Guest guest Posted February 16, 2002 Report Share Posted February 16, 2002 Namaste, I am replying to the earlier discussion on Tat tvam asi and later its discussion in advaita list on grace >On Tue, 12 Feb 2002, nanda chandran wrote: > >> >If that is so then why does Shankara still assert that in the ultimate >> >moment liberation is only possible due to divine grace? >> >--------- >> > >> >Can you give the reference for this quote? >> >> Ravi, I wanted to write to you earlier with the exact references, but have >> been travelling and hence do not have references at hand. But this I can >> tell you : there are two such references that the removal of avidhya is >> effected only by divine grace. One is in Shankara's commentary on the Brahma >> Sutras and the other is in his commentary on the Katha Upanishad. >> > > Maybe others can help here? > > Sri Sadanandaji wrote, This maya of mine is of divine origin. only by surrendering to me one will be able to cross this maaya - says Krishna. Also - any knowledge is not purusha tantra that is it does not depend on the human being. That means knowledge cannot be willed. One can make an effort to gain the knowlege but the knowledge which is not a product of a effort. knowledge is considered as vastu tantra. Like hearing - what I hear does not depend on me but on the source of the noise. Same way. Knowledge has to down on one who mind is prepared. This includes self-knowledge. It is graceful way of saying that it is divine grace that one can gain the knowledge. Shankra wrote in Vivekachuudamani : manushyatvam, mumukshatavam and mahaapurusha samsrayam - thjese is due to the diving grace only. - durlabham trayamevaitat daivanugrahamevacha| manushyatvam mumukshatvam mahapurusha samprayaH| ------------------ Recently i heard an example on grace, If you want to have the warmth of fire, you have to go near it, the grace in the form of heat in fire is always there, Sameway the grace in the form of shastra, guru and myself being brahman is always there, only i need the grace to approach them and not that divine grace is the direct means for ultimate liberation. Also as grace means someone's will is involved and as Sri Sadanadji pointed out any knowledge is not purusha tantra that is it does not depend on the human being. That means knowledge cannot be willed. Viraj Sports - Coverage of the 2002 Olympic Games http://sports. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.