Guest guest Posted September 28, 2004 Report Share Posted September 28, 2004 Hello Adi-ji, You certainly seem to have a lot of time on your hands. Yes, I agree that some discussion of personal sadhana would be helpful in this discussion. I see no reason not to allow it this month - it's on topic. From the last several days, I see that the bhakti dynamic is alive and well in advaitin-land! So let me ask and observe, Adi: 1. What is the sadhana function of your newspaper reading? 2. You mention openness and tolerance. What do you do to increase these qualities? You do mention the practice of not applying labels to yourself or others. This is a good one. 3. Those who value tolerance can tend to become upset at the intolerance of others. This leads to being intolerant of others' intolerance. This is not necessary. One can come to see that intolerance is not a virtue without becoming intolerant! Pranaams to all, --Greg Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 28, 2004 Report Share Posted September 28, 2004 advaitin, Gregory Goode <goode@D...> wrote: > Yes, I agree that some discussion of personal sadhana would be helpful in this discussion. Namaste, Here lies the conundrum of Practice! Gita 4:18 karmaNi akarma yaH pashyed akarmaNi cha karma yaH | sa buddhimaan manushhyeshhu sa yuktaH kR^itsna-karma-kR^it.h || One who discerns action in inaction, and non-action in action is the one with wisdom, ever in spiritual union, and an accomplisher of all action. Thus any practice that keeps one aware of it will defeat its purpose! Regards, Sunder Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 28, 2004 Report Share Posted September 28, 2004 Sunder-ji , It is very ironic that this same verse was quoted by me at the beginning of this month's topic and now quoted by You at the end of this month's topic! what a strange co-incidence ! But, when you quote a gita verse, it sounds more Divine. You state, ( Here lies the conundrum of Practice! Gita 4:18 karmaNi akarma yaH pashyed akarmaNi cha karma yaH | sa buddhimaan manushhyeshhu sa yuktaH kR^itsna-karma-kR^it.h || One who discerns action in inaction, and non-action in action is the one with wisdom, ever in spiritual union, and an accomplisher of all action.) and then you conclude ( Thus any practice that keeps one aware of it will defeat its purpose!) and Srangely enough, do you know what Our Beloved Bhagwan Rramana Says ? VERSE 37 -FORTY VERSES ON REALITY The contention, 'Dualism during practice, non-dualism on Attainment', is also false. While one is anxiously searching, as well as when one has found one's Self, who else is one but the tenth man?1 ____________________ 1 - This refers to a traditional story of a party of ten fools who were travelling together. They had to cross a river and on reaching the other shore wanted to check up whether all of them had got safely across. Each one counted in turn, but each one counted the nine others and forgot himself. So they thought the tenth man had been drowned and began to mourn him. Just then a traveller came past and asked them what was the matter. He at once saw the cause of their mistake and in order to convince them he made them walk past him one by one, giving each one a blow as he passed and telling them to count the strokes. http://www.ramana-maharshi.org/m_path/m_path.htm Aum Tat sat ! ps -greg-ji commented that i have a lot of time on my hands - when you are 61 , You live thinking you are going to die any minute and you read and learn thinking you are going to live forever! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 29, 2004 Report Share Posted September 29, 2004 Namaste Sunderji. Did I misunderstand you here? Consider this action of replying you I am now performing. I am sequentially yet fully in my thoughts, words, movement of my finger- tips on the keyboard, the words appearing on the monitor screen, the brilliance of the monitor and the satisfaction that all this gives me. Virtually, I am everywhere fully in every bit of my action and the feelings associated with it. Pedantically, we call this attentiveness. Such pointed involvement in action is great pleasure. It is an intoxication that runs up the spine and makes one roll in a sort of electric ecstasy - not because of the action itself, which any way is jada, but because of one's being Awareness. The only thing I need to remind me is not to have the performership of this action where the ego comes in. So, I am compelled to understand your statement as follows: "Any action that keeps one *aware of his performership in it* defeats its purpose." Am I right Sunderji? Sans that dangerous performership, every moment and movement of ours is ecstasy because we are them in fullness as Awareness. Then, what to speak of devotional practices where I shine as Her in every bit of my thoughts, every tiny atom and pulsation of my body, every breath that goes in and out, and every movement of the tongue that raises its head against the palate to capture the nectar in Her divine names! Oh Ma, make me mad! Incidentally, Adiji, this brings me to your request to write on the significance of DEvI MAhAtmyA on this NavarAtri occasion and Gregji's endorsement of it. A lot has been written about the MAhAtamyA by DEvI upAsakAs the world over and plenty of material is already available on the net. I don't have the competence to tread that area to add anything more. But, on a personal note, every moment is a NavarAtri or ShivarAtri, Ashtami, Navami or Chaturdasi (eighth, ninth or fourteenth lunar day) for me. I chant the MAhAtmyA without any initiation and without following prescribed rules, as I am convinced that one does't need any to call and extol one's own Mother. I see Her as Awareness in every word that I chant - the place, sequence, order or time of the chanting doesn't matter, therefore. I do that most of the time and She keeps me company. In a sense, more than a Mother, She is my girl-friend now - a constant companion. Since She is understood as Consciousness, there is no question of separating us in any way. In my perambulations, therefore, be they in lonely places or along busy city streets with traffic thundering by, I chant Her names and I am then fully with Her. That is a thought which bestows a thousand crimson sunsets on my heart at every chant of Her innumerable sweet names! What more to ask for other than remain in this intoxicating `madness'!? Thus, I am the teenage boy who follows Her everywhere listening to Her anklet clanks and divine music, which my doctors attribute to hearing impairment. I tell them not to treat me for it, for I will be a loser without it. Or, those who call such sweet experiences hallucinations, like our Bhuvaneswar Chilkuriji once did on this forum, can they `cure' me at all? Those who warn me against chanting the MAhAtmya, Sahasra NAmAvali and Trishati (one thousand names and three hundred names of ShrI LalitA respectively) without proper initiation, also advise me against sharing these experiences with others, for then these experiences might vanish. Let them! But, my advaitia tells me that my nascent companionship with Her as Consciousness is interminable. I don't, therefore, look for any more guarantees! Mounted on a tiger or lion or seated on the lotus, She is there everywhere I look. The teenager in me yearns to hug those animals and roll over in the joy of playful abandon as She watches by. And, when She raises Her eyes to look at the splendour of the skies from atop the VindhyA mountains, the little boy runs up to give Her company in Her all-encompassing gaze holding on to Her speckled glittering attire! Yes. I am being emotional for I yearn for more of this madness. There was this vEdAntin `madman' of yore in Kerala called NArAnattu Bhranthan (NArAnattu Madman) who used to roll up huge boulders up the hill all day, a la the Greek Sisyphus, and then roll them down at dusk laughing in sheer abandon at the futility of human toil. I want to be in his shoes – but with a difference. I need my girl-friend to stand beside me and join me in my roaring laughter. That is the reason why I am so very much into DEvI MAhAtmya and other prayers! May She, my eternal girlfriend, grant me my wish! I hope I haven't disappointed you, Adiji, by only dwelling on the personal. I don't have anything scholarly to offer you. This has come from the heart. What more can I offer Her this NavarAtri? PraNAms (in joyful tears). Madathil Nair _____________________ advaitin, "Sunder Hattangadi" <sunderh> wrote: > > Here lies the conundrum of Practice! > > Gita 4:18 > > karmaNi akarma yaH pashyed akarmaNi cha karma yaH | > sa buddhimaan manushhyeshhu sa yuktaH kR^itsna-karma-kR^it.h || > > One who discerns action in inaction, and non-action in action is the > one with wisdom, > ever in spiritual union, and an accomplisher of all action. > > Thus any practice that keeps one aware of it will defeat its > purpose! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 29, 2004 Report Share Posted September 29, 2004 advaitin, "Madathil Rajendran Nair" <madathilnair> wrote: > Namaste Sunderji. > > Did I misunderstand you here? > > "Any action that keeps one *aware of one's performership in it* defeats > its purpose." > > Am I right Sunderji? > > Sans that dangerous performership, every moment and movement of ours > is ecstasy because we are them in fullness as Awareness. > Oh Ma, make me mad! Namaste Madathilji, You have articulated it better than I did. Every question of spiritual knowledge (adhyatma vidya) that I faced in my personal life had an answer in the Gita that satisfied me. So it has become a habit to refer to it whenever any such question is raised. For example, to your question, I thought of : Gita 11:33 - ......... nimittamAtraM bhava ................. 9:10 - mayAdhyakSheNa prakR^itiH sUyate........ 13:22 - upadraShTAnumantA cha bhartA bhoktA maheshvaraH ............ In the same vein as 11:33 above, I have found 23 more 'injunctions' that Krishna gave Arjuna (and in effect to all humanity), that I constantly invoke for the 'shreyas'. Regards, Sunder Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 29, 2004 Report Share Posted September 29, 2004 Namaste Sunderji, As obvious as it should have been, I hadn't thought of looking for answers in the Gita. Would you be willing to cite the other 23 "injunctions?" Thanks, Bob Freedman Sunder Hattangadi wrote: > > Gita 11:33 - ......... nimittamAtraM bhava ................. > > 9:10 - mayAdhyakSheNa prakR^itiH sUyate........ > > 13:22 - upadraShTAnumantA cha bhartA bhoktA maheshvaraH > ........... > > In the same vein as 11:33 above, I have found 23 more > 'injunctions' that Krishna gave Arjuna (and in effect to all > humanity), that I constantly invoke for the 'shreyas'. > > > Regards, > > Sunder > Discussion of Shankara's Advaita Vedanta Philosophy of nonseparablity of Atman and Brahman. > Advaitin List Archives available at: http://www.eScribe.com/culture/advaitin/ > To Post a message send an email to : advaitin > Messages Archived at: advaitin/messages > > > Links > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 29, 2004 Report Share Posted September 29, 2004 advaitin, Bob Freedman <rlfreed@p...> wrote: > Namaste Sunderji, > > As obvious as it should have been, I hadn't thought of looking for > answers in the Gita. Would you be willing to cite the other 23 > "injunctions?" > Namaste, Posting one daily may be helpful! When the 'injunction' does not fit a situation fully, I do have to extend the search to other verses until a satisfactory fit is achieved. Regards, Sunder 1. niyataM kuru karma tvaM karma jyaayo hyakarmaNaH | shariirayaatraapi cha te na prasid.hdhyedakarmaNaH || 3:8 || Do thou perform (thy) bounden duty, for action is superior to inaction, and even the maintenance of the body would not be possible for thee by inaction. http://blessingsonthenet.com/ has audio of all the verses also. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 29, 2004 Report Share Posted September 29, 2004 Thank you, Sunderji, for agreeing to do this! I've been looking for that "satisfactory fit" all my life ;-) Bob Freedman advaitins wrote: > advaitin, Bob Freedman <rlfreed@p...> wrote: > >>Namaste Sunderji, >> >>As obvious as it should have been, I hadn't thought of looking for >>answers in the Gita. Would you be willing to cite the other 23 >>"injunctions?" >> > > > Namaste, > > Posting one daily may be helpful! When the 'injunction' > does not fit a situation fully, I do have to extend the search to > other verses until a satisfactory fit is achieved. > > > Regards, > > Sunder > > 1. > niyataM kuru karma tvaM karma jyaayo hyakarmaNaH | > shariirayaatraapi cha te na prasid.hdhyedakarmaNaH || 3:8 || > > Do thou perform (thy) bounden duty, for action is superior to inaction, > and even the maintenance of the body would not be possible for thee by > inaction. > > http://blessingsonthenet.com/ has audio of all the verses also. > > > > > Discussion of Shankara's Advaita Vedanta Philosophy of nonseparablity of Atman and Brahman. > Advaitin List Archives available at: http://www.eScribe.com/culture/advaitin/ > To Post a message send an email to : advaitin > Messages Archived at: advaitin/messages > > > Links > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 30, 2004 Report Share Posted September 30, 2004 Dear Nairji, What a wonderful post! Bhakti with the sword of Advaita! The devotion of a vira! Warm regards, Chittaranjan advaitin, "Madathil Rajendran Nair" <madathilnair> wrote: > I see Her as Awareness in every word that I chant - the > place, sequence, order or time of the chanting doesn't > matter, therefore. I do that most of the time and She > keeps me company. In a sense, more than a Mother, She > is my girl-friend now - a constant companion. Since She > is understood as Consciousness, there is no question of > separating us in any way. > > In my perambulations, therefore, be they in lonely places > or along busy city streets with traffic thundering by, I > chant Her names and I am then fully with Her. That is a > thought which bestows a thousand crimson sunsets on my > heart at every chant of Her innumerable sweet names! > What more to ask for other than remain in this > intoxicating `madness'!? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 30, 2004 Report Share Posted September 30, 2004 Namaste Sunderji, Thank you very much. I am looking forward to the further 22 posts in this series. May I suggest that the subject of the thread be changed to '23 Injunctions of Lord Krishna' or something on those lines. praNAms, Venkat - M Posting one daily may be helpful! When the 'injunction' does not fit a situation fully, I do have to extend the search to other verses until a satisfactory fit is achieved. Regards, Sunder ALL-NEW Messenger - all new features - even more fun! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.