Guest guest Posted November 5, 2002 Report Share Posted November 5, 2002 Our devi_bhakta never ceases to amaze me! week after week he introduces such wonderful topics - this week he has chosen ' tamizh' thai' Tamil as mother goddess!!! now, members may ask and wonder how can a language be regarded as a 'goddess' ... a poet (bharatidasan) sings... Language is breath Language is consciousness Language is life .................. language is world without language, who are we? REALLY, Who ARE WE? it is our language that defines us... when you ask a tamilian who is he? he will not say - i am an indian or a hindu - he will say I am a tamilian- such is his 'passion' and 'devoti0on' to his mother tongue!! i I recall very vividly a incident that occured in my life while i was in new delhi india several years ago... the census LADY had come to our house to do an interview.... after asking the usual questions- how many people in the household, the gender of each of my children , husband's salary ( i was a full time mom and a householder at that time-) my religionon etc.... she came to the most difficult question of all - " madam, what is your mother tongue? " i was speechless for one whole minute---- now, pray , what is my mother tongue? i asked myself? well, my dad is a die-hard tamilian being born in erode and educated in chennai, tamizhnadu .... he spoke pure, chaste tamil...my mother, although a tamilian , was born and brought up in new delhi under the british raj- my grand dad was a lawyer in the high court in the british raj- my mom attended a convent- st.thomas school - she spoke fluent english and was well-versed in hindi? but, tamil- her tamil was just like my dad's hindi - that bad!! smiles.... and i, cannot call 'tamil' my mother tongue ! technically, it was but in reality it was not as parents always conversed in english- only when they had argumments -they will swear at each other in their respective languages!!! so, i was very embarassed and with great difficulty i said rather unconvincingly my mother tongue is tamil!!! it was then that i decided to learn Tamizh if not master it!!! no doubt, it is a hard language - grammar is as complicated as the japanese language- sounds as guttral as dutch - but is very romantic and poetic like french if you know the real 'tamizh' language (sangam) not the colloquial version!!! our penkatali, a linguist of sorts, quotes ... ônkal iTaivant uyarntôr tolaviLanki ênkoli ñâlat tiruLakarrum, ânkavarruL minnêr taniyâli venkatiron rânaiyatu tannêr ilâta tamil. There are two things born from mountains, shining so brilliantly that the great bow down, driving darkness from earth circled by roaring waters. One is the flaming sun, single wheel bright as lightning, the other is Tamil that has no comparison!! —from the taNTiyalankârum please visit this site penkatali's beautiful translation of bharatiyar songs... http://www.penkatali.org/bharati.html search within this site our db has mentioned about thiruvalluvar's tamil classic 'thirukural' in the group page! except our beloved shankaree how many people quote from this great text? we all like to quote from the gita, vedas , upanishads and other sources but seldom quote from thirukural!! we thank shankaree for bringing these 'gems' to us!!! Shri rama said to lakshmana " mother and motherland are dearer than heaven" ( janani , janmabhoomicha swargatpi gariyasi!) - i will add one more to this list- mother, motherland and mother tongue are dearer than heaven... a tamilian always says - "' this body is for the earth ; but this life is for tamizh"'- udal mannukku' ooyir tamizhukku!! you have seen suicide bombers killing themselves for their motherland or for their religion but so called passionate tamilians self- immolate themselves for their mother tongue!! such is their passion and intensity !!! members, i would like to draw your attention to a book called - Passions of the Tongue: Language Devotion in Tamil India, 1891-1970 (Studies on the History of Society and Culture , No 29) by Sumathi Ramaswamy available at amazon.com List Price: $24.95 Used & new from $4.38 Edition: Paperback | All Editions the author asks --- "why would love for their language lead several men in southern India to burn themselves alive in its name? Passions of the Tongue analyzes the discourses of love, labor, and life that transformed Tamil into an object of such passionate attachment, producing in the process one of modern India's most intense movements for linguistic revival and separatism." Sumathi Ramaswamy suggests that these discourses cannot be contained within a singular metanarrative of linguistic nationalism and instead proposes a new analytic, "language devotion." She uses this concept to track the many ways in which Tamil was imagined by its speakers and connects these multiple imaginings to their experience of colonial and post-colonial modernity. Focusing in particular on the transformation of the language into a goddess, mother, and maiden, Ramaswamy explores the pious, filial, and erotic aspects of Tamil devotion. She considers why, as its speakers sought political and social empowerment, metaphors of motherhood eventually came to dominate representations of the language. -- Sumathi Ramaswamy is Assistant Professor of History at the University of Pennsylvania. -- ******************************************************* in short, we are all attached to our Mothers, mother tongues and motherland? and above all , we are all attached tO mother GODDESS - she manifests herself in everything !!!! om sree matrayaii nmaha! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.