Guest guest Posted March 11, 1997 Report Share Posted March 11, 1997 **************Mani Wrote ...************************************* Aside from the fact that this tale has nothing to do with Bhagavan Garuda's wisdom or devotion, these ``recite the mantra and get results'' stories smack of a very unenlightened and selfish form of religion, one that is not respected very much by Krishna himself (recall the classification of adhikaaris in the Gita) ***************************end quote************************* I had been having this question for a long time. Probably this is what is the inherent manifestation of an ordinary soul's Bheethi. (Or the avidhya or whatever that covers his NYaanam) There could arise some testing situations for which we need an immediate solution, be it a short term one. This is when we tend to fall for 'recite the mantra and get the results'. I feel kinda disheartened to see a BIG list of what all to do, how to do in great detail about the sundhara kaaNdam pArAyaNam. By the side of each modality the 'palan's will also be listed. This looks sorta commercial to me more than anything spiritual. If somebody has a deep devotion and love towards Rama and Sita and especially hanumAn, they should just go ahead and read it however they feel like. I am NOT saying anything against those who read it by some pArAyaNa muRai. It is the question of the order of preference between the mode of pArAyaNam and the devotional aspect to it. We are all (atleast I am) some ordinary soul(s) going through several difficult situations in this samsAram. We very much need some kinda solace. We will definitely be very satisfied if somebody understands our problem and shows us a way to get rid of the obstacles. More so if it is of the form: If ur obstacle is X, Do Y and it will go away. My point is that a person needs to be more mature to realize that these are just kAmyArtha and are nowhere near the bhakthi/prapaththi paths towards mOksham. As Mani says: ******************************************************* It seems to me that someone who has surrendered his very self to the Divine Lord should already be free from these worldly concerns, or at least try to be so. Is this not why a prapanna is described by Desika as a kRta-kRtya (one who has done what ought to be done, and is therefore supremely satisfied in his Self)? ******************************************************* This calls for a good, deep understanding of our religion and a high level of maturity. Is there anything like "recite this, You will get that maturity????:-) :-)" (Just kidding..) I am NOT finding fault with anybody or any mode of bhakthi. These opinions are entirely mine. I am just expressing them out loud. I am open to any suggestions... (Infact i myself am reading sundhara kANdam for my sister's marriage, ofcourse not on any strict timeline. Sometimes i even read some portions twice!! just bcos i feel good about it....It is just the belief in our family to do so..) My 2 cents worth... -Viji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.