hidden homosexuality in Ramaksrihna

> > can diminish his giant stature of Kali's devotee.

> > Few years ago I had been reading, for almost two years continuosly,

> his> gospels,

> > and it is the maximum in devotion, but also there is a deep

> understanding of> non-duality.

> > Can homosexuality diminish my love and respect for such a being?

>

> no not at all

>

> but the point is Shri ramakrishna transcended all sexuality,

> homosexuality, hetrosexuality and bisexuality ....

>

> so, why say something that is not true ...

>

> it is like saying the Pope slept with madonna ! smiles ! that will a

> good advertisement for madonna but bad for the Vatican! smiles,

> again!

>

> Dear heart, it is not about hindus or christians

>

> how many will like to see or hear about this

>

> that jesus christ and mary magdelene had something going?

>

> christians will say we are being blasphemous ...

>

> and GOddess can be worshipped in the 'vira' bhava which is unique to

> hinduism... here only such tantriks who have conquered all pashu

> bhava (lower animal nature) can worship goddess approaching her as a

> lover using the pancha makara sadhana ( including erotic rituals)

>

> it is hinduism which has given the world a book called Yoni Tantra (

> yoni means -vagina)

>

> take care

>

> love and ((((((((((((((hugs))))))))))))))

>

>

>

> /join

>

>

>

>

>

> "Love itself is the actual form of God."

>

> Sri Ramana

>

> In "Letters from Sri Ramanasramam" by Suri Nagamma

> Links

>

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

yogi_or writes ...

 

"why do you always think of sex and other negative things when there

are so many things other this could be learned."

 

sir, with all due respects to you, we are here discussing only the

contents of Jeffrey kirpal's book and i am in no way defending the

contents of the book .

 

It is well known Shri Ramakrishna was (is) a great saint.

 

Thank you sir for reminding us of this fact.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...