Guest guest Posted November 24, 2005 Report Share Posted November 24, 2005 , zen2wrk@a... wrote: > > > In a message dated 11/24/2005 4:13:43 P.M. Pacific Standard Time, > aoclery writes: > > I am not saying that meat eaters aren't on the path, what I am > saying is that it is against Ahimsa and Daya for animals, therefore > is a desire samskara to be purified. > > The DL may or may not be more advanced than I am, but in the end we > still have to purify the Buddhi. > > > > What is against ahimsa is to create suffering for others, animal or human. > The Jains understand and wisely teach this, and most of course, as you would > suggest, choose not to eat meat in order to avoid that added > complication...but they are not absolutists, they know that at times, regrettably, one has to > do things in order to choose a path that provides for survival, health, and > balance. If your crops are all going to be destroyed by locusts, despite > Ahimsa, the Jains do not believe in infinite mercy toward the locusts, but will > light fires to ward them off and yes, to kill them. During times of famine, > Jains will also even consume locusts, if need be to survive. They realize > that each day, tiny insects and organisms are destroyed just by their act of > breathing, walking and other activities. They understand that to exist, a > larger creature necessarily is imperfect and will harm, through no voluntary > action untold millions of lesser creatures. We should not increase the suffering > of other beings, nor should we unduly produce suffering in other family > members or ourselves. That too, violates Ahimsa. We cannot consider ourselves > enlightened beings if we protect all other living things but punish ourselves. > > Purification? That is a loaded concept, because it implies that we are > somehow contaminated to begin with. I would prefer to think that we arrive at a > state of clear headed, dispassionate enlightenment that also has room for > love, mercy, joy and bliss. If we take all the pleasures out of our heaven, I > believe that we can safely rename it "Hell." > > Cheers, > > ZB Namaste, I'm not Jain although I did study them at university. We can only do our best....We are contaminated with samskaras.Desire and lack of awareness which in many cases is just ego of desire.........ONS...Tony. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 24, 2005 Report Share Posted November 24, 2005 In a message dated 11/24/2005 6:44:28 P.M. Pacific Standard Time, aoclery writes: We are contaminated with samskaras.Desire and lack of awareness which in many cases is just ego of desire....... This is not a "contamination," Tony, this is the spark that ignites the fuel that burns in the engines of our very Dharma. We burn this, we test this, we are challenged by this in order to find the truth, to go beyond our seeming limitations and to grow spiritually. If we were all hatched fully-achieved into the world like some sort of cosmic turkey of grace, then we would need do nothing at all, nor would we understand anything from the level of being -- all would be in a static state of endless bliss...and for turkeys, this may in fact be their reality, so much so that their deaths in honor of our Pilgrim holidays may not bother them at all. Perhaps they are the fully realized ones, after all. Did you know that a turkey lived for almost a year after its head had been removed in an accident, and the owner fed the bird via the neck with a syringe of broth? Is that unbelievable? What does that teach us? Well, it suggests that turkeys do not need much intellect to function, and that maybe consciousness resides in places in the body other than in the brain. I have often suspected as much from my conversations with certain conservative political and religious types, I am afraid. Cheers, Zenbob PS, I am not a farmer, Tony. I have a small 10 acre ranch, and none of the animals on it are raised for food. They are raised for fleece, never harmed. Oh, I do have chickens, but I only use their unborn innocent potential children for food, and then, I swear, only as necessary meal ingredients and never to mock their aspirations of Poultry Motherhood. ZB Change Your Life.... www.igonet.com/zencommunications Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 24, 2005 Report Share Posted November 24, 2005 In a message dated 11/24/2005 7:40:29 P.M. Pacific Standard Time, baba108 (AT) hotmail (DOT) com writes: who are we to judge anybodya young man once urinated on Bhagavan Ramana MaharshiBhagavan said not one wordMay God Grant Me such GraceJai BhagavanLove baba Ah, so very true! Of course, Bhagavan may merely have been speechless with shock, as even someone as verbose as I would be challenged to find my tongue at a moment such as that. Maybe he discussed it the next day? OM, Peace, Zenbob Change Your Life.... www.igonet.com/zencommunications Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 24, 2005 Report Share Posted November 24, 2005 That may all be true an noble.. but the assertion that a person > who eats meat cannot be enlightened does not follow. > > > > Sam > > Namaste, > > Sure it does, it shows a violation of Ahimsa and no Daya or > compassion for the animals etc. > > The only person who can eat meat, in that context, is one who is > already Realised and just eats whatever is put in his bowl, with no > desire/attachment or a lack of awareness of the fact the animal was > tortured and killed. > > I'm not saying all who eat meat aren't on the path, I'm just saying > they haven't developed Daya as yet, which is a requirement for > Moksha...Tony. > Jayas tu paandu pudarnam, yashaam pakshe Janardhanah .... Personals Single? There's someone we'd like you to meet. Lot's of someone's, actually. Try Personals Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 24, 2005 Report Share Posted November 24, 2005 Should a person stranded on an > island never eat meat to survive because they have once chosen to not eat > meat for spiritual reasons? What if the life of a child or children were at > stake? > > We have a name for people who must be totally 100% consistent under all > times and conditions. Oh, and it's not "enlightened being," it's "foolish." > > Zenbob Namaste, It is difficult to talk to a farmer and meat eater about this as we have found before. A person an a desert island is just a 'red herring' the circumstances are different. Some primitive humans kill and eat meat according to custom, to survive...I know that. I have also gleaned from the Vedanta that one desire only is enough to prevent Moksha. The Buddhi has to be purified, we are all working on it. I am not saying that meat eaters aren't on the path, what I am saying is that it is against Ahimsa and Daya for animals, therefore is a desire samskara to be purified. The DL may or may not be more advanced than I am, but in the end we still have to purify the Buddhi. http://www.geocities.com/aoclery/AVEGETARIANandAHIMSA.htm ONS...Tony. Jayas tu paandu pudarnam, yashaam pakshe Janardhanah ..... Music Unlimited - Access over 1 million songs. Try it free. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 24, 2005 Report Share Posted November 24, 2005 Sri Janaardana Kalianandaswami wrote: Hari Om as a strict vegetarian I find that judging anyone on their diet is completely revolting what Lord Buddha of Compassion eats is His business and none of mine the first Buddha died from eating rotten pork who are we to judge anybody a young man once urinated on Bhagavan Ramana Maharshi Bhagavan said not one word I don't know that story. Could you please give the source? There is a story of thieves breaking into Ramanashram. Sri Ramana got some blows as well with sticks on his legs. Later he said in humor that he had been paid proper respect using the term with the double meaning. Puja (worship) in Hindi can have a double meaning as well depending on the context of the situation. Now what is this story of someone urinating on Sri Ramana's legs. I have not heard this story at all. Please do relate that and the source. Thanks. Love to all Harsha May God Grant Me such Grace Jai Bhagavan Love baba Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 25, 2005 Report Share Posted November 25, 2005 Sri Janaardana Kalianandaswami wrote: Hari Om as a strict vegetarian I find that judging anyone on their diet is completely revolting what Lord Buddha of Compassion eats is His business and none of mine the first Buddha died from eating rotten pork That regards a metaphor on the dissolution of afflictions (physical pain the last one) and isn't to be taken literally. who are we to judge anybody There are no others. a young man once urinated on Bhagavan Ramana Maharshi Bhagavan said not one word Urine happens to be sterile until it has left the bladder. In that sense it might be cleaner than the water from many rivers. May God Grant Me such Grace Jai Bhagavan Love baba It's easy, don't blame and there's nothing to forgive. When that fails, remember "there are no others". Jan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 25, 2005 Report Share Posted November 25, 2005 panamavolcan wrote: real Dear Jan, Gosh your format or the format is really messed up had to go for miles to read your post.. Most posts written from the interface get messy as the automatic text wrap function is used, and replying to them, the formatting only gets messier. Please get knowledgeable in these elementary matters. Jan waht you say makes no sense to me at all..yes everything including this body is not real and of course if you just stop eating the not real body will die and your point is.. my point simply is the idea that you can get there from here when your already there?? One consequence of the axiom that the mind & body are unreal is that whatever such an unreal structure produces, is unreal too. That was the point, perhaps it's clearer now. Jan Randy Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.