Fwd: Thirumaalai - aazhvar's 2 different anubhavams - Sriman Sundar's reply

[Guest guest]

Sriman Sundar Saranathan pointed out that this has been clarified by none other than

Sri PeriaVachanPillai swami in his vyakyanam.

 

Smt. Sumitra Vardharajan has explained this

at:http://www.acharya.org/vyakyanam/thirumalai/tmalai14.html

 

more bhagavathaa experiences/explanations on this topic will be more nectar to the ears!

 

 

aazhvar thiruvadigalE charanam sowmyanarayanan

 

adiyen..

sowmyanarayanan

 

Comment: DomainKeys? See http://antispam./domainkeys

Wed, 21 Sep 2005 15:06:40 -0000

"Sundar Saranathan" sundar138

Opalvn

Re: Thirumaalai - aazhvar's 2 different anubhavams

In-1fb.11706ea3.30623094

User-Agent: eGroups-EW/0.82

Sender: notify

sri:

srimathE rAmAnujaya nama:

 

dear swamin,

your question has been answered by our Sri PeriaVachanPillai swami

in his vyakyanam..

 

Smt. Sumitra Vardharajan has explained this at:

http://www.acharya.org/vyakyanam/thirumalai/tmalai14.html

 

This is the index of

it:http://www.acharya.org/vyakyanam/thirumalai/index.html

 

Your question is answered in part 14.

 

adiyEn rAmAnuja dAsan,

s. sundar

 

Oppiliappan, Opalvn@a... wrote:

>

> In a Thirumaalai paasuram, aazhvar's anubhavam is

>

> pachchai maamalai pole maeni, pavazhavaaik kamala chengaN

> achchutha amararErE, aayartham kozhundae ennum

> ichchuvai thavira yaan poY indiraloGamalum

> achchvai perinum vanedane, arangamanagarulanae

>

> meaning he does not want to miss such anubhavam in Bhuloka

Vaikundam.

>

> In a following verse, the anubhavam is

>

> veda nool pirayam nooru, manusar tham puguvaraelum

> paadhiyum uRangip pogum, ninRathil padhinaiyandu

> paedhai palaganathagum, pasi pini mooppu thunBam

> aaddhalal piravi vaendane, arangamanagarulanae

>

> meaning aazhvar does not want a piravi.

>

> Is there something to be reconciled between the two anubhavams?

The former

> may not be possible with the latter (no piravi). Adiyen had the

pleasure of

> briefly

> talking to Sriman Murali Rangaswamy Swamin about this. We thought

it might

> be a good idea to obtain all bhaagavathas' clarifications and

anubhvams on

> this

> matter.

>

> aazhvar thiruvadigalE charanam

>

> sowmyanarayanan