M. Mishra: Autochtonous Aryans? - A review

[Guest guest]

INDOLOGY, vaidix@h... wrote:

>

> Can we get Mr. Mishra's original comment? Thanks in advance.

>

> Regards

> Bhadraiah

 

See the latest comments from M. Mishra about M. Witzel's

review, INDOLOGY/message/809

 

indictraditions, Madhusudan_Mishra@h... wrote:

Dear Prof.Witzel,

 

You have rightly perceived that my review is little concerned with

what you have written in details in EJVS 7-3. As a matter of fact,

I am really mostly concerned with my research on Indus language and

Script and I want to bring you to my field of study.

 

Deciphering the Indus Script is the only point from which all my

discussions start and on which all my research hinges. For this

purpose,I have gone to reconstruct the earliest stage of the human

speech.

 

The inflectional Sanskrit must have been agglutinative at the

earlier stage, which too would have started at the isolating stage.

I have shown to you the reconstructed UR-Sanskrit.Don't you agree

with this reconstruction?

 

I invite you to review all my books and I would not mind if I am

grilled.Your review of my first book in EJVS 7-1 is not justified

as you did not go thru all my books.I wish these would be reviewed

in the next issue of EJVS.

 

Please also refer to some excerpts of my last posting which is

reproduced below:

 

We should devote our energy to the decipherment of the Indus Script,

which is the genuine and first hand witness to the real Ancient Indian

History.On the other hand,we have erected a dummy figure of a ghost

called IE and worship it blindly as deity.

 

Till the Indus inscriptions themselves speak,the old arguments should

be supposed to be hoax.Our most recent queries have to be replied,and

our certain new convictions must be refuted if false:

 

1.The numerals of the Indus Script of specific shapes and sizes

exactly coincide with the syllabic ....

 

[The rest of Mishra's arguments is at his old message,

Mishra's construction of Indus language with Sanskrit syllables]:

INDOLOGY/message/790