Thirumaalai - aazhvar's 2 different anubhavams

[Guest guest]

In a Thirumaalai paasuram, aazhvar's anubhavam is

 

pachchai maamalai pole maeni, pavazhavaaik kamala chengaN

achchutha amararErE, aayartham kozhundae ennum

ichchuvai thavira yaan poY indiraloGamalum

achchvai perinum vanedane, arangamanagarulanae

 

meaning he does not want to miss such anubhavam in Bhuloka Vaikundam.

 

In a following verse, the anubhavam is

 

veda nool pirayam nooru, manusar tham puguvaraelum

paadhiyum uRangip pogum, ninRathil padhinaiyandu

paedhai palaganathagum, pasi pini mooppu thunBam

aaddhalal piravi vaendane, arangamanagarulanae

 

meaning aazhvar does not want a piravi.

 

Is there something to be reconciled between the two anubhavams? The former

may not be possible with the latter (no piravi). Adiyen had the pleasure of briefly

talking to Sriman Murali Rangaswamy Swamin about this. We thought it might

be a good idea to obtain all bhaagavathas' clarifications and anubhvams on this

matter.

 

aazhvar thiruvadigalE charanam

 

sowmyanarayanan