Guest guest Posted January 1, 2006 Report Share Posted January 1, 2006 I sent a reply to Hindustan times too here it is. Just for fun. The evangelist fellow will, of course, ignore it. "I was flabbergated to read the article. I suspect that it was penned by an evangelist or by someone who was suitably "motivated" by an evangelist. It is basically Christian goebbelsian propaganda. First say things to catch the attention of the target group then insert the misinformation. Classic case. The misinformation inserted is "In contrast to the Russian Orthodox Church's stance, Hindus respect Jesus Christ, who is predicted in the Vedas, the ancient Hindu scriptures, as a specifically empowered personality." This is lot of hogwash to say the least. Being conversant with the evangelical propaganda, and the basic texts referred to this is just goebbelsian trick. Is the author a Caucasian or a Christian please?? I am sure you will not publish this." sankara menon <kochu1tz wrote: Dear all: Eve the aricle referenced by Felicia is part of the christian evangelistmovement to "save" India. wrote whats below even fefore I read the ari\tilcle. But I now notice that it is by an unnamed author, from the "UK Beureau". What gives awa the ethenicity and intent and purport of the article is the paragraph "In contrast to the Russian Orthodox Church's stance, Hindus respect Jesus Christ, who is predicted in the Vedas, the ancient Hindu scriptures, as a specifically empowered personality." The first few paragraphs will get the attentio of the hindus then the Gobbelsian westernn trick by adding the above quoted paragraph. Thisis untrue and a lot of hogwash thats being propagated by the evangelists to reduce resistence to conversion!! Actually this illustrated what i said in the original reply. Plantng a false idea and then letting it grow. You expect us to believe such artiles?? It is obviosly penned at the instance of evangelists by an evangelist ot a paid off scribe. sankara menon <kochu1tz wrote: Felicia said "I note two facts - these articles are not being carried by mainstream British or US news wires. So, where is the corroboration of these allegations?" --- So?? A news report in Hindustan Times is acceptable only when it is corroborated by '"mainstream" British and American papers'?? Are they the ultimate arbiters of what is true and what is not? As far as I know the British and American "mainstream" press are backers of all sorts of western propaganda to further western interests. They mix truth and fiction as they deem necessary. In order to shore up the credibility, they sometimes they criticize the west and bring verifiable stories also. That’s all part of the propaganda apparatchik. I have found this slanted racist attitude everywhere from London Times BBC and whatnot. Look at CNN and its "embedded" reporters like amanpour and others - pure propagandists who have been built up by CNN to pass on US propaganda in Iraq. I will not believe one word of what they say. I would rather see the scenes and draw my own conclusions - however censored the scenes are. Thats your idea of "free press"? I make it clear that Indian Press is far more free than the so called “western free press” which is but an arm of western interests. Felicia <hygeiea44 wrote: , shankaree ramatas <shankaree> wrote: > Pranam. An article from another group... Ur comments, pls. Shankaree, Check out this article: http://www.hindustantimes.com/2005/Dec/06/5983_1566453,00430005.htm I note two facts - these articles are not being carried by mainstream British or US news wires. So, where is the corroboration of these allegations? The article in Hindustan times names the particular archbishop ofRussian Orthodox church who is referring to Lord Krishna as Satan. Love, Felicia Photos Ring in the New Year with Photo Calendars. Add photos, events, holidays, whatever. Devi Traditions Divine Visit your group "" on the web. DSL Something to write home about. Just $16.99/mo. or less Devi Traditions Divine Visit your group "" on the web. DSL Something to write home about. Just $16.99/mo. or less Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2006 Report Share Posted January 1, 2006 Dear Mr Menon You have my full support. This is exactly what is happening. The American and British Public is completly zombified and paralyzed by a vile propaganda machine where even the criticism is deliberatly faked to perfect the mind control. There was some minor resistance against this zombification in Continental Europe but this has been completly eradicated in the last few years. The media are constantly flooding the masses with misinformation, 24 hours, nonstop, upholding and implanting the idea of the moral superiority of the western so-called democratic "civilisation" and the western way of life over the rest of the uncivilised world. Political Parties only serve to establish the Illusion of democracy, actual politics do not change after an election of a different political Party. This reminds me of a joke : One western Lady was once asking a chinese Communist: Do you chinese folk also have real elections like we have in the west? He answered: Yes Madam of coulse we have evely molning. -----> > So?? A news report in Hindustan Times is acceptable only when it is corroborated by '"mainstream" British and American papers'?? Are they the ultimate arbiters of what is true and what is not? > > As far as I know the British and American "mainstream" press are backers of all sorts of western propaganda to further western interests. They mix truth and fiction as they deem necessary. In order to shore up the credibility, they sometimes they criticize the west and bring verifiable stories also. That's all part of the propaganda apparatchik. > > I have found this slanted racist attitude everywhere from London Times BBC and whatnot. Look at CNN and its "embedded" reporters like amanpour and others - pure propagandists who have been built up by CNN to pass on US propaganda in Iraq. I will not believe one word of what they say. Dear Mr Menon You have my full support. This is exactly what is happening. The American and British Public is completly zombified and paralyzed by a vile propaganda machine where even the criticism is deliberatly faked to perfect the mind control. There was some minor resistance against this zombification in Continental Europe but this has been completly eradicated in the last few years. The media are constantly flooding the masses with misinformation 24 hours nonstop upholding and implanting the idea of the moral superiority of the western so called democratic "civilisation" and the western way of life over the rest of the uncivilised world. Political Parties only serve to establish the Illusion of democracy, actual politics do not change after an election of a different political Party. This reminds me of a joke : One western Lady was once asking a chinese Communist: Do you chinese folk also have real elections like we have in the west? He answered: Yes Madam of coulse we have evely molning. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2006 Report Share Posted January 1, 2006 Sankara, I think we have a misunderstanding. I don't mean to insinuate that the original article you posted was false, merely that the news wires are remiss. Here, in the US, we have the same ugly phenomenon: A news item is carried by Salon.com or by NPR or by Canadian News. But, CNN and MSNBC never mention it. Hence, my heavy reliance on Salon.com and the blogosphere for real news. More comments below: > It is basically Christian goebbelsian propaganda. > First say things to catch the attention of the target group > then insert the misinformation. Classic case. The misinformation > inserted is > "In contrast to the Russian Orthodox Church's stance, > Hindus respect Jesus Christ, who is predicted in the Vedas, > the ancient Hindu scriptures, as a specifically empowered > personality." This may not be intentional misinformation on the part of Evangelists. Yogananda's Self Realization Fellowship attracts a fair number of Christians who really do believe, because Yogananda taught his followers to respect the prophets of all religions including Christ, that Hindus *do* respect Yeshuah ben Josef and that the Vedas predicted him, etc. Also, the Theosophists have done a good job of spreading this propoganda, as well. It's a classic tactic to gain followers. ;-) That's not to say Evangelists don't resort to Goebbelsian propoganda. ;-) Love, Felicia Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 1, 2006 Report Share Posted January 1, 2006 I am sure the poor fellow must be tuning in his grave because of all the misinformation and false statements about and allegedly by him. **This may not be intentional misinformation on the part of Evangelists.** ohhhhhhhh ever seen an honest evangelist? There was this stanes fellow from Australia, he created so much discord someone threw petrol on his vehicle and burnt him. In the process two of his children were also klled. Even with the alleged husband dead the widow was more interested in prolystation than the death of alleged husband and children. Do not forget that the propaandists in the evanelism field are especially trained in the black art o propaganda. The YSS and Theo people who spread all these stories are also caucasian now with a sprinkin of Indians to grant authenticity. I know this because I know that YSS reserves monkhood mostly to westerners while giving sanyas to a few Indians for appearence's sake and those who are given sanyas, however senior wll never have any say in the organisation. So they are not interpreting vedas. Can any one show me the alleged quote from Vedas referring to Jesus?? Lets assume for amoment thats true, then all christians should become hindus because hindsm isreate to have predcted this so accuraly. Why create another religion?? Felicia <hygeiea44 wrote: Sankara, I think we have a misunderstanding. I don't mean to insinuate that the original article you posted was false, merely that the news wires are remiss. Here, in the US, we have the same ugly phenomenon: A news item is carried by Salon.com or by NPR or by Canadian News. But, CNN and MSNBC never mention it. Hence, my heavy reliance on Salon.com and the blogosphere for real news. More comments below: > It is basically Christian goebbelsian propaganda. > First say things to catch the attention of the target group then insert the misinformation. Classic case. The misinformation inserted is > "In contrast to the Russian Orthodox Church's stance, > Hindus respect Jesus Christ, who is predicted in the Vedas, the ancient Hindu scriptures, as a specifically empowered personality." This may not be intentional misinformation on the part of Evangelists. Yogananda's Self Realization Fellowship attracts a fair number of Christians who really do believe, because Yogananda taught his followers to respect the prophets of all religions including Christ, that Hindus *do* respect Yeshuah ben Josef and that the Vedas predicted him, etc. Also, the Theosophists have done a good job of spreading this propoganda, as well. It's a classic tactic to gain followers. ;-) That's not to say Evangelists don't resort to Goebbelsian propoganda. ;-) Love, Felicia Devi Traditions Divine Visit your group "" on the web. Photos Ring in the New Year with Photo Calendars. Add photos, events, holidays, whatever. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2006 Report Share Posted January 2, 2006 Hello Sankara, You mention an incident where someone set fire to the vehicle of a Christian evangelist called Stanes, an Australian, killing not only the man himself but two of his children as well. You seem to be saying that those who set the fire are not to be blamed, rather the evangelist is to be blamed because he "created so much discord". Is this really what you are saying, or have I misunderstood? And what exactly do you mean by "alleged husband"? Do you suspect that these two people were not lawfully married? If so, I wonder what evidence, if any, you have for such suspicion? Om Shantih Colin , sankara menon <kochu1tz> wrote: > > I am sure the poor fellow must be tuning in his grave because of all the misinformation and false statements about and allegedly by him. > > **This may not be intentional misinformation on the part of Evangelists.** ohhhhhhhh ever seen an honest evangelist? > > There was this stanes fellow from Australia, he created so much discord someone threw petrol on his vehicle and burnt him. In the process two of his children were also klled. Even with the alleged husband dead the widow was more interested in prolystation than the death of alleged husband and children. Do not forget that the propaandists in the evanelism field are especially trained in the black art o propaganda. The YSS and Theo people who spread all these stories are also caucasian now with a sprinkin of Indians to grant authenticity. > I know this because I know that YSS reserves monkhood mostly to westerners while giving sanyas to a few Indians for appearence's sake and those who are given sanyas, however senior wll never have any say in the organisation. So they are not interpreting vedas. > > Can any one show me the alleged quote from Vedas referring to Jesus?? Lets assume for amoment thats true, then all christians should become hindus because hindsm isreate to have predcted this so accuraly. Why create another religion?? > > Felicia <hygeiea44@l...> wrote: > Sankara, > > I think we have a misunderstanding. I don't mean to insinuate that the original article you posted was false, merely that the news wires are remiss. Here, in the US, we have the same ugly phenomenon: A news item is carried by Salon.com or by NPR or by Canadian News. But, CNN and MSNBC never mention it. Hence, my heavy reliance on Salon.com and the blogosphere for real news. > > More comments below: > > > It is basically Christian goebbelsian propaganda. > > First say things to catch the attention of the target group then insert the misinformation. Classic case. The misinformation inserted is > > > "In contrast to the Russian Orthodox Church's stance, > Hindus respect Jesus Christ, who is predicted in the Vedas, the ancient Hindu scriptures, as a specifically empowered personality." > > This may not be intentional misinformation on the part of Evangelists. Yogananda's Self Realization Fellowship attracts a fair number of Christians who really do believe, because Yogananda taught his followers to respect the prophets of all religions including Christ, > that Hindus *do* respect Yeshuah ben Josef and that the Vedas predicted him, etc. Also, the Theosophists have done a good job of spreading this propoganda, as well. It's a classic tactic to gain followers. ;-) > > That's not to say Evangelists don't resort to Goebbelsian propoganda. ;-) > > Love, > Felicia > Devi Traditions Divine > > > > > > Visit your group "" on the web. > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > Photos > Ring in the New Year with Photo Calendars. Add photos, events, holidays, whatever. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2006 Report Share Posted January 2, 2006 , sankara menon <kochu1tz> wrote: > Can any one show me the alleged quote from Vedas referring to Jesus?? Lets assume for amoment thats true, then all christians should become hindus because hindsm isreate to have predcted this so accuraly. Why create another religion?? In Vedas there is no reference even to Krishna or Rama, not to say of Jesus or Muhammad LOL. Maybe what was meant is the known reference to Bhavishya-purana, where some "Isha Natha" is mentioned. That passage is a recent interpolation, made on behalf of christian missionaries. It's a fake stuff Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2006 Report Share Posted January 2, 2006 , sankara menon <kochu1tz> wrote: > > I am sure the poor fellow must be tuning in his grave because of all the misinformation and false statements about and allegedly by him. You mean they buried him rather than cremate? Boy, he was more of a heretic than I thought! ;-) > **This may not be intentional misinformation on the part of Evangelists.** ohhhhhhhh ever seen an honest evangelist? Which organized religion does not propogate lies and a slave mentality among adherants who bow to the morals and dogma for food and care in this life and a promise of a heavenly place in the alleged afterlife rather than develop their own ethical framework and live creatively, here and now? > There was this stanes fellow from Australia, he created > so much discord someone threw petrol on his vehicle and > burnt him. In the process two of his children were also klled. > Even with the alleged husband dead the widow was more > interested in prolystation than the death of alleged husband > and children. Graham Stewart Stains For those interested, I found a news article here: http://www.rediff.com/news/1999/jan/23oris.htm Is violence justified against those who proselytize an intolerant religion and yet devote themselves to physical care of the most down-trodden of the outcaste/untouchables who are not cared for by their own aparteided society? That's not to say that I advocate what passes for Christianity in this yuga of Kali. One has only educate oneself to know that it is a heresy and these people rely heavily on a misinterpretation and mistranslations of the original Greek and Hebrew. Be that as it may, as Colin wonders, so do I - why do you say "alleged widow"? My experience of evangelists in Mexico is that they are *always* married couples devoted to spreading their religion and offering care in exchange to the most down-trodden. > Do not forget that the propaandists in the evanelism field are > especially trained in the black art o propaganda. Beg to differ: Gray art - as it inevitably mixes a grain of truth with falsehoods. ;-) > The YSS and Theo people who spread all these stories are > also caucasian now with a sprinkin of Indians to > grant authenticity. > I know this because I know that YSS reserves monkhood mostly > to westerners while giving sanyas to a few Indians for > appearence's sake and those who are given sanyas, however > senior wll never have any say in the organisation. > So they are not interpreting vedas. Indeed, the fruit of Yogananda's envy of Vivekananda's success... ;-) > Can any one show me the alleged quote from Vedas referring > to Jesus?? If it is published by YSS and attributed to Yogananda, surely it must be true... ;-) > Lets assume for amoment thats true, then all christians should > become hindus because hindsm isreate to have predcted this so > accuraly. Why create another religion?? Who is creating another religion? It's already quite firmly established and here to stay, attracting new slaves, daily. Nearly 90 years old, in fact. Did I ever mention the guru's dilemma? There once was a guru who lived high up on a mountain cliff. To him climbed many a shishya desiring Enlightenment. Every time a would-be shishya arrived to learn at this great Ascended Master's feet, he said, "Fine. you must do everything I tell you." Upon the shishya's groveling agreement, he declared, "My first instruction is to go jump off this cliff." After awhile, because of a shortage of shishyas, the other gurus sent a delegation up the mountain to confront this madman... er, great Avadhut. "Why do you give this instruction to shishyas?" they demanded. Without hesitation, the Master replied, "Who wants a stupid chela?" Love, Felicia Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2006 Report Share Posted January 2, 2006 Dear Felicia: It is not me alone who feel this way. Slowly the majority of Indian Hindus are feeling the same way. It is slowly building up. It will explode one day. Then it will be far worse than jihad. No personal offence intended. Felicia <hygeiea44 wrote: , Sankara Menon <kochu1tz> wrote: > > I am sure the poor fellow must be tuning in his grave because of all the misinformation and false statements about and allegedly by him.=è This was with respect to jesus!! You mean they buried him rather than cremate? Boy, he was more of a heretic than I thought! ;-) > **This may not be intentional misinformation on the part of Evangelists.** ohhhhhhhh ever seen an honest evangelist? Which organized religion does not propagate lies and a slave mentality among adherents who bow to the morals and dogma for food and care in this life and a promise of a heavenly place in the alleged afterlife rather than develop their own ethical framework and live creatively, here and now? Hinduism does not prolystate by making false propaganda. For Christians the alleged caring for the poor and destitute is the cover for attempts to convert. There are 25% CHRISTIAN Americans who cannot have food everyday. Why do the good Christians not first help their own before fanning out to other countries where other religions are majority?? > There was this stanes fellow from Australia, he created so much discord someone threw petrol on his vehicle and burnt him. In the process two of his children were also klled. Even with the alleged husband dead the widow was more interested in prolystation than the death of alleged husband and children. Graham Stewart Stains For those interested, I found a news article here: http://www.rediff.com/news/1999/jan/23oris.htm Read While no motive has yet been ascribed, police sources said the attack was most likely perpetrated by the Bajrang Dal, an arm of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, which has been active in the area. Communal tension has reportedly been high for the last year in the area. =è Its OK for evangelists to be active but it is not OK for the indigenous religion to be active?? Manoharpur itself has a high population of converts to Christianity, which is reportedly resented by the tribal Hindus. Just a few months ago, Bajrang Dal activists had attacked trucks of cattle owned by Muslims. Is violence justified against those who proselytize an intolerant religion and yet devote themselves to physical care of the most down-trodden of the outcaste/untouchables who are not cared for by their own aparteided society? ð You have rightly said that the evangelists are intolerant. Let them set their house right before invading and attacking other peoples’ beliefs and societies. There are 25% poor in US f A. Australians support US of A. Why did this Staines fellow not deem it necessary to go to US of A and help the poor?? Was it because there are no converson opportunities?? That's not to say that I advocate what passes for Christianity in this yuga of Kali. One has only educate oneself to know that it is a heresy and these people rely heavily on a misinterpretation and mistranslations of the original Greek and Hebrew. Be that as it may, as Colin wonders, so do I - why do you say "alleged widow"? My experience of evangelists in Mexico is that they are *always* married couples devoted to spreading their religion and offering care in exchange to the most down-trodden. ð è Ahhhhhhhh this marriage is a really good cover you know. I know at least 3 missionary couples who are not married and sleep with the targets to convert. The care included sleeping with a white. So that they become superior. Do not forget that the propaandists in the evanelism field are especially trained in the black art o propaganda. Beg to differ: Gray art - as it inevitably mixes a grain of truth with falsehoods. ;-) The YSS and Theo people who spread all these stories are also caucasian now with a sprinkin of Indians to grant authenticity. I know this because I know that YSS reserves monkhood mostly to westerners while giving sanyas to a few Indians for appearence's sake and those who are given sanyas, however senior will never have any say in the organisation. > So they are not interpreting vedas. ð They are a group of westerners who took over a perfectly Indian organization by infiltration Indeed, the fruit of Yogananda's envy of Vivekananda's success... ;-) > Can any one show me the alleged quote from Vedas referring > to Jesus?? If it is published by YSS and attributed to Yogananda, surely it must be true... ;-) ð “Attributed” and truth are different. > Lets assume for amoment thats true, then all christians should become hindus because hindsm isreate to have predcted this so accuraly. Why create another religion?? Who is creating another religion? It's already quite firmly established and here to stay, attracting new slaves, daily. Nearly 90 years old, in fact. Did I ever mention the guru's dilemma? There once was a guru who lived high up on a mountain cliff. To him climbed many a shishya desiring Enlightenment. Every time a would-be shishya arrived to learn at this great Ascended Master's feet, he said, "Fine. you must do everything I tell you." Upon the shishya's groveling agreement, he declared, "My first instruction is to go jump off this cliff." After awhile, because of a shortage of shishyas, the other gurus sent a delegation up the mountain to confront this madman... er, great Avadhut. "Why do you give this instruction to shishyas?" they demanded. Without hesitation, the Master replied, "Who wants a stupid chela?" Love, Felicia Shopping Find Great Deals on Holiday Gifts at Shopping Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2006 Report Share Posted January 3, 2006 , sankara menon <kochu1tz> wrote: > > It is not me alone who feel this way. Slowly the majority > of Indian Hindus are feeling the same way. It is slowly > building up. It will explode one day. Then it will be far > worse than jihad. No personal offence intended. Dear Sankara, Personal offense? You may have noticed I'm not a bloody Evangelist. ;-) But, at the risk of offending you, I will state: Revolution comes from within. Where are the educated, wealthy Brahmins with access to high speed internet service who care enough about their disadvantaged countrymen and about their own cultural heritage to flood the blogosphere and iPods with photos and video footage and accurate, factual reporting of the Evangelist's methods? Is the culture so stratified that your wealthy, advantaged countrymen are too blind to see that they themselves are the enemy of their own people? Rather than violence/jihad, Indians could do themselves a very big favor by getting video footage and photos posted to bloggers and podcasters who have access to reliable, high speed internet service - on a continuing and ongoing basis. You may have noticed that, increasingly, the news wires are relying on the blogosphere for up-to-the minute reporting of developing news, worldwide. That means international attention. That level of media access is very, very powerful. It also takes a great deal of dedication, attention to detail, constancy and continued effort. As they say, a picture is worth a thousand words. iPodcasting, the internet and, specifically, the blogosphere are the revolution. You reach more young people, that way. Love, Felicia Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2006 Report Share Posted January 3, 2006 , sankara menon <kochu1tz> wrote: > > Dear Felicia: > > It is not me alone who feel this way. Slowly the majority of Indian Hindus are feeling the same way. It is slowly building up. It will explode one day. Then it will be far worse than jihad. No personal offence intended. > A little off the point. I really think something like an explosion will never happen. Look at the history. The hindus were ruled (and most of the time not favourably) for more that 1000 years but they still did not have any significant rebellion. Vivekananda had said that hindus can never be united. This is also a part of hindu tolerance. I think most of the religions came after hinduism therfore we are not taught how to react to other religion (there is no concept of other religion in hinduism, only dharma and adharma). This is in contrast to Islam /Christianity which were propogated at the cost of other existing faiths. Regards Sumanta *********** I disagree though. Because times have changed and people are fed up. I know this because, in my official capacity, sometime not too long ago, I had read assesments. The first instance was the NDA Government. But that was not a success because depite the color change many of the leaders were corrupt polticians. Now, I am told, there is a thought process of creaing unsullied people who are well educated the andidates. IF that happens it could lead to a change in status that could result in a backlash by people who gained benifits on the basis of religion - mainly Chrisians and Mualims - and that will lead to a reacion. Thats what I was speaking about. Now that I am in ndia for a few days more I am talking to people and this is the impression I gained. KOCHU ******************* Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2006 Report Share Posted January 3, 2006 Dear Felicia, I don´t know what your Interpretation of this "allegedly" Indian Story is, should it imply that, to an Avadhoot Guru, intelligence is more important than devotion to the Guru, you have a mistaken notion of the tradition. On the contrary especially amongst the Kaulas, Avadhootas, Nathas and Digambaras Devotion to the Guru is the key to sucess and is the basic requirement,Intelligence is not a prerequiste and never was because the teaching is non dual and way beyond manas, while without Devotion no progress beyond a certain point is possible. There are other sampradayas who rely more heavily on Jnana, but those mentioned above promote Teachings way above caste creed and mental concepts and can lead to sucess without recourse to Mind activity. In fact Mind activity is considered more as an obstacle than an asset, because as one can easily notice following illusive thought constructs most often only strengthen the feeling of superiority to others, this is one of the main obstacles to progress in this path. More than just Humility is needed. No true Avadhoota would mistreat People like the Teacher in your story allegedly does, only because they are not as intelligent as he deems himself to be. Mahahradanatha > Did I ever mention the guru's dilemma? > > There once was a guru who lived high up on a mountain cliff. > To him climbed many a shishya desiring Enlightenment. > Every time a would-be shishya arrived to learn at this great > Ascended Master's feet, he said, > "Fine. you must do everything I tell you." > Upon the shishya's groveling agreement, > he declared, "My first instruction is to go jump off this cliff." > After awhile, because of a shortage of shishyas, the other gurus sent a delegation up the mountain to confront this madman... er, great Avadhut. > "Why do you give this instruction to shishyas?" they demanded. > Without hesitation, the Master replied, "Who wants a stupid chela?" Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2006 Report Share Posted January 3, 2006 , "mahahradanatha" <mahahradanatha> wrote: > > Dear Mr Menon > > You have my full support. This is exactly what is happening. The > American and British Public is completly zombified and paralyzed by a vile propaganda machine where even the criticism is deliberatly faked to perfect the mind control. > > There was some minor resistance against this zombification in > Continental Europe but this has been completly eradicated in the last few years. > > The media are constantly flooding the masses with misinformation, 24 > hours, nonstop, upholding and implanting the idea of the moral > superiority of the western so-called democratic "civilisation" and > the western way of life over the rest of the uncivilised world. > Political Parties only serve to establish the Illusion of democracy, > actual politics do not change after an election of a different > political Party. (snip) Greetings, All, and Happy New Year's wishes to everyone. I concur with these thoughts, and think the insidiousness goes beyond politics in a way. The political neoCON agenda has used the trappings of "democracy" and "freedom" to promote the Christian Fundamentalista perversion of "if you're not with us, you're against us" dualism. 93/696, Nina Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2006 Report Share Posted January 3, 2006 Namaste...... Well, I remember a story similar with this one with the Guru living high up in the mountain, but it was different and the Guru was Babaji and his followers, who travel from remote places in wilderness to some other places using his spiritual powers known as translocation, and one day an aspired disciple got the chance to come close to its group of disciples and when Babaji saw him said: “Who are you looking for?” the intruder replied: “I was looking for you MASTER, because I always wanted to meet you. I will do whatever you want me to do to. Please, let me stay with you and become your disciple.” Then, Babaji looked at him and said: “If you are willing to do what I want you to do then jump off this cliff.” Immediately with no hesitation the poor fellow jumped and died instantly. It was a bloody scene to see such a thing happening, and all of his disciples looked at the scene in consternation. Babaji came down and with a magic touch resurrected the poor chela who dared to become his disciple. And then explained to them that he couldn’t accepted him as a disciple because of his negative karma, but now he is ready to follow him and only in this way was possible to wipe out rapidly and efficiently his bad karma to be accepted as his disciple. I came with this reply because it was necessary to make you to understand that we can’t think any single moment that Spiritual Path it’s a joke or we can make fun of such things like Guru Stories for amusement, and it’s easy to accumulate negative karma every day of our life but hard to get rid of it. We have to be mature and honest with ourselves to understand and follow instructions gave to us by our teachers to make some progress in our personal Spiritual Journey and wipe out negative karma in a slow process by doing SADHANA. ~ OM TAT SAT ~ mahahradanatha <mahahradanatha wrote: Dear Felicia, I don´t know what your Interpretation of this "allegedly" Indian Story is, should it imply that, to an Avadhoot Guru, intelligence is more important than devotion to the Guru, you have a mistaken notion of the tradition. On the contrary especially amongst the Kaulas, Avadhootas, Nathas and Digambaras Devotion to the Guru is the key to sucess and is the basic requirement,Intelligence is not a prerequiste and never was because the teaching is non dual and way beyond manas, while without Devotion no progress beyond a certain point is possible. There are other sampradayas who rely more heavily on Jnana, but those mentioned above promote Teachings way above caste creed and mental concepts and can lead to sucess without recourse to Mind activity. In fact Mind activity is considered more as an obstacle than an asset, because as one can easily notice following illusive thought constructs most often only strengthen the feeling of superiority to others, this is one of the main obstacles to progress in this path. More than just Humility is needed. No true Avadhoota would mistreat People like the Teacher in your story allegedly does, only because they are not as intelligent as he deems himself to be. Mahahradanatha > Did I ever mention the guru's dilemma? > > There once was a guru who lived high up on a mountain cliff. > To him climbed many a shishya desiring Enlightenment. > Every time a would-be shishya arrived to learn at this great > Ascended Master's feet, he said, > "Fine. you must do everything I tell you." > Upon the shishya's groveling agreement, > he declared, "My first instruction is to go jump off this cliff." > After awhile, because of a shortage of shishyas, the other gurus sent a delegation up the mountain to confront this madman... er, great Avadhut. > "Why do you give this instruction to shishyas?" they demanded. > Without hesitation, the Master replied, "Who wants a stupid chela?" Devi Traditions Divine Visit your group "" on the web. Shopping Find Great Deals on Holiday Gifts at Shopping Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2006 Report Share Posted January 3, 2006 , david keller <davekeller121> wrote: > > Namaste...... > Well, I remember a story similar with this one ...... > I came with this reply because it was necessary to make you to understand that we can't think any single moment that Spiritual Path it's a joke or we can make fun of such things like Guru Stories for amusement, Namaste Dave! Please read both Stories again.they are not similiar, their meaning is exactly opposite. Felicias Story seems to depict a teacher who punishes and ridicules those devotees that are devoted to him, and considers devotion a vice and a sign of stupidity. Your stories Meaning is that devotion is a virtue. I don´t understand your second remark. I was not making fun of Guru stories. I commented upon a story that in my opinion is ridiculing the values of a Guru parampara it professes to stem from. The origin of the Story or the reason for the distortion of this story might be an deliberate attempt to destroy Indian Values and replace them with western scepticism and evil fundamental christianity. Everyone knows how Christianity hates the Guru worship they have good reasons to spread that Distortion. Mahahradanatha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2006 Report Share Posted January 3, 2006 Mahahradanatha, 'Jumping off this cliff' is a metaphor for exercising a sense of humor. ;-) Love, Felicia , david keller <davekeller121> wrote: > > Namaste...... > Well, I remember a story similar with this one with the Guru living high up in the mountain, but it was different and the Guru was Babaji and his followers, who travel from remote places in wilderness to some other places using his spiritual powers known as translocation, and one day an aspired disciple got the chance to come close to its group of disciples and when Babaji saw him said: > "Who are you looking for?" > the intruder replied: > "I was looking for you MASTER, because I always wanted to meet you. I will do whatever you want me to do to. Please, let me stay with you and become your disciple." > Then, Babaji looked at him and said: > "If you are willing to do what I want you to do then jump off this cliff." > Immediately with no hesitation the poor fellow jumped and died instantly. > It was a bloody scene to see such a thing happening, and all of his disciples looked at the scene in consternation. Babaji came down and with a magic touch resurrected the poor chela who dared to become his disciple. And then explained to them that he couldn't accepted him as a disciple because of his negative karma, but now he is ready to follow him and only in this way was possible to wipe out rapidly and efficiently his bad karma to be accepted as his disciple. > > I came with this reply because it was necessary to make you to understand that we can't think any single moment that Spiritual Path it's a joke or we can make fun of such things like Guru Stories for amusement, and it's easy to accumulate negative karma every day of our life but hard to get rid of it. We have to be mature and honest with ourselves to understand and follow instructions gave to us by our teachers to make some progress in our personal Spiritual Journey and wipe out negative karma in a slow process by doing SADHANA. > > ~ OM TAT SAT ~ > > > mahahradanatha <mahahradanatha> wrote: Dear Felicia, > > I don´t know what your Interpretation of this "allegedly" Indian Story > is, should it imply that, to an Avadhoot Guru, intelligence is more > important than devotion to the Guru, you have a mistaken notion of the > tradition. > On the contrary especially amongst the Kaulas, Avadhootas, Nathas and > Digambaras Devotion to the Guru is the key to sucess and is the basic > requirement,Intelligence is not a prerequiste and never was because the > teaching is non dual and way beyond manas, while without Devotion no > progress beyond a certain point is possible. > There are other sampradayas who rely more heavily on Jnana, but those > mentioned above promote Teachings way above caste creed and mental > concepts and can lead to sucess without recourse to Mind activity. > In fact Mind activity is considered more as an obstacle than an asset, > because as one can easily notice following illusive thought constructs > most often only strengthen the feeling of superiority to others, this > is one of the main obstacles to progress in this path. More than just > Humility is needed. No true Avadhoota would mistreat People like the > Teacher in your story allegedly does, only because they are not as > intelligent as he deems himself to be. > > Mahahradanatha > > > > Did I ever mention the guru's dilemma? > > > > There once was a guru who lived high up on a mountain cliff. > > To him climbed many a shishya desiring Enlightenment. > > Every time a would-be shishya arrived to learn at this great > > Ascended Master's feet, he said, > > "Fine. you must do everything I tell you." > > Upon the shishya's groveling agreement, > > he declared, "My first instruction is to go jump off this cliff." > > After awhile, because of a shortage of shishyas, the other gurus sent > a delegation up the mountain to confront this madman... er, great > Avadhut. > > "Why do you give this instruction to shishyas?" they demanded. > > Without hesitation, the Master replied, "Who wants a stupid chela?" > > > > Devi Traditions Divine > > > > > > Visit your group "" on the web. > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > Shopping > Find Great Deals on Holiday Gifts at Shopping > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2006 Report Share Posted January 3, 2006 , "Felicia" <hygeiea44@l...> wrote: > > Mahahradanatha, > > 'Jumping off this cliff' is a metaphor for exercising a sense of > humor. ;-) > > Love, > Felicia Dear Felicia, Your answer is evasive. Mahahradanatha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 17, 2006 Report Share Posted January 17, 2006 I agree with Mahahradanath as this being true. However as I read between the lines, the instance referred to by Felicia is an Aspirant seeking his or her Guru, which needs to be done with prudence. Once one accepts that personage as their Guru then total surrender/ sincerity is expected. In this story the Aspirant/s appears to have accepted the Master as his/her Guru without proper evaluation, perhaps on the heresay of others, so in effect they are dumb/ignorant. Those that did jump off the cliff did show devotion and hopefully smartened up in their next incarnation/s, so now the Guru can teach them. Discrimination is essential. --- mahahradanatha <mahahradanatha wrote: Dear Felicia, I don�t know what your Interpretation of this "allegedly" Indian Story is, should it imply that, to an Avadhoot Guru, intelligence is more important than devotion to the Guru, you have a mistaken notion of the tradition. On the contrary especially amongst the Kaulas, Avadhootas, Nathas and Digambaras Devotion to the Guru is the key to sucess and is the basic requirement,Intelligence is not a prerequiste and never was because the teaching is non dual and way beyond manas, while without Devotion no progress beyond a certain point is possible. There are other sampradayas who rely more heavily on Jnana, but those mentioned above promote Teachings way above caste creed and mental concepts and can lead to sucess without recourse to Mind activity. In fact Mind activity is considered more as an obstacle than an asset, because as one can easily notice following illusive thought constructs most often only strengthen the feeling of superiority to others, this is one of the main obstacles to progress in this path. More than just Humility is needed. No true Avadhoota would mistreat People like the Teacher in your story allegedly does, only because they are not as intelligent as he deems himself to be. Mahahradanatha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.