Guest guest Posted March 11, 2003 Report Share Posted March 11, 2003 Dear group I got so many interesting messages here on the subject of boring I have not even "emptied my bladder" as Sri Richard noted it. LOL There is someone close to me who has said that she does not have many thoughts during meditation and because it is boring she wont meditate. She actually wants thoughts which is diametrically opposed to what I want. Now she is getting more thoughts as an effect of taking a university philosophy course. I agree with what Miles posted on the boring mind. Could it be just tamasic mental states appearing? It that were true, she would have gone into the highest Buddhist states of Jnana or absorption. I don't recall the exact time but I remember is was not very many mind moments of no thoughts to go into the highest state. Therefore, when people say they were thoughtless, it may be they are not aware of subtle thoughts. As for myself, most of my meditation with wall to wall thoughts could be noted as being boring, but since I have such a great desire for Pure Being, that I wont characterize it as boring, just blowing away the smoke of mental tendencies. Occasionally I do get some real silence and to me it is an exhilarating experience, which may be similar to snorting coke. I am not a drug person, but tried it may years ago twice and the silence I occasionally get it similar to the clarity and power that one gets on that drug. I noted that I want free drugs for life to a friend and that friend did not understand. As I progress, sorry I mean deepen, LOL, I notice that my mind states are one of increasing clarity and mental power, similar to those drug experiences mentioned above. I am going to copy and paste many of these informative messages and send it to you know who in the other room. Its now time for breakfast of "Freedom Fries". The U.S. congress is retaliating so today changed the name. LOL. Love, Not Boring Alton Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 11, 2003 Report Share Posted March 11, 2003 Dear Group, this is an interesting thread. What is for sure: the true silence is never boring. If there is boredom the sooner one comes out of it the better. If it happens frequently during (sitting) meditation it is possibly better not to meditate for so long stretches. One has to find out for oneself. One also can catch this feeling and ask deep within: Who is feeling boring? More and more this should become the practice - but for sure: the I-I in the Heart is NOT boaring. This is a mental state which has to be overcome also. Possibly sometimes one has to bear it patiently - and embrace it in surrender. In Sri Ramana Gabriele Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 11, 2003 Report Share Posted March 11, 2003 Dear Gabriele: No one will ever be able to say you are boring, that's for sure. Love, Alton Dear Group,this is an interesting thread. What is for sure: the true silence is never boring.If there is boredom the sooner one comes out of it the better. If it happens frequently during (sitting) meditation it is possibly better not to meditate for so long stretches. One has to find out for oneself. One also can catch this feeling and ask deep within: Who is feeling boring? More and more this should become the practice - but for sure: the I-I in the Heart is NOT boaring. This is a mental state which has to be overcome also. Possibly sometimes one has to bear it patiently - and embrace it in surrender. In Sri RamanaGabriele Post message: RamanaMaharshi Subscribe: RamanaMaharshi- Un: RamanaMaharshi- List owner: RamanaMaharshi-owner Shortcut URL to this page: /community/RamanaMaharshi Your use of is subject to the Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 11, 2003 Report Share Posted March 11, 2003 Dear Sri Gariele and ALL: I do not know about boredom. I do not know about your boredom. But I do know about the boredom that I-I have experienced. It has nothing to do with sitting meditation or formal time-wise vichara. I speak of a boredom that appeared on its own. Because while many persons speak and write about vichara and meditations at certain times I refer to a boredom born of continuous sadhana. I am trying to elucidate a part of the death throes of ego--the dying gasps of the "i". michael --- gabriele_ebert <g.ebert wrote: > Dear Group, > this is an interesting thread. > What is for sure: the true silence is never boring. > > If there is boredom the sooner one comes out of it > the better. > If it happens frequently during (sitting) meditation > it is possibly > better not to meditate for so long stretches. One > has to find out for > oneself. One also can catch this feeling and ask > deep within: Who is > feeling boring? More and more this should become the > practice - but > for sure: the I-I in the Heart is NOT boaring. This > is a mental state > which has to be overcome also. Possibly sometimes > one has to bear it > patiently - and embrace it in surrender. > > In Sri Ramana > Gabriele > > > > Web Hosting - establish your business online http://webhosting. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 11, 2003 Report Share Posted March 11, 2003 Dear Michael, Are you really saying that boredom is part of the dying-process of ego coming from continous sadhana? Please say more about. In Sri Ramana Gabriele RamanaMaharshi, Michael Bowes <rmichaelbowes> wrote: > Dear Sri Gariele and ALL: > > I do not know about boredom. I do not know about your > boredom. But I do know about the boredom that I-I > have experienced. It has nothing to do with sitting > meditation or formal time-wise vichara. I speak of a > boredom that appeared on its own. Because while many > persons speak and write about vichara and meditations > at certain times I refer to a boredom born of > continuous sadhana. I am trying to elucidate a part > of the death throes of ego--the dying gasps of the > "i". > > michael > --- gabriele_ebert <g.ebert@g...> wrote: > > Dear Group, > > this is an interesting thread. > > What is for sure: the true silence is never boring. > > > > If there is boredom the sooner one comes out of it > > the better. > > If it happens frequently during (sitting) meditation > > it is possibly > > better not to meditate for so long stretches. One > > has to find out for > > oneself. One also can catch this feeling and ask > > deep within: Who is > > feeling boring? More and more this should become the > > practice - but > > for sure: the I-I in the Heart is NOT boaring. This > > is a mental state > > which has to be overcome also. Possibly sometimes > > one has to bear it > > patiently - and embrace it in surrender. > > > > In Sri Ramana > > Gabriele > > > > > > > > > > > > > Web Hosting - establish your business online > http://webhosting. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 11, 2003 Report Share Posted March 11, 2003 Dear All, It seems to me that boredom is a sign of the setting in of dispassion with the material world and a necessary preliminary stage for detachment. A sign of progress. If boredom sets in during mediation than its nothing other but a game of the ego not wanting to die. Then only the sword of vichara, who is it that is bored, helps. In Aruanachalananda Christina Dear Group, this is an interesting thread. What is for sure: the true silence is never boring. If there is boredom the sooner one comes out of it the better. If it happens frequently during (sitting) meditation it is possibly better not to meditate for so long stretches. One has to find out for oneself. One also can catch this feeling and ask deep within: Who is feeling boring? More and more this should become the practice - but for sure: the I-I in the Heart is NOT boaring. This is a mental state which has to be overcome also. Possibly sometimes one has to bear it patiently - and embrace it in surrender. In Sri Ramana Gabriele Sponsor if (document.domain.indexOf("") != -1) document.domain=""; var lrec_target="_top"; var lrec_URL = new Array(); lrec_URL[1] = "http://rd./M=245783.2925235.4380522.2152211/D=egroupweb/S=1705077076:HM/A=1485589/R=0/id=flashurl/*http://www.atlanticvideo.com/ccom/clients"; var link="javascript:LRECopenWindow(1)"; var lrec_flashfile = 'http://us.a1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/a/1-/flash/us_catholic/300_250_b.swf?clickTAG='+link+''; var lrec_altURL = "http://rd./M=245783.2925235.4380522.2152211/D=egroupweb/S=1705077076:HM/A=1485589/R=1/id=altimgurl/*http://www.atlanticvideo.com/ccom/clients"; var lrec_altimg = " "; var lrec_width = 300; var lrec_height = 250; <http://rd./M=245783.2925235.4380522.2152211/D=egroupweb/S=1705077076:HM/A=1485589/R=2/id=noscript/*http://www.atlanticvideo.com/ccom/clients> Post message: RamanaMaharshi Subscribe: RamanaMaharshi- Un: RamanaMaharshi- List owner: RamanaMaharshi-owner Shortcut URL to this page: /community/RamanaMaharshi Terms of Service <> . Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2003 Report Share Posted March 12, 2003 Dear Alton, it is interesting to note that the empty mind, so interesting to some is "boring' to others. My teacher says that for meditations to go deep, then Self-knowledge must be a part of it. (Our minds quiet each night during deep sleep, but since there is no Self-knowledge involved here, it does not bring Self-realization.) It may be that with the one close to you, that she can get to the empty mind, but has no idea of what "to do with it." (For me, the empty mind is a place of peace, and a place where I look to my own deep Being, and a place where I see that I do not need even one idea to exist. Since this supports my Self-knowledge as one who is not even one single thought, then this experience -- together with the subtle discrimination that this experence makes possible -- is one that brings me real inner peace, and I find highly desirable.) It is also funny that while you still struggle with thoughts, that your other does not. My wife and I have the opposite situation; My mind often gets quiet pretty quickly, and she says that hers rarely does. Her mind is the quietest, I think, in satsang and when I read to her from "Song of Ribhu." WE are not two, Richard RamanaMaharshi, " UNBOUND" <unbound@h...> wrote: > Dear group I got so many interesting messages here on the subject of boring I have not even "emptied my bladder" as Sri Richard noted it. LOL > > There is someone close to me who has said that she does not have many thoughts during meditation and because it is boring she wont meditate. She actually wants thoughts which is diametrically opposed to what I want. Now she is getting more thoughts as an effect of taking a university philosophy course. I agree with what Miles posted on the boring mind. Could it be just tamasic mental states appearing? > It that were true, she would have gone into the highest Buddhist states of Jnana or absorption. I don't recall the exact time but I remember is was not very many mind moments of no thoughts to go into the highest state. Therefore, when people say they were thoughtless, it may be they are not aware of subtle thoughts. > > As for myself, most of my meditation with wall to wall thoughts could be noted as being boring, but since I have such a great desire for Pure Being, that I wont characterize it as boring, just blowing away the smoke of mental tendencies. > > Occasionally I do get some real silence and to me it is an exhilarating experience, which may be similar to snorting coke. I am not a drug person, but tried it may years ago twice and the silence I occasionally get it similar to the clarity and power that one gets on that drug. I noted that I want free drugs for life to a friend and that friend did not understand. > As I progress, sorry I mean deepen, LOL, I notice that my mind states are one of increasing clarity and mental power, similar to those drug experiences mentioned above. > > I am going to copy and paste many of these informative messages and send it to you know who in the other room. > > Its now time for breakfast of "Freedom Fries". The U.S. congress is retaliating so today changed the name. LOL. > > Love, > Not Boring Alton Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2003 Report Share Posted March 12, 2003 Dear Gabriele: That may be true; but really I don't know for sure. michael --- gabriele_ebert <g.ebert wrote: > Dear Michael, > Are you really saying that boredom is part of the > dying-process > of ego coming from continous sadhana? Please say > more about. > > In Sri Ramana > Gabriele > > > RamanaMaharshi, Michael Bowes > > <rmichaelbowes> wrote: > > Dear Sri Gariele and ALL: > > > > I do not know about boredom. I do not know about > your > > boredom. But I do know about the boredom that I-I > > have experienced. It has nothing to do with > sitting > > meditation or formal time-wise vichara. I speak > of a > > boredom that appeared on its own. Because while > many > > persons speak and write about vichara and > meditations > > at certain times I refer to a boredom born of > > continuous sadhana. I am trying to elucidate a > part > > of the death throes of ego--the dying gasps of the > > "i". > > > > michael > > --- gabriele_ebert <g.ebert@g...> wrote: > > > Dear Group, > > > this is an interesting thread. > > > What is for sure: the true silence is never > boring. > > > > > > If there is boredom the sooner one comes out of > it > > > the better. > > > If it happens frequently during (sitting) > meditation > > > it is possibly > > > better not to meditate for so long stretches. > One > > > has to find out for > > > oneself. One also can catch this feeling and ask > > > deep within: Who is > > > feeling boring? More and more this should become > the > > > practice - but > > > for sure: the I-I in the Heart is NOT boaring. > This > > > is a mental state > > > which has to be overcome also. Possibly > sometimes > > > one has to bear it > > > patiently - and embrace it in surrender. > > > > > > In Sri Ramana > > > Gabriele > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Web Hosting - establish your business > online > > http://webhosting. > > Web Hosting - establish your business online http://webhosting. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2003 Report Share Posted March 12, 2003 Dear Richard or anyone: Richard:it is interesting to note that the empty mind, so interesting to some is "boring' to others. My teacher says that for meditations to go deep, then Self-knowledge must be a part of it. (Our minds quiet each night during deep sleep, but since there is no Self-knowledge involved here, it does not bring Self-realization.) It may be that with the one close to you, that she can get to the empty mind, but has no idea of what "to do with it." Alton: Ramana, I read, said that you can Realize in swoon, but not in deep sleep. So, I presume there is more awareness in swoon. I presume that swoon is when you faint, but to me there is practically no awareness when you faint, so I am slightly confused. What about dreams, can one Realize during a dream if it is a lucid dream? Also,If you remember your deep sleep and you are the Self during deep sleep, why is not the memory enough to enable Realization. "She" said that I have a model and teachings that I believe in, that makes having a silent mind or no thoughts of value, but she does not, so it is not valuable to her. Is "she" right that I have been brainwashed so that I will get joy from a silent mind or Realization, but others who don't have that conditioning wont? I do believe that if someone had the Realization and did not have the cosmology to go along with it, they would only be freaked by it and might commit themselves to a mental ward or take Prozac. Richard again:(For me, the empty mind is a place of peace, and a place where I look to my own deep Being, and a place where I see that I do not need even one idea to exist. Since this supports my Self-knowledge as one who is not even one single thought, then this experience -- together with the subtle discrimination that this experience makes possible -- is one that brings me real inner peace, and I find highly desirable.) It is also funny that while you still struggle with thoughts, that your other does not. My wife and I have the opposite situation; My mind often gets quiet pretty quickly, and she says that hers rarely does. Her mind is the quietest, I think, in satsang and when I read to her from "Song of Ribhu." Atlon: When your mind gets quiet pretty quickly, you are then thoughtless, or just have fewer thoughts? It you mind got totally silent would you not go automatically into Samadhi states? Or are you talking about relative quiet? Thanks in advance for any members to reply. Mahalo, Alton is so far two,three, four, and many more. Maybe I can have multiple Realizations with this split personality. ROFLMBO. Bhattathity M P: Do you have some alternative meanings for ROFLMBO? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2003 Report Share Posted March 12, 2003 Dear Alton, Most teachers recommend meditation when awake. I have been watching the dream state, seeing what I can see from gross to subtle, as a aide to discrimination. Clearly I can experience the dream body, dream world, dream senses and sream emotions. I have not been able to see, so far dream thoughts. I also have not yet (as far as I can remember) been able to dream meditate. I would not way that I have been brainwashed to get joy from the empty mind, though I find it there (for me it is more 'inner peace' than 'joy'). Again, my teacher says is that what is experienced depend entirely on "Where one stands." it is most likely that when I experience the empth mind and when your wife experiences it, we are looking from different 'stands.' Also, for me (and I think for many others who meditate) what happens is an open minded (and open hearted) looking to see what is there, and to see for myself what is true. This does not seem like brainwashing to me. It seems more like seeing what is there. When my mind is quiet, then there are no thoughts (there are also times where there are few thoughts). Most of the time it does not (yet) seem to me like a samadhi state. I still am aware of me and the quiet mind, so it is, so far, not nearly as 'deep' as it gets. With the quiet mind, this is also a kind of 'timeless' state. We normally measure time by activity or by the passing of thoughts. When there are no thoughts, it seems to me that the sense of passage of time is very different. Perhaps others could comment on this. I have had periods where it seemed like I was "standing in the Silence." This seemed very deep to me. This silence does not depend on outer silence, but is much more interior. So far the longest (in worldly time) that this has lasted is a few hours. We are not two, Richard RamanaMaharshi, " UNBOUND" <unbound@h...> wrote: > Dear Richard or anyone: > > > Richard: > it is interesting to note that the empty mind, so interesting to some > is "boring' to others. My teacher says that for meditations to go > deep, then Self-knowledge must be a part of it. (Our minds quiet > each night during deep sleep, but since there is no Self- knowledge > involved here, it does not bring Self-realization.) It may be that > with the one close to you, that she can get to the empty mind, but > has no idea of what "to do with it." > Alton: > Ramana, I read, said that you can Realize in swoon, but not in deep sleep. > So, I presume there is more awareness in swoon. I presume that swoon is when you faint, but to me there is practically no awareness when you faint, so I am slightly confused. > What about dreams, can one Realize during a dream if it is a lucid dream? Also,If you remember your deep sleep and you are the Self during deep sleep, why is not the memory enough to enable Realization. > > "She" said that I have a model and teachings that I believe in, that makes having a silent mind or no thoughts of value, but she does not, so it is not valuable to her. Is "she" right that I have been brainwashed so that I will get joy from a silent mind or Realization, but others who don't have that conditioning wont? I do believe that if someone had the Realization and did not have the cosmology to go along with it, they would only be freaked by it and might commit themselves to a mental ward or take Prozac. > > > > Richard again: > (For me, the empty mind is a place of peace, and a place where I look > to my own deep Being, and a place where I see that I do not need even > one idea to exist. Since this supports my Self-knowledge as one who > is not even one single thought, then this experience -- together with > the subtle discrimination that this experience makes possible -- is > one that brings me real inner peace, and I find highly desirable.) > > > It is also funny that while you still struggle with thoughts, that > your other does not. My wife and I have the opposite situation; My > mind often gets quiet pretty quickly, and she says that hers rarely > does. Her mind is the quietest, I think, in satsang and when I read > to her from "Song of Ribhu." > > Atlon: > When your mind gets quiet pretty quickly, you are then thoughtless, or just have fewer thoughts? It you mind got totally silent would you not go automatically into Samadhi states? Or are you talking about relative quiet? > Thanks in advance for any members to reply. > > Mahalo, > Alton is so far two,three, four, and many more. > Maybe I can have multiple Realizations with this split personality. ROFLMBO. > Bhattathity M P: Do you have some alternative meanings for ROFLMBO? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2003 Report Share Posted March 12, 2003 --- Dear Alton You wrote: > Richard: > it is interesting to note that the empty mind, so interesting to some > is "boring' to others. My teacher says that for meditations to go > deep, then Self-knowledge must be a part of it. (Our minds quiet > each night during deep sleep, but since there is no Self-knowledge > involved here, it does not bring Self-realization.) It may be that > with the one close to you, that she can get to the empty mind, but > has no idea of what "to do with it." > Alton: > Ramana, I read, said that you can Realize in swoon, but not in deep sleep. > So, I presume there is more awareness in swoon. I presume that swoon is when you faint, but to > me there is practically no awareness when you faint, so I am slightly confused. > What about dreams, can one Realize during a dream if it is a lucid dream? Also,If you remember > your deep sleep and you are the Self during deep sleep, why is not the memory enough to enable > Realization. Ramana said on several occaisions that Self Realisation for the ajnani is only possible in the waking state -hence it's value.[see Talks] > > "She" said that I have a model and teachings that I believe in, that makes having a silent > mind or no thoughts of value, but she does not, so it is not valuable to her. Is "she" right Yes .people have had experiences akin to an awakening i.e.losing the sense of ' me 'without ending the vasanas .This Ramana calls a first stage awakening {see Letters} - the second stage is when the vasanas are burned out and harmless .But without a model - people do not know what is happening to them and become very confused .They may go to a psych. with an identity crisis problem .Unless one has studied this Teaching one would not know what is going on .There is a famous case of Suzanne Segal who this happened to .She has written a book .She thought she was going mad and visited many psychs .who couldn't help her .She then met Jean Klein who put her in context and told her what had happenned ,and all was well .I have forgotten the Title of the book regretably . > that I have been brainwashed so that I will get joy from a silent mind or Realization, but > others who don't have that conditioning wont? The brain needs washing .This teaching cleanses and purifies the mind by surrender and self enquiry so that an awakening can safely take place .Without the conditioning of the teaching people will be confused and disorientated as was Suzanne Segal . I do believe that if someone had the Realization > and did not have the cosmology to go along with it, they would only be freaked by it and might > commit themselves to a mental ward or take Prozac. Yes ,as above . Trust this clarifies the question somewhat , Love as ever , in His Grace , Alan > > > Everything you'll ever need on one web page from News and Sport to Email and Music Charts http://uk.my. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2003 Report Share Posted March 12, 2003 Dear Alan: Here is a link for Suzanne Segal. Also, thanks for you views on "boring". I will post more soon on it. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=Suzanne+Segal&btnG=Google+Search Aloha, Alton --- Dear AltonYou wrote:> Richard:> it is interesting to note that the empty mind, so interesting to some > is "boring' to others. My teacher says that for meditations to go > deep, then Self-knowledge must be a part of it. (Our minds quiet > each night during deep sleep, but since there is no Self-knowledge > involved here, it does not bring Self-realization.) It may be that > with the one close to you, that she can get to the empty mind, but > has no idea of what "to do with it." > Alton: > Ramana, I read, said that you can Realize in swoon, but not in deep sleep.> So, I presume there is more awareness in swoon. I presume that swoon is when you faint, but to> me there is practically no awareness when you faint, so I am slightly confused. > What about dreams, can one Realize during a dream if it is a lucid dream? Also,If you remember> your deep sleep and you are the Self during deep sleep, why is not the memory enough to enable> Realization.Ramana said on several occaisions that Self Realisation for the ajnani is only possible in thewaking state -hence it's value.[see Talks] > > "She" said that I have a model and teachings that I believe in, that makes having a silent> mind or no thoughts of value, but she does not, so it is not valuable to her. Is "she" rightYes .people have had experiences akin to an awakening i.e.losing the sense of ' me 'without endingthe vasanas .This Ramana calls a first stage awakening {see Letters} - the second stage is whenthe vasanas are burned out and harmless .But without a model - people do not know what ishappening to them and become very confused ..They may go to a psych. with an identity crisis problem .Unless one has studied this Teaching one would not know what is going on .There is afamous case of Suzanne Segal who this happened to .She has written a book .She thought she wasgoing mad and visited many psychs .who couldn't help her .She then met Jean Klein who put her incontext and told her what had happenned ,and all was well .I have forgotten the Title of the bookregretably .> that I have been brainwashed so that I will get joy from a silent mind or Realization, but> others who don't have that conditioning wont? The brain needs washing .This teaching cleanses and purifies the mind by surrender and selfenquiry so that an awakening can safely take place .Without the conditioning of the teachingpeople will be confused and disorientated as was Suzanne Segal .I do believe that if someone had the Realization> and did not have the cosmology to go along with it, they would only be freaked by it and might> commit themselves to a mental ward or take Prozac.Yes ,as above .Trust this clarifies the question somewhat , Love as ever , in His Grace , Alan > > > Everything you'll ever need on one web pagefrom News and Sport to Email and Music Chartshttp://uk.my. Post message: RamanaMaharshi Subscribe: RamanaMaharshi- Un: RamanaMaharshi- List owner: RamanaMaharshi-owner Shortcut URL to this page: /community/RamanaMaharshi Your use of is subject to the Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2003 Report Share Posted March 12, 2003 Dear Alan and Alton, Suzanne Segal's book is called "Collision with the Infnite." A small part of the book is on the web here: http://www.realization.org/page/doc0/doc0095.htm Rob - "Alan Jacobs" <alanadamsjacobs <RamanaMaharshi> Wednesday, March 12, 2003 11:53 PM Re: [RamanaMaharshi] Re: Boring >... There is a > famous case of Suzanne Segal who this happened to .She has written a book .She thought she was > going mad and visited many psychs .who couldn't help her .She then met Jean Klein who put her in > context and told her what had happenned ,and all was well .I have forgotten the Title of the book regretably . > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2003 Report Share Posted March 12, 2003 Dear Alton, > I do believe that if someone had the Realization and > did not have the cosmology to go along with it, they > would only be freaked by it and might commit themselves > to a mental ward or take Prozac. Ramana Maharshi himself is an example. He didn't know what happened to him. In the words of David Godman: "Years later, when he was recollecting this experience he said that he thought at the time that he had caught some strange disease. However, he thought that it was such a nice disease, he hoped he wouldn't recover from it. At one time, soon after the experience, he also speculated that he might have been possessed. When he discussed the events with Narasimhaswami, his first English biographer, he repeatedly used the Tamil word avesam, which means possession by a spirit, to describe his initial reactions to the event." -- quoted from http://www.davidgodman.org/rteach/jd1.shtml Rob - UNBOUND RamanaMaharshi Wednesday, March 12, 2003 3:01 PM Re: [RamanaMaharshi] Re: Boring Dear Richard or anyone: Richard:it is interesting to note that the empty mind, so interesting to some is "boring' to others. My teacher says that for meditations to go deep, then Self-knowledge must be a part of it. (Our minds quiet each night during deep sleep, but since there is no Self-knowledge involved here, it does not bring Self-realization.) It may be that with the one close to you, that she can get to the empty mind, but has no idea of what "to do with it." Alton: Ramana, I read, said that you can Realize in swoon, but not in deep sleep. So, I presume there is more awareness in swoon. I presume that swoon is when you faint, but to me there is practically no awareness when you faint, so I am slightly confused. What about dreams, can one Realize during a dream if it is a lucid dream? Also,If you remember your deep sleep and you are the Self during deep sleep, why is not the memory enough to enable Realization. "She" said that I have a model and teachings that I believe in, that makes having a silent mind or no thoughts of value, but she does not, so it is not valuable to her. Is "she" right that I have been brainwashed so that I will get joy from a silent mind or Realization, but others who don't have that conditioning wont? I do believe that if someone had the Realization and did not have the cosmology to go along with it, they would only be freaked by it and might commit themselves to a mental ward or take Prozac. Richard again:(For me, the empty mind is a place of peace, and a place where I look to my own deep Being, and a place where I see that I do not need even one idea to exist. Since this supports my Self-knowledge as one who is not even one single thought, then this experience -- together with the subtle discrimination that this experience makes possible -- is one that brings me real inner peace, and I find highly desirable.) It is also funny that while you still struggle with thoughts, that your other does not. My wife and I have the opposite situation; My mind often gets quiet pretty quickly, and she says that hers rarely does. Her mind is the quietest, I think, in satsang and when I read to her from "Song of Ribhu." Atlon: When your mind gets quiet pretty quickly, you are then thoughtless, or just have fewer thoughts? It you mind got totally silent would you not go automatically into Samadhi states? Or are you talking about relative quiet? Thanks in advance for any members to reply. Mahalo, Alton is so far two,three, four, and many more. Maybe I can have multiple Realizations with this split personality. ROFLMBO. Bhattathity M P: Do you have some alternative meanings for ROFLMBO? Post message: RamanaMaharshi Subscribe: RamanaMaharshi- Un: RamanaMaharshi- List owner: RamanaMaharshi-owner Shortcut URL to this page: /community/RamanaMaharshi Your use of is subject to the Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 12, 2003 Report Share Posted March 12, 2003 Dear Rob: I can always depend of you to find the source of anything. Now please do it with the Self and let me know how to find it? You cant find it in the thinking You cant find it in the visual You cant find it in the feelings You can't find it by negating You cant find it in the seeing, Can you find it in the Being? Love, Alton Dear Alton, > I do believe that if someone had the Realization and > did not have the cosmology to go along with it, they > would only be freaked by it and might commit themselves > to a mental ward or take Prozac. Ramana Maharshi himself is an example. He didn't know what happened to him. In the words of David Godman: "Years later, when he was recollecting this experience he said that he thought at the time that he had caught some strange disease. However, he thought that it was such a nice disease, he hoped he wouldn't recover from it. At one time, soon after the experience, he also speculated that he might have been possessed. When he discussed the events with Narasimhaswami, his first English biographer, he repeatedly used the Tamil word avesam, which means possession by a spirit, to describe his initial reactions to the event." -- quoted from http://www.davidgodman.org/rteach/jd1.shtml Rob - UNBOUND RamanaMaharshi Wednesday, March 12, 2003 3:01 PM Re: [RamanaMaharshi] Re: Boring Dear Richard or anyone: Richard:it is interesting to note that the empty mind, so interesting to some is "boring' to others. My teacher says that for meditations to go deep, then Self-knowledge must be a part of it. (Our minds quiet each night during deep sleep, but since there is no Self-knowledge involved here, it does not bring Self-realization.) It may be that with the one close to you, that she can get to the empty mind, but has no idea of what "to do with it." Alton: Ramana, I read, said that you can Realize in swoon, but not in deep sleep. So, I presume there is more awareness in swoon. I presume that swoon is when you faint, but to me there is practically no awareness when you faint, so I am slightly confused. What about dreams, can one Realize during a dream if it is a lucid dream? Also,If you remember your deep sleep and you are the Self during deep sleep, why is not the memory enough to enable Realization. "She" said that I have a model and teachings that I believe in, that makes having a silent mind or no thoughts of value, but she does not, so it is not valuable to her. Is "she" right that I have been brainwashed so that I will get joy from a silent mind or Realization, but others who don't have that conditioning wont? I do believe that if someone had the Realization and did not have the cosmology to go along with it, they would only be freaked by it and might commit themselves to a mental ward or take Prozac. Richard again:(For me, the empty mind is a place of peace, and a place where I look to my own deep Being, and a place where I see that I do not need even one idea to exist. Since this supports my Self-knowledge as one who is not even one single thought, then this experience -- together with the subtle discrimination that this experience makes possible -- is one that brings me real inner peace, and I find highly desirable.) It is also funny that while you still struggle with thoughts, that your other does not. My wife and I have the opposite situation; My mind often gets quiet pretty quickly, and she says that hers rarely does. Her mind is the quietest, I think, in satsang and when I read to her from "Song of Ribhu." Atlon: When your mind gets quiet pretty quickly, you are then thoughtless, or just have fewer thoughts? It you mind got totally silent would you not go automatically into Samadhi states? Or are you talking about relative quiet? Thanks in advance for any members to reply. Mahalo, Alton is so far two,three, four, and many more. Maybe I can have multiple Realizations with this split personality. ROFLMBO. Bhattathity M P: Do you have some alternative meanings for ROFLMBO? Post message: RamanaMaharshi Subscribe: RamanaMaharshi- Un: RamanaMaharshi- List owner: RamanaMaharshi-owner Shortcut URL to this page: /community/RamanaMaharshi Your use of is subject to the Post message: RamanaMaharshi Subscribe: RamanaMaharshi- Un: RamanaMaharshi- List owner: RamanaMaharshi-owner Shortcut URL to this page: /community/RamanaMaharshi Your use of is subject to the Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 13, 2003 Report Share Posted March 13, 2003 Dear Sri Unbound Alton, If you tell me who is trying to find it, I'll answer your question. Haha, sorry, couldn't resist. Bhagavan's devotee Papaji liked to say that trying to find the Self is like hunting for your glasses when they are already on your nose and you are looking through them. Love, Rob - UNBOUND RamanaMaharshi Thursday, March 13, 2003 2:36 AM Re: [RamanaMaharshi] Re: Boring Dear Rob: I can always depend of you to find the source of anything. Now please do it with the Self and let me know how to find it? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.