(No subject)

[Guest guest]

Dear Members of the Bhakti List,

 

Mani writes:

*******************************************************************************

My thanks to Murali for explaining Desika's Garuda poems

to us. However, I ask a very fundamental question, one that

I am surprised has not already come up.

*******************************************************************************

 

*I do not quite understand why we as Sri Vaishnavas would

*resort to worshipping Garuda (or even the Lord for that

*matter) for the sake of obtaining something. These are

*kaamyaartha, are they not, lower desires nowhere near

*the pursuit of jnaana, bhakti, and consequently moksha?

 

It is not for the sake of obtaining anything that one worships Garuda,

any other Nitya Suri or Lord Narayana. When one becomes a Prapanna, they give

up all thoughts of their Yogakshemam, because they have the firm faith

(Maha Vishvasam) that the all pervading Lord Narayana will take care of their

spiritual as well as materialistic needs (Sarva Rakshakatvam). Take for

instance the case of Dhruva. His worship of Lord Narayana granted him not

only material benefit (of becoming an emperor) but also gave him the most

exalted status of the pole-star. I never suggested in my post that one must

worship Garuda for Kaamyartha.

 

In fact, I stated Swami Desikan's message that

worship of Garuda bestows Adhyatma Vidya. Although Swami Desikan was a great

Aradhakar of Garuda, never once did he worship Garuda with the intent of

receiving any material benefit. Instead, he sought Adhyatma Vidya in pursuit

of Moksha, which he was blessed with on account of the grace of Garuda Bhagavan

and Bhagavan Hayagriva. In fact, Swami Desikan emphatically declares in the RTS

(if one cares to read Sriman Anbil Ramaswamy's eloquent accounts on this

subject) " do not worry about those things that have no value some value

high value. Go after that which has the highest value". In this context, this

is meant to be taken as "Thirst for Moksha. Nothing else

has greater value. Everything else is useless tinsel". Therefore, it is

absolutely ridiculous to conclude that Swami Desikan has instructed Sri

Vaishnavas to engage in the worship of Lord Narayana, Garuda or for that matter

any other Nitya Suri for the pursuit of any kaamyartha.

 

*******************************************************************************

For example, it is often stated that recitation of the

Sudarshana Mantra can be used as means to ward off disease,

that the Garuda Mantra wards off poisons and snakes, etc.

Appeals to the fantastic mythology of Garuda and the

popular tales concerning his obtaining of amRita are often

told in this context. Aside from the fact that this

tale has nothing to do with Bhagavan Garuda's wisdom or

devotion, these ``recite the mantra and get results''

stories smack of a very unenlightened and selfish form

of religion, one that is not respected very much by

Krishna himself (recall the classification of adhikaaris

in the Gita).

*******************************************************************************

The above comments are best addressed by an Acharya.

However, I shall make my feeble attempts at answering these remarks.

Sri Sampath Rengarajan noted in his reply that many great Mahans are privy to

some Mantram or the other. The

effect of the Mantram can only be experienced and no amount of words can

sufficiently describe the effect of a sincere recantation of the Mantrams

with strict adherence to its practice. I can point out a number of instances

which demonstrate the power of the Mantrams. Swami Desikan is one among

several others that come to mind. I urge Sri Mani to attend one of the

Sudarshana Homams performed by Sri Mukkur Swamigal, where he cures people from

the affliction of the Brahma Rakshasa. Prof. M.G. Prasad demonstrated through

a slide the effect of properly chanting the Sudarshana Maha Mantram during

the performance of the Sudarshana Homam. A beautiful chakram formation in the

flame of the Homa Kundam was there for all to see. I can vouch that this was

no P.C. Sarkar like stunt. This phenomenon defies any scientific or logical

explanation. If there is one, I would love to hear it.

 

Contrary to Mani's remarks, none of the Srivasihnava Acharyas has prescribed

the method of "recite the Mantra and get results". I challenge Mani to come

up with one such instance. In fact they fully believe in Lord Krishna's

message in the Bhagavad Gita "Yetechhati Tatha Kuru" (following the Visvarupa

Darshanam).

 

*******************************************************************************

Please note that my comments are not directed towards

anyone in this group, in any manner.

 

*******************************************************************************

It seems to me that someone who has surrendered his

very self to the Divine Lord should already be free

from these worldly concerns, or at least try to be so.

Is this not why a prapanna is described by Desika as

a kRta-kRtya (one who has done what ought to be done,

and is therefore supremely satisfied in his Self)?

*******************************************************************************

The question in this paragraph has been answered in part above and in part

by Sri Mani's own admission below.

 

*******************************************************************************

I must admit that Desika's vivid and fancy description

of the Puranic tales of Garuda also do not hold my

attention very much. This is admittedly a criticism

of me rather than Swami Desikan, but I fail to see how

contemplation of the Puranic stories of Garuda (which

are obvious mythologies from any perspective, given

that Garuda is a nitya-sUri in our sampradAya) helps

one in the path to God-consciousness.

*******************************************************************************

One must listen to the Upanyasams of our Acharyas to appreciate the truths

that lie buried in our Puranic stories. The Kalakshepams of Sri

Srivatsankachariar Swamigal would be a good starting point.

 

Since my posts seem to be objectionable to Sri Mani, this is my

last post on the subject. I started the series on Garuda Bhagavan in response

to Smt. Satyan's request as a kainkaryam for my Acharyan. I shall communicate

with her through private email. Demands of my professional life have made it

quite difficult to keep up with the activity on the Bhakti list. Therefore,

I request Sri Mani to remove me from the list.

 

Namo Narayana,

 

Muralidhar Rangaswamy