Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Sacrilege and Tolerance

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

June 25, 2005: One of the saddest things noticed in recent times is

that religious intolerance, nay hostility, in most societies in the

world seems to be increasing instead of showing signs of abating.

 

The recent acts of sacrilege against symbols of Muslim religion

committed by a handful of American soldiers led to protests —

accompanied by violence in countries like Pakistan and Afghanistan —

in all the 57 or so Muslim countries. It also reinforced anti-US

feelings in the Muslim world and authorities in the US just don't

seem to know how to win back the affections of the Muslims at home

and abroad.

 

While the focus is generally on 'desecration' of Muslim symbols,

other major religions are also at the receiving end of vandalism.

The demolition of Babri mosque incensed Muslims all over the world

but fanatics in India have also ransacked churches and harassed nuns

in smaller towns. The most horrible act of theirs was the burning

alive of a Christian missionary and his two young sons in Orissa. On

the other hand, Hindu temples and Sikh gurdwaras have also come

under attack from anonymous vandals, both in India and abroad.

 

Of all the communities, the Hindus have generally been comparatively

restrained in their reaction. The protests by and large saw less of

violence when they were not peaceful. But this might well change if

the trend of increasing incidents of sacrilege of Hindu symbols of

worship in the West is not arrested now because, of late, a large

measure of intolerance has seeped through the self-appointed

custodians of religion.

 

Designers in the West find it very fashionable to depict Hindu

symbols. Where the depiction was offensive to religious

sensitivities, it had a backlash. For instance, the Hindu community

in France and elsewhere in Europe, particularly the UK, has taken

great umbrage at the depiction of Lord Ram as an 'exotic eastern

sign' on shoes manufactured by a French firm called Minnelli.

 

The abuse of Hindu religious images and symbols in the West has

taken many shapes, though the shoe seems to have been a favourite.

The figure of the goddess of learning, Saraswati has been painted on

toilet seats. Lord Krishna has appeared on pocket tissues. Panties

have been adorned with the figure of Hanuman. In Italy bikinis have

come with the figure of various Hindu gods and goddesses. Women's

swimwear and underpants have been particularly favoured garments for

painting Hindu religious symbols.

 

France is often hailed as the seat of European culture and the

country is said to be very proud of the freedom enjoyed by its

people. But it is the same France where the Sikh pupils are not

allowed to attend school unless they remove their turbans. The ban

on the turban is said to be a sort of collateral damage of a new

French law that bans wearing of any religious symbol to schools.

Objections were dismissed casually.

 

In fact, one French minister was reported to have said that if the

Sikhs really thought their children could not attend school without

the turban then they should give them 'invisible turbans'! Most

people say that the law was primarily aimed at the headscarf,

or 'hijab', worn by Muslim women, but it had to include the Jewish

skullcap ('kippa'), the Christian cross and the Sikh turban to make

it appear that the French do not discriminate against any particular

religion. How thoughtful!!

 

For many in this part of the world it will be difficult to

understand what harm the wearing of these 'religious symbols' do.

Yes, those wearing a religious symbol will stand out from the rest.

But should that be seen as a sign of defiance or the will to resist

assimilation with the local populace, as the French seem to think?

 

If 'standing out' in a crowd is such a bad thing then it will be

difficult for the coloured people of Asia, Africa and Latin America

to breath easily in the white Caucasian West and, likewise, the

Whites will become target objects in the coloured world.

 

Certain myths need to be shattered. On the rare occasion when the

Western media pays some attention to the Hindu religion, the

writings are mostly offensive, written with a clear bias against the

Hindu religion. Hindu religious practices are seen as something like

hippie rituals. The French refuse to see that their self-invented

exotic appeal of the Hindu religion can offend the Hindus. The

obduracy of the French firm Minnelli is in contrast to the reaction

of the Italian firm of Roberto Cavalli.

 

When a clothesline of the Italian firm was found to be carrying

Hindu figures in offensive manner, the daughter of the owner flew

down to the UK to talk to representatives of Hindu organisations and

the offensive garment was removed from the shelves.

 

But perhaps a more dangerous situation seems to be developing in

some of the former far-flung British colonies where, ironically,

people of Indian origin constitute a large section of the

population. In the Pacific island nation of Fiji, the ethnic Indians

are now down to 44 percent from nearly 50 percent because the native

Fijians have aggressively and successfully run a campaign of hate

against the Hindus to deny them (Indians) their rightful place in

the society.

 

At the other end of the world, in the West Indies, ethnic Indians

constitute a major part of the population in the territories of

Guyana and the islands of Trinidad and Tobago. Some time ago, there

was a report that authorities in Guyana (where, in fact, the Indians

constitute the majority) had banned cremation at a site where the

Hindus were performing the last rituals of their dead for decades.

Regretfully, the move had come following objections by an Indian

community member belonging to another religion. Despite their large

numbers, the Hindus in Guyana have to put up with frequent

vituperative outpourings—both verbal and print, from leaders and the

media.

 

In Trinidad, the Hindus had to form a Protection Group after a

series of incidents of damage and destruction of their religious

institutions. There have been instances of pulling down of temples

to build another religion's structures. TV talk hosts have heaped

scorn on the Hindu religion. Desecration of Hindu institutions has

been a common sight. In Tobago, the authorities reportedly turned

down the demand for building a temple and a cremation site.

 

The message of religious tolerance has to percolate down to every

society in the world, small or big, weak or strong.

 

Source: Asian Tribune

URL: http://www.asiantribune.com/show_article.php?id=2502

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Namaste,

 

this religious intolerance is hardly a new fad, or a product of modernity. Have

we forgotten

the Crusades? The Spanish Inquisition? The Third Reich? What about the goings on

in Tibet

for the last 50 years?

 

As for temples build on temples, that's a tradition with a pedigree. There's

Masjid's built

on the sites of older Hindu temples and Hindu Temples now standing where older

Masjid's

once stood.

 

The Muslims now claim as sacred sites that the Christians claimed from the Jews,

who

record in their holy books the slaughter of the Pagans who once occupied the

land that the

Tribes of Israel claimed was deeded to them by God.

 

Increasing?

 

I don't think so. But I don't think it's abating either.

 

namaste,

 

prainbow

 

, "devi_bhakta" <devi_bhakta> wrote:

> June 25, 2005: One of the saddest things noticed in recent times is

> that religious intolerance, nay hostility, in most societies in the

> world seems to be increasing instead of showing signs of abating.

>

> The recent acts of sacrilege against symbols of Muslim religion

> committed by a handful of American soldiers led to protests —

> accompanied by violence in countries like Pakistan and Afghanistan —

> in all the 57 or so Muslim countries. It also reinforced anti-US

> feelings in the Muslim world and authorities in the US just don't

> seem to know how to win back the affections of the Muslims at home

> and abroad.

>

> While the focus is generally on 'desecration' of Muslim symbols,

> other major religions are also at the receiving end of vandalism.

> The demolition of Babri mosque incensed Muslims all over the world

> but fanatics in India have also ransacked churches and harassed nuns

> in smaller towns. The most horrible act of theirs was the burning

> alive of a Christian missionary and his two young sons in Orissa. On

> the other hand, Hindu temples and Sikh gurdwaras have also come

> under attack from anonymous vandals, both in India and abroad.

>

> Of all the communities, the Hindus have generally been comparatively

> restrained in their reaction. The protests by and large saw less of

> violence when they were not peaceful. But this might well change if

> the trend of increasing incidents of sacrilege of Hindu symbols of

> worship in the West is not arrested now because, of late, a large

> measure of intolerance has seeped through the self-appointed

> custodians of religion.

>

> Designers in the West find it very fashionable to depict Hindu

> symbols. Where the depiction was offensive to religious

> sensitivities, it had a backlash. For instance, the Hindu community

> in France and elsewhere in Europe, particularly the UK, has taken

> great umbrage at the depiction of Lord Ram as an 'exotic eastern

> sign' on shoes manufactured by a French firm called Minnelli.

>

> The abuse of Hindu religious images and symbols in the West has

> taken many shapes, though the shoe seems to have been a favourite.

> The figure of the goddess of learning, Saraswati has been painted on

> toilet seats. Lord Krishna has appeared on pocket tissues. Panties

> have been adorned with the figure of Hanuman. In Italy bikinis have

> come with the figure of various Hindu gods and goddesses. Women's

> swimwear and underpants have been particularly favoured garments for

> painting Hindu religious symbols.

>

> France is often hailed as the seat of European culture and the

> country is said to be very proud of the freedom enjoyed by its

> people. But it is the same France where the Sikh pupils are not

> allowed to attend school unless they remove their turbans. The ban

> on the turban is said to be a sort of collateral damage of a new

> French law that bans wearing of any religious symbol to schools.

> Objections were dismissed casually.

>

> In fact, one French minister was reported to have said that if the

> Sikhs really thought their children could not attend school without

> the turban then they should give them 'invisible turbans'! Most

> people say that the law was primarily aimed at the headscarf,

> or 'hijab', worn by Muslim women, but it had to include the Jewish

> skullcap ('kippa'), the Christian cross and the Sikh turban to make

> it appear that the French do not discriminate against any particular

> religion. How thoughtful!!

>

> For many in this part of the world it will be difficult to

> understand what harm the wearing of these 'religious symbols' do.

> Yes, those wearing a religious symbol will stand out from the rest.

> But should that be seen as a sign of defiance or the will to resist

> assimilation with the local populace, as the French seem to think?

>

> If 'standing out' in a crowd is such a bad thing then it will be

> difficult for the coloured people of Asia, Africa and Latin America

> to breath easily in the white Caucasian West and, likewise, the

> Whites will become target objects in the coloured world.

>

> Certain myths need to be shattered. On the rare occasion when the

> Western media pays some attention to the Hindu religion, the

> writings are mostly offensive, written with a clear bias against the

> Hindu religion. Hindu religious practices are seen as something like

> hippie rituals. The French refuse to see that their self-invented

> exotic appeal of the Hindu religion can offend the Hindus. The

> obduracy of the French firm Minnelli is in contrast to the reaction

> of the Italian firm of Roberto Cavalli.

>

> When a clothesline of the Italian firm was found to be carrying

> Hindu figures in offensive manner, the daughter of the owner flew

> down to the UK to talk to representatives of Hindu organisations and

> the offensive garment was removed from the shelves.

>

> But perhaps a more dangerous situation seems to be developing in

> some of the former far-flung British colonies where, ironically,

> people of Indian origin constitute a large section of the

> population. In the Pacific island nation of Fiji, the ethnic Indians

> are now down to 44 percent from nearly 50 percent because the native

> Fijians have aggressively and successfully run a campaign of hate

> against the Hindus to deny them (Indians) their rightful place in

> the society.

>

> At the other end of the world, in the West Indies, ethnic Indians

> constitute a major part of the population in the territories of

> Guyana and the islands of Trinidad and Tobago. Some time ago, there

> was a report that authorities in Guyana (where, in fact, the Indians

> constitute the majority) had banned cremation at a site where the

> Hindus were performing the last rituals of their dead for decades.

> Regretfully, the move had come following objections by an Indian

> community member belonging to another religion. Despite their large

> numbers, the Hindus in Guyana have to put up with frequent

> vituperative outpourings—both verbal and print, from leaders and the

> media.

>

> In Trinidad, the Hindus had to form a Protection Group after a

> series of incidents of damage and destruction of their religious

> institutions. There have been instances of pulling down of temples

> to build another religion's structures. TV talk hosts have heaped

> scorn on the Hindu religion. Desecration of Hindu institutions has

> been a common sight. In Tobago, the authorities reportedly turned

> down the demand for building a temple and a cremation site.

>

> The message of religious tolerance has to percolate down to every

> society in the world, small or big, weak or strong.

>

> Source: Asian Tribune

> URL: http://www.asiantribune.com/show_article.php?id=2502

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I notice you have mentioned Fiji as being one of the places of religious abuse

faced by Hindus. I live in Fiji,am born here. My ancestors came here 126 years

ago under British rule from India to trade. Until recently, we watch on TV news

(as i just watched today) a Hindu temple ransacked, vandalized, burnt or

completely destroyed and all idols stolen. Most of the Hindu community here are

farmers who do not earn enough but have throughout their lives saved and

collectively built temples which are destroyed in no time. I must say the Police

is doing "their best"but nothing is happeneing. In my life, I have not heard of

any Masjid or Church gone under the same as what the Hindu temples are facing. I

feel if we do not do anything oneday we will have no place to worship and the

historic temples will be just pile of dust. EVERY WEEK A TEMPLE IS DESTROYED,

ROBBED, VANDALIZED, RANSACKED IN FIJI.

 

Jay Dayal

FIJI.

 

devi_bhakta <devi_bhakta wrote:

 

But perhaps a more dangerous situation seems to be developing in

some of the former far-flung British colonies where, ironically,

people of Indian origin constitute a large section of the

population. In the Pacific island nation of Fiji, the ethnic Indians

are now down to 44 percent from nearly 50 percent because the native

Fijians have aggressively and successfully run a campaign of hate

against the Hindus to deny them (Indians) their rightful place in

the society.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...