Doubts in Valivadham and New Doubt about Srimad Ramayanam

January 20, 2003

Dear Sirs,

This seems to be an interesting topic. For this I have heard pulavar keeran's

concept of vali vadham but that does not seem to convince me. Iam also waiting

for learned members of this group like Mr Harikrishnan to answer this.

I have another doubt on srimad Ramayanam.

When maricha was shot by rama, he shouted as “ ah lakshmana…ah seetha in Rama’s

voice” Understanding the cunning motive of maricha, rama could have alerted

Seetha and Lakshmana immediately. Why Rama kept silence?

Thanks,

Srinath

Nanmaaran <nanmaaran wrote:Dear Shri Harikrishnan,

Thanks for your excellent posting on Ramayanam and i have learnt a lot thru

that. I have following doubts for which i request you to clarify.

Can you give the reference sloka or verse where vali accepted that he coveted

Ruma w/o sugriva.? In both valmiki and kamban's work.

When Rama sent emissary twice (hanuman and angada) to the known culprit who

abducted his wife sita, why he did not give a chance to vali?. He could have

sent same hanuman as emissary and requested Vali to release Ruma and to give the

status to sugriva..Even in krishnavataram also we see that our emperumaan

personally takes the position of emissary and asks duriyodana for the rights of

pandavas. Why did Rama fail to do for Vali alone?

Regards,

Nanmaaran

-----------------------------

- SrImate rAmAnujAya namaH -

To Post a message, send it to: bhakti-list

Group Home: bhakti-list

Your use of is subject to

Catch all the cricket action. Download Score tracker

Recommended Posts