Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Intellectual Understanding vs Direct Realization

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Hi group:

Understanding is not enough? This trying to get the "Direct

Realization"is much like trying to get water from a mirage, once

it is seen as impossible the effort will stop by itself. For some

seekers this statement of intellectual vs direct understanding seems

to be a truth like a rock,but why make a difference between

intellectual and living understanding?Let do a little experiment,Just

sit with eyes closed and watch the thoughts arise.just watch them...

appear, stay, then disappear .... on The seeing. This SEEING , this

ordinary everyday awareness is IT. IT is nothing new. It doesn't

matter what the thoughts are (I understand it but I'm not living it

ect...etc...), you are The SEEING of those thoughts.It's common to

make this distinction, but it is really not as relevant as it is made

out to be. What would be the difference between these two aparent

modes of understanding? Probably it is anticipated that the shift

from intellectual to true understanding will cause some change in

one's experiencing of daily life. As long as that position is taken

there is no recognition of the ever present apperception, whether

labeled intellectual or other wise.What you look for is what you

always already are and it can not be brought into experience as it is

the experiencing itself. It is the intuitive recognition that you are

the unseen seeing.And when you try to make the shift from

intellectual to a alleged true understanding, it means that there is

no recognition of the ever present.Relaxation of this effort follows

when it is clear (whether one calls it intellectually or not that

this effort an exercise in futility.All effort is a product of

misunderstanding.The seeing cannot be an object to Itself.You seems

to still looking for something different, maybe a special event to

happens and it's not happening, an then there is a belief,that you

are not living it or that you are missing a "direct realization of

it". But relax,there is nothing different that will happen, this

Ordinary Everyday Awareness IS IT.

Atagrasin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Namaste,

 

sounds relax viewpoint.....

i wish i could sit with "eyes closed now and watch the thoughts

arise.................."

 

....but then i need to think about my work that i have to do.....

i have no choice ....there is the work which will be done by the

power of God.....there will be many different tasks to

fulfill.....lots of forms and minds to work with......included my own

 

....the forms and minds are different to each?....yes and no

if i'm Aware of the Real.....there is no difference.....means, there

is God and the power of Maya working....just like everyday....

 

if i'm not Aware of the Real.....there is me and you and

everybody ....percieved as different forms ...seperated to each....by

the ego mind.....by my own ego mind......(there is never any other

ego existing....in whole of my existence...except mine....means, as

non-realised Self)

 

we have the choice to be Aware of the Real...or of the Unreal....

 

no "transformation" needed to realise the whole Self?

 

i think it take time to accept that all our own Being is not

different than any other Being......that there is only One Being.....

 

....during this time......we can discuss about many things...and

accept and learn many things.....

 

up to us...

 

there is nobody else

 

....the thoughts we are watching don't belong to us?

 

to whoever they belong.....they are There....like everybody else.....

 

why things are There?....because we Are

 

wish a good day

 

Regards and Love

 

Marc

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

advaitin, "atagrasin" <k1c2@h...> wrote:

>

> Hi

group:

> Understanding is not enough? This trying to get the "Direct

> Realization"is much like trying to get water from a mirage, once

> it is seen as impossible the effort will stop by itself. For some

> seekers this statement of intellectual vs direct understanding seems

> to be a truth like a rock,but why make a difference between

> intellectual and living understanding?Let do a little

experiment,Just

> sit with eyes closed and watch the thoughts arise.just watch them...

> appear, stay, then disappear .... on The seeing. This SEEING , this

> ordinary everyday awareness is IT. IT is nothing new. It doesn't

> matter what the thoughts are (I understand it but I'm not living it

> ect...etc...), you are The SEEING of those thoughts.It's common to

> make this distinction, but it is really not as relevant as it is

made

> out to be. What would be the difference between these two aparent

> modes of understanding? Probably it is anticipated that the shift

> from intellectual to true understanding will cause some change in

> one's experiencing of daily life. As long as that position is taken

> there is no recognition of the ever present apperception, whether

> labeled intellectual or other wise.What you look for is what you

> always already are and it can not be brought into experience as it

is

> the experiencing itself. It is the intuitive recognition that you

are

> the unseen seeing.And when you try to make the shift from

> intellectual to a alleged true understanding, it means that there is

> no recognition of the ever present.Relaxation of this effort follows

> when it is clear (whether one calls it intellectually or not that

> this effort an exercise in futility.All effort is a product of

> misunderstanding.The seeing cannot be an object to Itself.You seems

> to still looking for something different, maybe a special event to

> happens and it's not happening, an then there is a belief,that you

> are not living it or that you are missing a "direct realization of

> it". But relax,there is nothing different that will happen, this

> Ordinary Everyday Awareness IS IT.

> Atagrasin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Namaste,

 

> i wish i could sit with "eyes closed now and watch the thoughts

> arise.................."

>

> ...but then i need to think about my work that i have to do.....

> i have no choice ....there is the work which will be done by the

> power of God.....there will be many different tasks to

> fulfill.....lots of forms and minds to work with......included my own

>

this is where surrender comes in. Just trust in the Self. Do not worry

about what will happen to your work when you are not thinking. When you

are established in the thoughtless state, the body will move when it is

required to move and the thoughts that are needed to perform your work

will arise in your mind when necessary. You are not required to do

anything only to remain as "Awareness". "everything else will be added

onto you"

 

 

Best wishes

 

Christiane

 

• Terms of

> Service.

>

>

Monsoonhouse Int.

Kovalam/Kerala

contact: christianecameron

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Namaste Christiane,

 

....don't worry....there is nothing "required" to anybody...

everybody is free to choose the path of Self-realisation one

day....or not.......

and so...to "stay in Awareness" is free choice....it just

happen....or not

 

Awareness .....is silence....

in silence there is nothing what "will be added to .."....but there

is just Being....

 

....the task of life is Self-realisation......

 

God know that already everybody is "Self-realised"....and so don't

expect anything.......

there could be something non-realised in God-consciousness?

 

God is sometimes non-realised?

 

i believe not......maybe we aren't when we are not in silence....

 

wish to enjoy God .......yourSelf.......

 

intensiv talk this days...i should remember mySelf....in silence....:)

 

Regards and love

 

Marc

 

 

 

advaitin, christiane cameron

<christianecameron@m...> wrote:

>

> Namaste,

>

>

> > i wish i could sit with "eyes closed now and watch the thoughts

> > arise.................."

> >

> > ...but then i need to think about my work that i have to do.....

> > i have no choice ....there is the work which will be done by the

> > power of God.....there will be many different tasks to

> > fulfill.....lots of forms and minds to work with......included

my own

> >

> this is where surrender comes in. Just trust in the Self. Do not

worry

> about what will happen to your work when you are not thinking. When

you

> are established in the thoughtless state, the body will move when

it is

> required to move and the thoughts that are needed to perform your

work

> will arise in your mind when necessary. You are not required to do

> anything only to remain as "Awareness". "everything else will be

added

> onto you"

>

>

> Best wishes

>

> Christiane

>

>

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > •

Terms of

> > Service.

> >

> >

> Monsoonhouse Int.

> Kovalam/Kerala

> contact: christianecameron@m...

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...