Guest guest Posted April 6, 2000 Report Share Posted April 6, 2000 Long soliloquy on teaching, part 2:<br><br>"HIERARCHY MISPERCEPTION" continued<br><br>I have often attended workshops with senior teachers at which my current teachers were also attending as students. I see no problem at all with this situation. At times it has actually deepened my respect for the teachers concerned, because I get to see the effort that goes into their practice, and because I realised that although they may be less experienced than the famous senior teachers, they were just as good at teaching and just as committed. And in my first few months I studied with two teachers who attended each other's classes as students without managing to confuse anybody.<br><br>I have also been taught by people who were normally students in the same classes as myself, who were temporarily covering the classes while the regular teachers were away. I didn't have a problem with this situation, nor did anybody else in the classes as far as I could see, and both the people concerned did a good job.<br><br>I have never witnessed people being taught adjustments in a normal class situation. I don't think it would be a good idea, except in an expressed teacher training context where the students had explicitly consented to be adjusted by an inexperienced teacher. But of course, any student in a class with a teacher they don't know is implicitly taking a risk of being adjusted by an inexperienced, clumsy or inept teacher. And there is really nothing a new student can do about this until they have enough experience to be able to perceive it. Which is a different issue and a very serious one.<br><br>Teacher in a self practice group with students. Hmm. Another interesting one that I haven't personally experienced. I guess it would be ok with a teacher and long term students who know each other well, as long as the students already have a reasonable level of independent self practice, and as long as everybody understands and accepts that this isn't a teaching situation. Would be difficult for the teacher if either they or anybody else there had any confusion about the situation. Which, once again, comes back to all the participants being reasonably mature in their attitude. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.