Guest guest Posted September 27, 1998 Report Share Posted September 27, 1998 Sri : Srimate Sri Lakshmi Nrusimha Para Brahmane Namaha Srimate ShatakopAya Namaha Srimate Bhagavad RAmAnujAya Namaha Srimate NigamAntha MahAdesikAya Namaha Srimate Sri Adhivan ShatakOpa Yateendra MahAdesikAyA Namaha Srimate Sri Lakshmi - Nrusimha Divya PAdukA Sevaka - Srivan Shatakopa Sri NArAyana Yateendra MahAdesikAya Namaha Dear bhaktAs of Sriman NArAyaNA, namo nArAyaNA . pranAmams. This is the last article on this Bhakti and Prapatti series. adiyEn is thankful to Sriman Sadagopan for kindly correcting the typos and grammatical mistakes and more importantly for his encouraging words. ------------------------------ The most important thing to understand while performing prapatti is that , "Prapatti" (SAdhyaupAyam) as an act by itself is not the reason for one's moksham. Rather , it is the mercy of Sriman NArAyaNA (Siddha upAyam) which is responsible for one's moksham . Prapatti is a SAdhya upAyA which needs to be done by a baddha jIvAtmA. This becomes a vyAjA for Sriman nArAyaNA , the Siddha upAyA, to grant moksham . In front of Siddha upAyA , SAdhya upAyA is "nothing" & can't even be compared. Neverthless , SAdhya upAyA needs to be performed since thats the way Sriman nArAyaNA has ordered ( in Sruti & Smruti) to have a vyAjA (excuse) for Him and thereby grant moksham by being impartial . Similarly ,Bhakti YogA is also a SAdhyaupAyam. Ofcourse , the performance of sAdhyaupAyam is also due to Sriman NArAyaNA's mercy. Since the mumukshu has proper karmA due to various pious deeds and (most importantly ) divine blessings of bhAgavathA(s) and SadAchAryA(s), Sriman NArAyaNA out of His mercy makes him/her perform the sAdhya upAyam prapatti and grants moksham using it as a vyAjA . So , if someone asks the reason for ones moksham , without any hesitation ,it is the siddha upAyam Sriman nArAyanA . The Divya Dampati is both the upAyA (means) & the upEyA (end) . SwAmi Desikan beautifully portrays the state of a prapannA while performing prapatti in the best & unparalleled heart melting pAsuram "nin aruLAm gadhi inRi mattRonRu illEn ....." (ie. There is No other refuge for a prapannA other than the aruL (mercy) of Sriman nArAyaNA ...). The actual performance (angI) of prapatti is composed of the following three acts : 1. Atma samarpanam ie. svaroopa samarpanam : From time immemorial, a baddha jIvAtmA is of the thinking that it is independent on its own . This is the greatest theft since all jIvAtmAs being chetanAs and made up of jn~Anam, are actually the most precious properties of Sriman NArAyaNA . Svaroopa samarpanam refers to the recognition of this fact and the anusandhAnam that one belongs only to Sriman NArAyaNA (not to any demigod) and is not an independent being. It also extends to the recognition and anusandhAnam that all chetanAs and achEtanAs like wife/husband , children , house etc that are associated with one also belong only to Sriman NArAyaNA. 2. Bhara Samarpanam : Recognition and anusandhAnam that the burden of one's (and all chEtanAs & achEtanAs associated with him/her) protection belongs only to Sriman NArAyaNA, the sarva rakshakan & not to oneself. This surrendering of burden of protection is unique for prapatti . One performing Bhakti YOgam will perform only Svaroopa and phala samarpanam & not Bhara Samarpanam . 3. Phala Samarpanam : Recognition and anusandhAnam that the fruit of one's (and all chEtanAs & achEtanAs associated with him/her) protection also belongs only to Sriman NArAyaNA , the sarva phalI. The highly sacred Dvaya Mantram which is eulogized as Mantraratnam is the prapatti mantra and the actaul act of prapatti is performed using this. Thus, prapatti is actually an act which is performed with all its entirety in a moment. This is much like the action of an archer, who after performing preliminary acts like taking the arrow, fitting it to the bow , perceiving and aiming the object etc discharges the arrow for hitting the target ,in a fraction of a second (jIvAtmA is the arrow which hits its target viz. Sriman NArAyaNA ).Infact Upanishads describes this act very well. Such an act of Prapatti is celebrated as the marriage between a jIvAtmA and paramAtmA Sriman NArAyaNA, due to which the jIvAtmA would lead its life totally dedicated in serving Sriman NArAyaNA like a pati vratA. There are various types of prapatti that is performed for obtaining moksham viz. Svanishta , Ukti nishta, AchArya nishta and BhAgavatha nishta. "Svanishta Prapatti" is the culmination of the fully blossomed Bhagavad PremA . For performing Svanishta prapatti (ie. on one's own, without the aid of the AchAryA , though the prapatti sAstrA as such would be learnt from an AchAryA ) one needs to have Very high qualification - likes of Bhagavad RAmAnujA & SwAmi Desikan . The most important ingredient for Svanishta prapatti is the IN & OUT knowledge of the meanings of the three rahasya mantrAs apart from other scriptural knowledge which exactly aids in completing all the requirements for a fruitful prapatti in a proper order/way . Even if one of the requirements gets unfulfilled , Prapatti is not complete & moksham won't be granted by Sriman nArAyaNA. Thats why , Ukti nishta & AchArya nishta is followed even by AchAryAs for their prapatti. Infact , the exact modus operandi of prapatti won't be revealed to a sishyA & a sishyA can possibly know it only during his prapatti & that too if it is in Ukti nishta . In AchArya nishta , that also is not possible . AchAryA passes on the upadesam to his select disciple whom he likes to continue performing "prapatti" for others. In ukti nishta ,since the sishyA repeats whatever the AchAryA says and Sriman NArAyaNA knows its meaning, he/she fulfills all the neccessary requirements of prapatti . In AchArya nishta , ofcourse all the neccessary requirements are taken care by AchAryA himself, while performing the prapatti for his disciple. The fourth type of prapatti is the BhAgavatha Nishta wherein a learned Sri VaishnavA (bhAgavathA) performs prapatti on one's behalf. Rarely does one develop very intense desire to reach Sri VaikuNTham immedietly to join nityasoorIs and muktAs to have uninterrepted bhagavad anubhavam and perform kainkaryam to the Divya Dampati. In such a case, one can perform "Artha prapatti", for which Sriman NArAyaNA mercifully grants mokshA without any delay as per the request. But, almost everyone performs "Dripta Prapatti", for which Sriman NArAyaNA grants mokshA at the end of one's lifetime as per the request. The basic reason for even parama bhAgavathAs to perform "Dripta Prapatti" is purely due to their boundless compassion to rescue all the jIvAtmAs suffering in this world by imparting them the infallible knowledge vouchsafed in the sAstrAs and thereby make everyone realize their svaroopam of being subservient to the Divya Dampati and aid them in performing prapatti . Ofcourse , it is due to the sankalpam of Sriman NArAyaNA that these parama bhAgavathAs exist in this world for the benifit of everyone. They also perform everything as a kainkaryam to the Divya Dampati with sAthvIka tyAgam. Prapatti thus assures moksham for sure , if the requirements were met out in its entirety. If even after undergoing prapatti, one doesn't have full faith in NArAyaNA & resorts to something like demigod worship & this was the case till he/she died,then it is be understood that NArAyaNA hasn't accepted his/her prapatti at all , since the basic qualification of having ananyagatitvam was not met out by him/her during the time of prapatti. Also, even after prapatti ,if a person somehow due to prArabdha karmA resorts to demigod worship and the like, but somehow restores back anytime before his/her death and follows Sri Vaishnavam with reverence to Sriman NArAyaNA and AchAryA ,and develops mahA visvAsam , it is to be understood that the Lord has accepted his/her prapatti . A prapanna should certainly have devotion in the sense of reciting VedAs, Divya Prabandhams, StotrAs , performing Nama Sankeertanams, etc, which are to be carried out as a kainkaryam (service) with sAthvIka thyAgam. Never should a prapanna perform some act as a means of attaining moksham, since he/she has already been assured of it through the prapatti and more importantly such an act exhibits his/her lack of mahA visvAsam and would thereby even negate the previous prapatti. While performing Prapatti, a mumukshu requests for Para Bhakti, Para Jn~Anam and Parama Bhakti from Sriman NArAyaNA and thus it is granted for him/her. Depending upon the mumukshu's karmA, the time at which they will blossom will differ. For instance, NammAzhwAr performed Prapatti unto Sriman NArAyaNA and did not perform Bhakti yOgA. But, AzhwAr went through all these three stages while being in this material world itself. Similarly, some prapannAs may go through these stages and they will be highly immersed in bhagavad anubhavam. But, they are not carrying out these things as an upAyam (ie. means) to attain moksham. Rather they perform it since it is their svaroopam (nature). This is ofcourse done with sAthvIka tyAgam and is known as "sAdhya bhakti". For many , these three stages blossoms only after reaching Sri VaikuNTham. It is however very important to understand that "prapatti" is not some mechanical process that fulfills some conditions . It is the fully blossomed stage of complete understanding of the tattva, hitam & purushArtam . sAstrAs are very merciful in enlisting various things that one would perform in that state of surrender thereby giving rise to its modus operandi . Ofcourse, for mumukshus performing through ukti & AchArya nishta , such thorough knowledge of sAstrAs & rahasya mantrAs is not neccessary. AchAryA takes care of all the requirements for pleasing Sriman nArAyaNA . This is also taken as a vyAjA for granting moksham by Sriman nArAyaNA .That is why, the adoration of AchAryA is even more important than the adoration of Sriman nArAyaNA for a baddha jIvAtmA. There is no possiblity for a baddha jIvAtmA who doesn't have the capacity to perform bhakti yogA ( complete akinchanA ), to ascend to Sri VaikuNTham other than to fully depend on the mercy of his AchAryA who knows the way of performing Prapatti for him. Thus , even one who has transgressed sAstrAs for time immemorial can obtain moksham by the mercy of a sadAchAryA .To repay one's AchAryA for either blessing one with the true & divine knowledge OR initiating him/her into rahasya mantrAs (pancha samskAram) OR performing prapatti for him/her, is an impossibility. To be in accordance with one's svaroopam (nature) , one has to perform AchArya ,BhAgavatha & PerumAL kainkaryam in that order of decreasing priority & these things doesn't mean that one is repaying something to the debt one owes to his/her AchAryA . To understand Prapatti properly , one needs to perform kAlakshebam under the lotus feet of a sadAchAryA & only by his blessings through the exposition of the grantham far supreme viz.Srimad Rahasya Traya SAram, the magnum opus of the Vishnu ghantA avatArA SwAmi Desikan, can one appreciate its glories. It is an unparalleled granthA containing the ocean of insatiable nectar delineating all the things a mumukshu needs to know (tattvA,hitA & purushArthA ) ,presented in such a commanding authority through pramAnAs & logic,which once heard would vanish all the sufferings and turmoils undergone by a jIvAtmA and make it have the unshakable faith on the saving grace of the most merciful Lord Sriman NArAyanA, thereby perform prapatti & attain prapatti nishtA with the impeccable jnAnam obtained from this granthA completely controlling all of its actions, thereby engaging completely in AchArya, BhAgavatha and Bhagavad kainkaryam for the pleasure of Divya Dampati, with no more burdens to be worried about. AzhwAr, EmperumAnAr, Desikan thiruvadigaLE saranam Sri Adhi vaNN shatakOpa yateendra mahAdesikAya namaha Srimad Azhagiyasingar thiruvadigaLe saranam namo nArAyaNA adiyEn rAmAnuja dAsan anantha PadmanAbha dAsan sarvam sri KrishnArpanamastu Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 28, 1998 Report Share Posted September 28, 1998 Sri Anand wrote: > Thus, prapatti is actually an act which is performed with all > its entirety in a moment. Dear Anand, Is this not a slightly misleading statement? All Sri Vaishnavas are agreed, irrespective of "kalai-bhEdam", that prapatti is characterized primarily (or exclusively) by a certain kind of knowledge. The term used for this is "jnAna-veSEsha". Should it not be said that prapatti, for followers of Desika, is primarily a mental resolve with the act as an important "anga" or accessory? After all, the vAkya is "jnAnAn moksha:, ajnAnAt samsAra:". Liberation results from knowledge, ignorance leads to worldly existence. Or, "tam eva viditvA ati mRtyum Eti" -- knowing Him alone, one crosses over death (SvetASvatara upanishad). It was my understanding that in the performance of SaraNAgati, the most important aspect was "mahAviSvAsa", or supreme faith that the paramAtmA SrIman nArAyaNa will undoubtedly save the supplicant. mahAviSvAsa is just a unique kind of knowledge. > Even if > one of the requirements gets unfulfilled , Prapatti is not complete & > moksham won't be granted by Sriman nArAyaNA. If, out of ignorance or unintentional error, someone falls short of the ideal, is it not the greatness of the Lord that he still accepts the devotee? Perfect prapatti a la Nammalvar is a very difficult state to reach. I think our AcAryas' tiruvuLLam was that we should try our best to be perfect prapannas, but our very imperfection is the cause for our prapatti and consequently for His acceptance of us. Sri Desika asks of the Lord: mukhyam ca yat prapadanam svayam api sAdhyam dAtavyam Isa kRpayA tad api tvayaiva | tan me bhavat caraNasangavatIm avasthAm paSyann upAyaphalayor ucitam vidheyAh || O Lord, that perfect prapatti should be accomplished by You Yourself and should be granted by You out compassion. Seeing my condition who am attached to Your feet, You should do the needful with respect to the means and the fruit. [saranaagati Dipika 55] I think if one insists unreasonably on "perfect" prapatti, the very saulabhyam of the Lord gets undermined, and one approaches the very thought of prapatti itself with fear. > The fourth type of prapatti is the BhAgavatha Nishta wherein > a learned Sri VaishnavA (bhAgavathA) performs prapatti on one's behalf. Is this mentioned by Desika or any other pUrvAcArya? This seems against the spirit of the Vedas and consequently the AcAryas' writings. Prapatti should involve a change in the individual who is to be liberated, not merely in someone who does a "proxy" SaraNAgati. Otherwise, God is liable to be accused of unfairness or partiality! Why should the Lord save someone who on their own accord has made no change in their relationship to Him? This is one of Desika's strongest arguments against passive or volition-less SaraNAgati. If I have misunderstood your writing in any manner, I apologize for the error. Can you clarify some of your thoughts on these issues? aDiyEn rAmAnuja-dAsan, Mani Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 28, 1998 Report Share Posted September 28, 1998 On Sep 28, 9:56am, Mani Varadarajan wrote: > Re: Bhakti and Prapatti - 4 > > > The fourth type of prapatti is the BhAgavatha Nishta wherein > > a learned Sri VaishnavA (bhAgavathA) performs prapatti on one's behalf. > > Is this mentioned by Desika or any other pUrvAcArya? > Dear Sri Mani, There is a reference to this, from Swami Desika prabahndam. More later, with the pasuram that actually talks about all these 4 types. adiyEN Sampath Rengarajan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted October 11, 1998 Report Share Posted October 11, 1998 Sri: Srimate Sri Lakshmi Nrusimha ParaBrahmane namaha Dear devotees , namo nArAyaNA . pranAmams . This posting is based on the teachings of bhagavad rAmAnujar as elaborated by swAmi Desikan . Sri Mani Varadarajan wrote: > Sri Anand wrote: > > Thus, prapatti is actually an act which is performed with all > > its entirety in a moment. > > Dear Anand, > > Is this not a slightly misleading statement? All Sri Vaishnavas > are agreed, irrespective of "kalai-bhEdam", that prapatti is > characterized primarily (or exclusively) by a certain kind of > knowledge. The term used for this is "jnAna-veSEsha". Should it > not be said that prapatti, for followers of Desika, is primarily > a mental resolve with the act as an important "anga" or accessory? > The modus operandi explained in Ahirbudhyna samhita, Lakshmi tantra etal further elaborated by many poorvAchAryAs has the "act " of prapatti referring to Atma, bhara and phala samarpanam. These three form the angI . The five angAs doesn't constitute the very act of prapatti . rather they are accessories only . Neverthless , they need to be there for a fruitful prapatti . More later on to what extent Sriman NArAyaNA expects these angAs to be present during various types of prapatti . Jn~Anam is indeed has to be there for performing prapatti . But prapatti is not merely that jn~Anam ( bhagavad seshatvam etc ) . more later . > After all, the vAkya is "jnAnAn moksha:, ajnAnAt samsAra:". Liberation > results from knowledge, ignorance leads to worldly existence. Or, > "tam eva viditvA ati mRtyum Eti" -- knowing Him alone, one crosses > over death (SvetASvatara upanishad). > This is very much true. But one needs to understand what it means . Liberation results from knowledge . But the knowledge by itself is not the liberation . There is a huge difference between these two . From sAstrAs, one needs to firmly understand the tattvAs first . This must result in one obtaining the most important knowledge concerning the sarIra sarIrI bhAvA existing between the jIvAtmA and the paramAtmA. But , a jIvATmA after knowing this tattvA ( jn~Anam of seshatvam to Divya dampati etc ) , should look into what the purushArtam (goal) is . Once that is understood , he/she has to look into what the hitam (means) is . sAstrAs says that for obtaining the purushArtam of moksham there are two hitams bhakti and prapatti accoding to the qualification of a mumukshu . The knowledge so gained should result in adopting any one of the means (sAdhya upAyam) since thats what Sriman NArAyaNA has ordered through sruti and smruti . We can't make our own judgement that by being in such and such a way, we shall obtain moksham ( anyway perumAL is merciful . Why won't he grant moksham to me etc type of attitude.this has no pramAnams from sAstrAs) . So, whatever sAstrAs ( bhagavad Aj~nA) say as hitam has to be followed . If one takes up upAsanA , well and good . There are detailed descriptions on the 32 brahma vidyAs and he can perfect it . If one feels that he can't perform all these things and is beyond his capacity , he can take up the other hitam viz. prapatti . It is to be noted that knowledge on the hitam thus acts as a pre requisite for performing it .. It is important to understand that bhakti is very much issued as a command for a mumukshu to be followed . Hundreds of pramAnams are there for this from upanishads and allied scriptures . Infact , in gItA KrishnA keeps on telling that one has to do bhakti yogam ( bhajasva etc type of vidhi / commands ) .Similarly , prapatti is also enshrined as a vidhi ( command) to be performed ( saranam vraja , AtmAnam mayi nikshipedh , AtmAthmeeya bharanyAsO hi Atma nikshEpa uchyate etc ) . These two are the hitam . Now lets look at the pre requisite for prapatti . One of them is the ananya gatitvam ( no other resort other than Sriman NArAyaNA ) . This the faculty of knowledge (jn~nam) that is needed. Also, the five angAs needs to be known . With respect to prapatti , the statement jn~Anam results in liberation means that once ananyagatitvam is achieved and the hitam prapatti is understood (5 angAs etc ), then it leads to moksham wherein one actually performs the act of prapatti by the mercy of a sadAchAryA. Scriptures say nAma sankeertanam results in moksham , divya desa yAtrA results in moksham , dip in sacred pushkarinIs result in moksham , contact with bhAgavathAs results in moksham , residing at divya desam results in moksham etc etc . All these things mean that it will make a jIvAtmA one day to perform the hitam and attain moksham , because of such pious acts. Thus if a person is devouted and performs such activities , its just a matter of time (few births probably ) for him/her to attain moksham . So the statement as such that divya desa yAtrA leads to moksham is not false since Sriman NArAyaNA guides that jIvAtmA to finally perform either bhakti or prapatti and make it as the vyAjA for granting moksham . Similarly, jn~Anam results into moksham . But the act of prapatti is not the jn~Anam by itself . Goptrutva varanam is an angA of prapatti wherein you have to ask Sriman NArAyaNA for granting the eternal kainkaryam at Sri VaikuNTham . During bhara samarpanam, Sriman NArAyaNA is pleaded to be present in the place of bhakti yogam . These type of things during prapatti are "acts " and are different from the various knowledge that one may have about even prapatti . SwAmi Desikan in Srimad RTS points out the criticism of BhAshyakArar over advaitin's mode of liberation based on the understanding of their interpretation on "tattvamasi" . To those advaitins who claim that liberation is obtained by mere avidhEya jn~Anam based on vAkya janyam , bhAshyakArar says that it is anAdharaNEyam due to upAsanAvidhi vaiyarthyAdhigaL. SwAmi Desikan has already raised the very question you have asked ( no one can be as predictive as swAmi desikan regarding our mode of thinking ) and says that the answer is already given by bhAshyakArar . Thus prapatti is an act that is performed with 5 angAs ( jn~Anam etc becomes a subset ) and not merely jn~Anam about Sriman NArAyaNA's saving grace / His paratvam/ His soulabhyam . It is not merely the seshatva anusandhAnam . The act of Atma nikshepa etc has to be there . > > It was my understanding that in the performance of SaraNAgati, the > most important aspect was "mahAviSvAsa", or supreme faith that > the paramAtmA SrIman nArAyaNa will undoubtedly save the supplicant. > mahAviSvAsa is just a unique kind of knowledge. > The most important angA of prapatti is mahAvisvAsam (supreme faith) . But , that by itself is not prapatti . It is only an angA of prapatti . But what is this mahA visvAsA ? It is the supreme faith on Sriman NArAyaNA that He would grant moksham for the prapatti thus performed ie. Supreme faith on the efficacy of prapatti . Mere knowledge that Sriman NArAyaNA is highly merciful to protect and grant moksham to those who surrender to Him, is not the mahA visvAsam . One has to "surrender" ie. perform prapatti and while surrendering ( act of prapatti) , one should have this supreme faith . It is to be noted that " surrendering" implies that all the modus operandi of prapatti in its entirety is performed and it does not refer to a mere prayer / faith / falling at His Lotus feet etc . MahAvisvAsam as an angam of prapatti doesn't mean that one has to leavedemigod worship and resort to Sriman NArAyaNA alone. Infact, this abstain from demigod worship and resorting to Sriman nArAyaNA alone is called as "ananyagatitvam" a pre-requisite qualification for performing prapatti and is not an angam. For performing any act prescribed in vedAs , faith (visvAsam) is needed. But , heavy emphasis on faith for performing prapatti is prescribed in sAstrAs because one will doubt it in various ways. In Srimad Rahasya Traya sAram , SwAmi Desikan beautifully explains the various doubts that shall arise in one's mind which will lead to one's lack of mahA viswAsam. For instance naichyAnusandhAnam also when done inappropriately will lead to this disaster of doubting prapatti ie. " I am a fool , stupid . Has no qualification . King of Sinners. How can Sriman nArAyaNA grant moksham , the greatest of all things one can obtain, to such a sinner like me, for a simple act of prapatti ? ". Well , this person hasn't understood the thiru uLLam of Divya Dampati at all; he is just emotionally outpouring something. But that emotional outpouring is not born out from the eye of sAstrAs . All devotion and emotions should emerge from the sAstrAs for it is the only guide for a baddha jIvAtmA . If that is not based on sAstrAs , then it is just some blaberring based on aj~nAnam ie.ignorance .All bhagavad anubhavams should arise out of the knowledge as perceived out of the eye of sAstrAs. In this above case, the devotee performing naichyAnusandAnam hasn't understood a,b,c,d of prapatti . When Sriman NArAyaNA Himself promises so many times that He would grant and in the past has done it for many , who is this guy to doubt even Lord ? In front of Lord's mercy , one's sins are nothing . SwAmi Desikan in general discusses five cases in which one would loose mahA viswAsam ( similar to above ) and gives five reasons by which he can strengthen his mahA viswAsam ( purushakAratvam of pirAtti can NEVER be violated by perumAL ; etc ) . Thus, MahA visvAsam is an important angA of prapatti . But it is not the prapatti by itself . --- to be continued --- namo nArAyaNA adiyEn rAmAnuja dAsan anantha padmanAbha dAsan sarvam sri krishnArpanamastu Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.