The Lost Treasure

[Guest guest]

Srimate SrivanSatakopa Sri Vedanta Desika Yatindra Mahadesikaya nama:

 

 

 

The Lost Treasures

 

 

 

A wealthy philanthropist built a palatial Dharmasaala (rest house) at Srirangam,

with the lofty purpose of accommodating all wayfarers who came to worship Sri

Rangaraja. The choultry provided all facilities for pilgrims, with comfortable

rooms to stay in, facilities for performing daily ablutions and sumptuous food

at appropriate intervals. All those who stayed at the Dharmasaala were extremely

grateful to the generous donor, who, in turn, was pleased beyond measure at the

opportunity for service to the Lord's devotees. Word of this munificence and

convenience spread and the Dharmasaala became the favourite destination of all

pilgrims to Srirangam. Countless were those who benefited from its conveniences.

 

 

 

 

 

The philanthropist grew old and entrusted the management of the choultry to his

progeny, who too carried on their father's work sincerely. In time and in tune

with the general decline in standards of ethics and Dharma, the management of

the rest house became progressively indifferent, with the successors of the

philanthropist showing less and less inclination for altruistic activities,

resulting in the vast Dharmasala falling gradually into disrepair and becoming

dysfunctional. And one sad day, the last pillar supporting the once-magnificent

columns fell, marking the closure of an institution that had served thousands in

its hay day. As if waiting for the event, a building promoter moved in and

constructed an impressively ugly block of match-box-like tenements, where there

once stood the magnificent Dharmasala. Thus was lost to posterity a veritable

treasure house.

 

 

 

This narration is neither fable nor fairy-tale, but a true-life story which has

happened with deplorable regularity, not only at Srirangam, but at many other

holy places. Buildings in ruins, with washed-out sign boards hanging askew and

bearing the barely-visible name of some charity or the other, are a common sight

at almost all Divyadesams.

 

 

 

While this is one aspect of our losing bequeathed treasures due to indifference

and inattention, there is another and more precious genre of heirlooms which we

may well have lost forever. And what is more, most of us haven't even realised

the magnitude of the loss and continue to wallow in blissful ignorance about its

enormity.

 

 

 

The immaculate Vedas and their explanatory manuals like the Itihaasas, Puranas,

Dharma Shastras, etc. are glorious guidebooks designed to pilot us safely

through the mine-field of Samsara and to reach us safely at the portals of

Paradise. These works of worship, propagated by the Lord Himself or His chosen

messengers-Maharshis, Sages and Acharyas-- have been handed down from generation

to generation, serving as a bright beacon to all those floundering in the

interminable gloom of Samsara. They function too as guideposts amidst the thorny

and confusing mundane maze, steering us in the right direction whenever we are

confronted by bewildering crossroads of choice. It is these which form the most

precious treasure bequeathed to us by our elders, the most valuable of heirlooms

which generations of our forebears have protected, preserved, propagated and

passed on, for the benefit of posterity.

 

 

 

 

 

Due to inadvertence and indifference, already we have suffered quite a heavy and

irreparable loss, by way of disappearance of portions of Shastras, particularly

Vedas, from currency. For instance, the Atharva Veda was all but lost a few

decades ago and it is only due to the enthusiastic and energetic efforts of a

few Mahatmas that there is now a healthy rejuvenation in its study. Even now,

students and exponents of this fourth among Vedas are to be found in a small

number in Gujarat, though it is slowly spreading to other places.

 

 

 

Though Vedas are reputed to be beyond numbers ("Anantaa vai Vedaa:"),we

understand from Scriptures that there were no less than 1180 Shaakhas of the

Shruti extant in the not too distant past, each with its own Samhita, Aaranyaka

and Upanishad components. And all these Shakhas had their own votaries, engaged

in study, propagation and preservation of the Vedas. However, what we have now

is pitifully small in comparison.

 

 

 

We know of the Taittireeya Shakha, with the Taittireeya Samhita, Taittireeya

Braahmanam and the Taittireeya Upanisad, all of which have been remarkably well

preserved. However, granting that the Upanishad generally forms the concluding

part of a particular Veda Shakha, many of the Upanishads we have now, must have

been part of independent Shakhas, though not a trace remains of the rest. The

Kousheetaki Upanishad, for instance, is the sole remnant of the Saankaayana

Shakha, which must have been a wide-ranging and voluminous body of Vedic wisdom.

Though the Katopanishad is still extant, its Aaranyakam is nowhere to be found.

The loss we have thus suffered is incalculable and irreparable. What we have

lost are not mere books, but treasure houses of wisdom.

 

 

 

Coming to more recent times, within the last thousand years, we have managed to

lose many more precious heirlooms. Sri Nathamuni was the first protagonist of

our Visishtaadvaita Sampradaya ("Naathopagyam pravrittam") in this Kali Yuga. By

all accounts, he is reputed to have been a repository of pure devotion,

selflessness, vairaagyam and other sterling virtues, endowed with divine vision.

Though he is remembered for all these accomplishments, the moment we hear his

holy name, what springs to our mind is his wonderful and painstaking compilation

of the Naalayira Divya Prabandam, which had, by his time, almost vanished from

currency. He also set them to music and arranged for their recital at various

temples. Had it not been for this great Acharya and his Herculean efforts, we

would have lost the priceless treasure of Aruliccheyal, the ecstatical

outpourings of enlightened Azhwars.

 

 

 

It is therefore extremely ironical that Sri Nathamuni's own great works,

 

Yoga Rahasyam and Nyaaya Tattvam, are no longer available to us. The former was

a treatise on Yoga, while the latter was a voluminous work involving

interpretation of the Nyaaya Shastra according to Visishtaadvaitic tenets,

criticising the Gautama Nyaaya Sutras in the process. We learn of these great

works, only from copious references thereto by Swami Desikan in his various

works like Nyaaya Siddhaanjanam and Nyaaya Parisuddhi. According to Sri

Sudarsana Bhattar, Sri Ramanuja too, in his Sri Bhashya, has quoted briefly from

Nyaaya Tattvam.

 

 

 

Another great loss Srivaishnavas have suffered is the disappearance of Sri

Alavandar's path-breaking works Maha Purusha Nirnayam (establishing the

supremacy of Sriman Narayana) and Kashmira Agama Praamaanyam, which is said to

validate the Pancharatra Agama and its Vedic source, the Ekaayana Shakha. That

these works definitely existed, is again to be derived only from Swami Desikan's

references and quotes. Our sense of loss is further compounded when we learn

that Sri Yamunacharya's Siddhi Trayam (consisting of the Atma Siddhi, Isvara

Siddhi and Samvit Siddhi) too is available only in portions. To quote

Dr.M.Narasimhachary, "It is a matter of regret that all these three Siddhis

suffer from gaps and the extant text is only a fragment of an originally larger

work".

 

 

 

We come next to the works of Swami Desikan, the most prolific author among

Srivaishnava Acharyas. While it is indeed our good fortune that the major

portion of Sri Venkatanatha's works is remarkably well preserved, it is

simultaneously a matter of deep regret that several of his works too have been

lost. Sri Vedanta Desikan is reputed to have composed a magnificent and

voluminous commentary on Tiruvaimozhi, named "Nigama Parimalam", and another

Tamizh work by name "Tirumudi Adaivu", which are no longer extant. A similar

commentary on Kanninunsirutthaambu, aptly named "Madhurakavi Hridayam", is also

no longer available, which fate is shared by a host of Tamizh Prabandams of

Swami, titled "Pandu, Kazhal, Ammaanai, Oosal and Esal", apparently addressed to

Sri Deivanayakan of Tiruvaheendrapuram. "Steyaa Avirodham", a work justifying

Sri Tirumangai Mannan's unorthodox ways of fund-raising for good causes, is also

lost, as also "Adhikarana Darpanam". Only portions of Tattva Teeka (an elaborate

commentary on Sri Bhashyam) are available, as also of the "Sata Dooshani".

 

 

 

We hear too that Vyaakhyaana Chakkravartthi Sri Periyavaacchaan Pillai's

commentary on Periyaazhwar Tirumozhi is partially lost.

 

 

 

This, then, is a brief Status Paper on the priceless treasures of ancient and

unmatched wisdom that we have lost over the centuries.

 

 

 

In this context, we have to remember with gratitude Mahtamas who toiled hard and

spent whole lifetimes in searching for, restoring, editing and publishing rare

works of Acharyas. They were not endowed with unlimited supply of funds nor had

an army of supporters. Yet, with a missionary zeal for the protection and

preservation of Poorvacharya Sreesooktis, they sacrificed their all to ensure

that whatever works were available did not meet the same fate as the ones lost.

Two haloed names that spring to our mind in this regard are Tarkaarnava

Abhinavadesika Uttamur Sri Veeraraghavacharya Swamy and Prativaadi Bhayankaram

Sri Annangaracharya Swamy of Kanchi. Though both were prolific writers, they

displayed greater enthusiasm in publishing works of Poorvacharyas than their

own. The constant and continuing efforts of Sri Puttur Krishnamacharya Swamy too

merit special mention in this regard. The good work of institutions like the

Sanskrit Academy of Melkote (who have brought out critical editions of Sri

Bhashyam with various commentaries) also deserves great appreciation and

encouragement.

 

 

 

Though these Mahatmas' contribution is matchless, we can still endeavour to

emulate them to the extent possible, in identifying works of both Poorvacharyas

and later ones, for preservation. Many of these works are still unpublished,

especially numerous ones of various Srimad Azhagiasingars who adorned the

ascetic throne of Sri Ahobila Mutt and are currently available in the form of

manuscripts, many on palm leaves and similar perishable material. I am sure

similar works by distinguished Acharyas of Srimad Andavan Ashramam and Sri

Parakala Matam also exist, in similar need of preservation and publication.

Since use of paper for composition in our religious institutions is less than a

century old, earlier works must be on Taala Patram or Panai Olai, likely to

disintegrate anytime due to their age and disappear forever from our midst.

 

 

 

Even in respect of published works, though we come across quotes from several

old and hoary works like the commentary of Sri Govindaraja on Srimad Ramayanam,

that of Sri Veeraraghavacharya on Srimad Bhagavatam, the commentaries on Srimad

Rahasyatrayasaram like Sri Saaraasvaadini of Sri Tirukkudandai Desikan and Sri

Saarabodhini (of Injimedu Srimad Azhagiasingar) and that of Sri

Mahamahopaadhyaaya Chetlur Swami, we rarely get to set eyes on them. These works

need to be reprinted.

 

 

 

Against this rather bleak background of partial and total loss of the

accumulated fonts of wisdom, the recent efforts by inspired individuals to

identify, catalogue, preserve and publish hitherto unpublished manuscripts of

Acharyas, deserve all appreciation, encouragement and support. With the advanced

digital technology now available, scanning or even typing out these works from

their originals on palm leaf or ancient paper should be possible, which would be

the first step in preservation. Once the works are available in electronic form,

the possibilities are endless.

 

 

 

Most of these works may be in Sanskrit, many of them may be on esoteric or

subtle points of Shastra not of immediate interest to the common man-despite all

this, what we have to remember is that they emanated from erudite and

enlightened Acharyas who composed these works not as personal memorabilia, but

out of a fervent desire to inform and educate us. They are works of devotion

which would guide us on the right path by their mere presence in our home. (My

late, revered father, apart from his other sterling qualities and deep

attachment to Srimad Ramayanam, was an acknowledged authority both on shorthand

and Shakespeare. Though I have regrettably not inherited his enthusiasm for

either, I still preserve his books as their very sight reminds me of him and his

devotion. Similarly, works of our Acharyas too inspire us by their very presence

and sight, even if we are unable to profit from their wisdom immediately.) Once

these original works are preserved, translations to benefit the scholar and

layman alike, could be attempted.

 

 

 

As Srivaishnavas, it is hence our sacred duty to ensure that these bequests are

properly appreciated, treated with the veneration they deserve, protected

against the ravages of distortion and loss and preserved in all their pristine

purity, so that the generations that follow would also benefit from the ageless

wisdom.

 

 

 

What are the ways in which we can help?

 

 

 

We can search sincerely for such old and published/unpublished works of the

aforesaid kind, existing in our own library/those of institutions and

individuals likely to have such books or palm leaf manuscripts and make them

available to those who have undertaken the onerous task of converting them into

e-format.

 

 

 

Those among us who have the technical expertise can help in the above process by

offering consultancy/active participation.

 

 

 

Once the stage for publication comes, we can financially support the printing of

one or more works of Acharyas.

 

 

 

We can spread the word among our relatives/acquaintances about the need for the

entire endeavour and make them aware of the crying need for preserving our

heirlooms.

 

 

 

There can be no better tribute to Sri Hayagriva, who holds a book in His hand,

than to help in protecting works on religion and spirituality. And the venerated

authors of the unpublished manuscripts would definitely be gladdened at their

works getting published at long last, benefiting the entire Vaishnavite

community.

 

 

 

Come, let us help in this holy mission!

 

 

 

Sriamte Sri LakshmiNrisimha divya paduka sevaka SrivanSatakopa Sri Narayana

Yatindra Mahadesikaya nama:

 

dasan, sadagopan

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Guest guest]

> Srimate SrivanSatakopa Sri Vedanta Desika Yatindra Mahadesikaya nama:

 

 

shriirastu

 

In context of this posting, here are a few sites where scanned books

are online and I have found quite a few books at the site " the

million book project". Here are a couple of downloads.

 

http:www.archive.org/details/BrihadaranyakopanishadBhashya

http://www.archive.org/details/SvetasvataradyopanishadPusushasukthaBashyaPart1

http://www.archive.org/details/PrapannaParijatamOfSriVatsyaVaradacharya

The Upanishads have commentary by Rangaramanuja Mahadesikan and a

condensed form in tamil at the beginning - this , I think, is by

Abhinavadesika Uttamur Sri Veeraraghavacharya Swamy.

The last one mentioned in the list is the very rare Prapanna

Parijatham! There are more at this site including ShriBhashyam.

But, sometimes the site is down and we have to keep trying.

 

There is another site http://www.sanskritweb.net/ from which rig and

yajur vedas can be downloaded. This one is dedicated to Shri Mukkur

Lakshminarasimhachariar.

 

There is http://ff.mum.edu/vedicreserve/ from which almost anything

and most of the puranams can be downloaded.

None of these are exclusive ShriVaishnava sites. So it is necessary

to have a site devoted exclusively to our sampradayam. And we do have

to work towards that.

A word about individuals who have rare works:

Usually they are devout Bhagavathas who are treasuring their

collection- so we have to earn their trust before gaining access to

them. It may also be necessary to explain what digitizing means, and

that their treasures are regarded as treasures by us also; and we are

trying to preserve them.

 

 

Also, there are libraries in the US which have out of print books.

Two of these that I know of are University of Illinois, Urbana

Champaign and Stanford University in CA. (I have heard that University

of Pennsylvania also has a collection). The university at Urbana

Champaign allowed us to xerox one of their books that was printed in

late early 1900's!

There are many professors in our community who may have access to

these- I hope they will use their connections for digitizing these books.

So, to quote Shri Sadagopan Iyengar 'Come, let us help in this holy

mission!' and let us make haste!

Digitizing is great- we get to keep our books and share them with

others also at the same time! Reminds one of the metaphorical 'cake'-

except we get to eat, keep, store and share all at the same time!

VAsaka doshaH kshantavyaH

Subha Venkatesan

[Guest guest]

Subha Venkatesan

 

>In context of this posting, here are a few sites where scanned books

>are online and I have found quite a few books at the site " the

>million book project". Here are a couple of downloads.

 

sripedia was born of an interest to assist in such an

effort, and has assisted the internet archive, the million

book project and TTD in their efforts.

 

I might suggest the following

 

1. There are well-funded eforts underway that will sooner

or later reach organized (libraries etc) and semi organized

(institutions etc.) organizations.

2. the efforts of individuals on this list may best be placed

in 'identifying' manuscripts that reside in individual or

adhoc collections.

3. a manuscript registry has been setup towards just such an

effort.

http://www.ibiblio.org/sripedia/cgi-bin/manuscript

 

Note: Individuals who treasure rare works who maybe concerened with

parting with these works for the sake of digitizing will most likely

welcome a cataloging effort that merely wishes to 'record' the

availability of such a work.

 

Finally, digitizing, archiving and preservation are not sprints

but long marathons and a small first step that individuals such

as those on this list might take could be in assisting with the

cataloging of available rare works in individual and adhoc collections.

 

Thanks

S. Sriram