Guest guest Posted March 14, 2003 Report Share Posted March 14, 2003 The discussions on this thread contained some arguments on whether an inference is 'logical' or 'from intuition'. Is it possible to spell out a set of axioms, that cannot be proved by logic, and from which one has to proceed to understand advaita, so that all subsequent inferences must be made through logic (of course we are appealing to a common understanding of what the rules of inferences are). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 14, 2003 Report Share Posted March 14, 2003 Namaste: Axioms: A set of postulates in simple English from the Vedas (Sastras): (1) The Brahman alone exists. (2) The Brahman is not subject to birth or death. (eternal) (3) The Brahman is changeless. (4) The Brahman is omnipresent. Role of faith and conviction: Sastra Pramana - (When I am in doubt, I take the intuition of the seers as spelled out in the Sastras (Upanishads, Brahmasuutras and the Bhagavad Gita) as the Truth). I agree to accept and respect these postulates with faith and conviction. INFERENCE: I know that I exist (no proof is necessary for one's own existence because the very question on my existence is the proof for my existence!). Now I can logically infer non-duality using the above axioms: I exist but I accept that Brahman alone exists and consequently, I have to be the Brahman. My body is not the Brahman because I could witness my body undergoing the changes. My mind and intellect also have undergone with changes at every moment of time and consequently they can't be the Brahman. My perception of everything around me including that of you, others and everything around you and others also change. But everything that I perceive is necessarily an integral part of the Brahman because Brahman is omnipresent. I could conveniently label my perception as 'mAya' the integral part of the Brahman. After a moment of contemplation, I could recognize the existence of something other than my body, mind and intellect within me that is not subject to any change. I could conveniently call this as the spirit or the Atman which is necessarily the changeless Brahman and I am that Atman. This recognition of my true nature is being spelled out in the Upanishads as the 'mahavakyas - the four great statements.' Aham Brahmasmi (I am the Brahman). Tat twaqm asi (That thou art). Ayam Atma Brahman (This is that, Atman is Brahman). Prajnanam Brahman (Brahman is the highest wisdom). I believe that this simplistic interpretation is a good starting point for your elegant question. It seems that in many situations, we don't want to agree with a simple truth and allow the spell of ignorance to occupy our mind. Our ignorance seems to inject the mind with the creative power and enable to produce new notions. The unfulfilled mind increases the rate of production of notions in geometric progression. With the overflowing thoughts, we get fully trapped and we make a move to get out of this mess. After a considerable amount of time, the forgotten wisdom emerges to negate the notions one by one. Suddenly, we get the wake-up call from the rising sun with the light of wisdom to dispel our ignorance and to realize the Truth - "I am the Brahman." In the background we could hear the whispering voice of Sankara saying, "Stop your search; take a moment to contemplate that you are what you are!" warmest regards, Ram Chandran Note: Please note that this is my notion of Advaita and this is not necessarily the Truth! advaitin, "eknath2k" <eknath@u...> wrote: > The discussions on this thread contained some arguments on whether an > inference is 'logical' or 'from intuition'. Is it possible to spell > out a set of axioms, that cannot be proved by logic, and from which > one has to proceed to understand advaita, so that all subsequent > inferences must be made through logic (of course we are appealing to > a common understanding of what the rules of inferences are). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.