Please stop postings on Adhyasa and associated topics

[Guest guest]

Namaste:

 

Inspite of my direct and indirect hints to stop this discussion,

the 'piece-meal conversation' continues enabling Sri Jay to make the

noise!

 

In my young age, I and my brother used to shout at each other and my

grandmother used to advice us that if one of the two keeps quiet,

there will be no more noise! She was quite correct in her assertion

and let us borrow her wisdom and enjoy a peaceful atmosphere by

observing silence!

 

I appreciate your cooperation and understanding in advance,

 

Warmest regards,

 

Ram Chandran

[Guest guest]

Namaste Ramji.

 

Advice accepted, although I am unable to agree that silence is the

best solution in the circumstances.

 

And, if Jay is making noise, why has been invited to present his case

for a debate on a future date? We could have accepted Kathirasan-ji's

stand.

 

I thought there were some errors in Shri Jay's posts that don't pass

the test of commonsense (not prastAnatraya!). I was afraid I may

lose track of them if I postponed my questions to a future date. I

would still maintain that Shri Jay's answers have not satisfied me.

In fact, I feel that he has cleverly skirted the real issues. This

has given rise to more questions than have been answered so far. I

have no choice now but to bury them.

 

Anyway, I don't seem to qualify for the 'future debate' as my touch

with the Vedas is just rudimentary. I can't even claim to know the

Bhagawat Geetha well. Then, what to speak of the BrahmasUtras!

Although it is none of my business, I can't also help wondring how

many on this list are really qualified to engage Shri Jay in a

discussion. As he has asked me, he will naturally ask them if they

are proficinet in Vedas, have done samanvaya etc. etc. How many of

us can answer in the affirmative? So, what we can at best do is

listen. That would be like listening to Parabrahman! If we

understand anything, we are just lucky!

 

Best of luck then.

 

PranAms.

 

Madathil Nair

 

_____________________

 

advaitin, "Ram Chandran" <rchandran@c...>

wrote:

>

> Inspite of my direct and indirect hints to stop this discussion,

> the 'piece-meal conversation' continues enabling Sri Jay to make

the

> noise!

>

> In my young age, I and my brother used to shout at each other and

my

> grandmother used to advice us that if one of the two keeps quiet,

> there will be no more noise! She was quite correct in her

assertion

> and let us borrow her wisdom and enjoy a peaceful atmosphere by

> observing silence!

>

> I appreciate your cooperation and understanding in advance,