Guest guest Posted July 18, 2004 Report Share Posted July 18, 2004 I had recently posted the first link below as an email only. I went back and turned it into a webpage with my own layout. I also discovered that there are five parts in total to Chhaganlal's story. Part II is also posted in the link below. To be continued :-) http://www.omshaantih.com/Ramana/Stories/Chhaganlal%20Yogi/I.htm http://www.omshaantih.com/Ramana/Stories/Chhaganlal%20Yogi/II.htm Love, Joyce Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 19, 2004 Report Share Posted July 19, 2004 Dear Lady Joycewhat a joy this early morning thru your wonderful effort please feel embraced with a huge smile of inner happiness yours Michael >"Lady Joyce" <shaantih (AT) comcast (DOT) net> > >To: <> > Chhaganlal Yogi...How the Maharshi Came to Me...Part II >Sun, 18 Jul 2004 21:53:27 -0400 > >I had recently posted the first link below as an email only. >I went back and turned it into a webpage with my own layout. >I also discovered that there are five parts in total to Chhaganlal's story. >Part II is also posted in the link below. To be continued :-) > >http://www.omshaantih.com/Ramana/Stories/Chhaganlal%20Yogi/I.htm > >http://www.omshaantih.com/Ramana/Stories/Chhaganlal%20Yogi/II.htm > >Love, > >Joyce > > > > > > > Add photos to your e-mail with MSN 8. Get 2 months FREE*. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 19, 2004 Report Share Posted July 19, 2004 Thanks ! for sharing the experiences of Chhaganlal Yogi. But not able to understand the emotional feelings I experience while reading...........perhaps still I have to go a long way to properly comprehend the 'Advaita' philosophy. Love & Om Lady Joyce <shaantih (AT) comcast (DOT) net> wrote: I had recently posted the first link below as an email only. I went back and turned it into a webpage with my own layout. I also discovered that there are five parts in total to Chhaganlal's story. Part II is also posted in the link below. To be continued :-) http://www.omshaantih.com/Ramana/Stories/Chhaganlal%20Yogi/I.htm http://www.omshaantih.com/Ramana/Stories/Chhaganlal%20Yogi/II.htm Love, Joyce Post message: RamanaMaharshi Subscribe: RamanaMaharshi- Un: RamanaMaharshi List owner: RamanaMaharshi-ownerShortcut URL to this page: http://www./community/RamanaMaharshi India Careers: Over 65,000 jobs online. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 19, 2004 Report Share Posted July 19, 2004 Harshaji, in another thread of the same cloth, wrote: Even surrender is not possible by self-effort but comes to the devotee only due to grace of Bhagavan. All is Grace. Doraji wrote: Dear Joyce, Thanks ! for sharing the experiences of Chhaganlal Yogi. But not able to understand the emotional feelings I experience while reading...........perhaps still I have to go a long way to properly comprehend the 'Advaita' philosophy. Love & Om Dear Doraji: Perhaps it is by Grace that you are already there :-) Love, Joyce Lady Joyce <shaantih (AT) comcast (DOT) net> wrote: I had recently posted the first link below as an email only. I went back and turned it into a webpage with my own layout. I also discovered that there are five parts in total to Chhaganlal's story. Part II is also posted in the link below. To be continued :-) http://www.omshaantih.com/Ramana/Stories/Chhaganlal%20Yogi/I.htm http://www.omshaantih.com/Ramana/Stories/Chhaganlal%20Yogi/II.htm Love, Joyce Post message: RamanaMaharshi Subscribe: RamanaMaharshi- Un: RamanaMaharshi List owner: RamanaMaharshi-ownerShortcut URL to this page: http://www./community/RamanaMaharshi India Careers: Over 65,000 jobs online. Post message: RamanaMaharshi Subscribe: RamanaMaharshi- Un: RamanaMaharshi List owner: RamanaMaharshi-ownerShortcut URL to this page: http://www./community/RamanaMaharshi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 19, 2004 Report Share Posted July 19, 2004 yes, even surrennder is possible only because of the Grace... for me, it is like this: the free-will we seem to have is like the free-will of a dream character in your dream; say, you dream tonight that you are in a cinema house watching a movie with 100's of people, if the person next to you takes a mobile phone call annoying you in a loud voice and you object to it and he says: "its my cell phone, when I get a call I attend to it, what's your problem?"; you show him a face that conveys disgust and he slaps you, and..... you wake up... now, after you woke up what happened to the person with the cell? gone.... say you remember the person/incident somewhat even after waking up, and you describe it to your friend who is argumentative by nature.....; what if the friend (in your waking state) says that the dream person was right in slapping you ? would you get angry? you would simply brush it aside "hey the whole thing was a dream, the cell phone nagger does not exist, so why bother?" so in this 'dream' called 'our life', the free-will is apparent and appears "very real" only to the 'dreamer' but he/she (the dreamer) is very bound and programmed by the 'waker' to think/behave in a particular way and they just think and do based on the programming.... of course, you may say 'life is not a dream because everything is real here; I have a body, I have emotions/feelings' etc.; also you may say 'if that was the case, how come my dream (of this life) is same as my friend's dream (of his/her life)'; meaning you would ask : 'how come two lives (which Murthy is saying are 'dreams') coincide with each other and the characters are all same)? we don't see that happening in our regular night-time dream.. that is because in the dream of life, the waker is 'only one'; It (this singular 'waker') is dreaming as several different microcosmic dreamers and each dreamer is producing their own environment (for ex. I am born in India whereas John is born in England) based on their own 'conditioning'; so when each apparent microcosmic 'dreamer' wakes up, then they get to know for themselves that they are nothing but the 'singular waker' who is dreaming all the dreams... the key is for the 'dreamer' to know he or she is indeed the 'waker' while still in 'one such' dream.... that is why those who have "woken up" while still continuing in the dream, like Shri. Bhagavan, keep repeating the same think to us, the other dream characters: 'hey, wake up, you are in a dream, you don't exist as the dreamer it is just illusory existence, you exist only as the waker, so wake up'; but since we are bound, we think He is talking about some esoterical abstract concept that is irrelevant for us and continue like robots in this 'programmed dream' and get to 'sleep' eventually (which is nothing but dying) till we get to another 'dream' life....; note that, in general, like we don't carry memory from one regular night-time dream to another regular night-time dream we don't have memory continuing from one life to another... one who has understood (even just intellectually) that he/she is bound is blessed; their understanding will lead them to 'give up', 'let go', "put the burden on the 'waker' and just be thankful" (this is what is Bhakthi, isn't it?), "feel insiginificant" and in general, in advanced stages, "act mad" from a bound person's viewpoint but ultimately he/she will vanish into nothing and they will know first-hand the "waker"'s moves while still in the dream...and It (the waker) will have taken over openly (It always had control but now it is in the open bcoz the dreamer does not exist).... and of course, the other one who thinks that he is "free" is bound seemingly eternally, till they come to a stage when they understand (yes, only intellectually at this stage) that they are indeed bound; this happens when after many lives (dreams) of generally 'happy' events, in some lives (dreams) the dreamer sees nothing happening alright even if they use their free-will, things becoming miserable day-by-day or they are simply not satisfied with the results and go for more and more and get tired ... thanks Murthy RamanaMaharshi, "Lady Joyce" <shaantih@c...> wrote: > Harshaji, in another thread of the same cloth, wrote: > > Even surrender is not possible by self-effort but comes > to the devotee only due to grace of Bhagavan. All is Grace. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2004 Report Share Posted July 20, 2004 RamanaMaharshi, "manof678" <manof678> wrote: > yes, even surrennder is possible only because of the Grace... > > for me, it is like this: > > the free-will we seem to have is like the free-will of a dream > character in your dream; > Namaste M, First of all it seems that `all', is actually mind. Sakti is mind, Mahat is mind, so really apart from individual thoughts, all is thought. The projected appearance of Saguna Brahman. In the first place all is a dream and an illusion , and we are operating at two levels, relative and absolute. Also there are the constituents of the dream to consider. If we take Einstein and relativity etc, then physically there is no time, beyond the speed of light. (In fact quarks and sub-atomic particles travel back in time.) This is Kala or time, and God is Kala or Time. So Time itself is an illusion and doesn't exist really. It is all a dream of the concept "God". So in this dream everything is really happening at the same time, it is just the play of consciousness that gives the illusion of progression and time. It is like lives, they are like a cartwheel and the lives are the spokes. Consciousness is the hub, and we concentrate consciousness on one spoke at a time, hence lives, but they all happen at once! However because consciousness has become associated with the illusion it has to free itself with free will. This entails taking responsibility for our actions , as if we were making things happen. It is said that we see our future life before taking birth, so everything that is going to happen has happened or rather is happening. So at birth a veil is drawn over our consciousness, so to speak and then we have to literally, "Act out ", the drama, as if we are making decisions , that effect a really non-existent future. So in fact when we ponder over a decision and them make it, that was the decision we had already made anyway. There was just the illusion that we were making it, so that we could take responsibility for it and learn. Learn what? Learn that we are part of a dream! So the illusion of experiencing causes pain etc and eventually the "Consciousness Realises this and wakes up------Liberated". However as Sankara says it is real enough whilst you are in it. This is where karma comes into play for at this level of relativity there is the law of "action and reaction ", that keeps the illusion going so to speak. Until you realise you are God and it is all a dream. "Understand there is no free will for individuals. They are constrained by various limitations. God alone has total free will. All others are bound in one way or another. Whatever one's efforts ,the ultimate outcome lies with Providence. ........ONS.. Tony. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2004 Report Share Posted July 20, 2004 Dear Tony, yes time and space do not have reality 'truely' just like how it is in our day-to-day dream phenomenon; when we dream, our dream events might happen in a huge space and in a time-based sequence and the dream characters (including the dreamer) may feel both the dimensions to be 'very real' within the dream, but once woken up, the waker (who is the same as the dreamer) would know that nothing ever happened and whatever was imagined as happened did so completely in the waker's mind instantaneously and hence was not in space or time... one anology in day-to-day life one can think of is mono-acting play in which the same person writes the story, script, arranges the light/background/settings/audio, acts out all roles; this person is kind of equivalent to an 'enlightened person' because at any given time within the play they know they are actually NOT the character, they know what is going to happen next, they know who is the controller of 'all this' and they know 'who they really are'; only thing is they are playing out only one character at any given time...lol in fact, such a creative person would have mostly 'dreamed up the whole thing in their head at least vaguely' before they committed the script/story/details to paper and then to 'actuality' in the physical world.... all this may sound intellectual discussion, but to me, clearer this understanding becomes based on one's own self inference, the better they can 'take things easily' in life (though remaining sincere in what one does and how they do, but not get affected much by the results) and pursue after whatever is 'real' based on their 'inference'.... of course, the waker should have 'programmed' such a pursuit for 'this dream character' in this dream itself, otherwise why would dreamers identified as Murthy and Tony be discussing this... thanks Murthy RamanaMaharshi, "Tony OClery" <aoclery> wrote: > RamanaMaharshi, "manof678" <manof678> > wrote: > > yes, even surrennder is possible only because of the Grace... > > > > for me, it is like this: > > > > the free-will we seem to have is like the free-will of a dream > > character in your dream; > > > > Namaste M, > > First of all it seems that `all', is actually mind. Sakti is mind, > Mahat is mind, so really apart from individual thoughts, all is > thought. The projected appearance of Saguna Brahman. > > In the first place all is a dream and an illusion , and we are > operating at two levels, relative and absolute. Also there are the > constituents of the dream to consider. If we take Einstein and > relativity etc, then physically there is no time, beyond the speed > of light. (In fact quarks and sub-atomic particles travel back in > time.) > > This is Kala or time, and God is Kala or Time. So Time itself is an > illusion and doesn't > > exist really. It is all a dream of the concept "God". So in this > dream everything is really happening at the same time, it is just the > > play of consciousness that gives the illusion of progression and > time. It is like lives, they are like a cartwheel and the lives are > the > > spokes. Consciousness is the hub, and we concentrate consciousness > on one spoke at a time, hence lives, but they all happen at > > once! However because consciousness has become associated with the > illusion it has to free itself with free will. > > This entails taking > > responsibility for our actions , as if we were making things happen. > It is said that we see our future life before taking birth, so > > everything that is going to happen has happened or rather is > happening. So at birth a veil is drawn over our consciousness, so to > > speak and then we have to literally, "Act out ", the drama, as if we > are making decisions , that effect a really non-existent future. > > So in fact when we ponder over a decision and them make it, that was > the decision we had already made anyway. There was just > the illusion that we were making it, so that we could take > responsibility for it and learn. Learn what? Learn that we are part > of a dream! > > So the illusion of experiencing causes pain etc and eventually > the "Consciousness Realises this and wakes > > up------Liberated". However as Sankara says it is real enough whilst > you are in it. This is where karma comes into play for at this > > level of relativity there is the law of "action and reaction ", that > keeps the illusion going so to speak. Until you realise you are God > > and it is all a dream. "Understand there is no free will for > individuals. They are constrained by various limitations. God alone > has > > total free will. All others are bound in one way or another. > Whatever one's efforts ,the ultimate outcome lies with Providence. > > .......ONS.. Tony. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.