mapping the roadblocks

[Guest guest]

http://www.rediff.com/news/2003/jun/28guest.htm

 

Mapping the roadblocks, Professor Madhuri Santanam Sondhi is Director of the

Institute for Asia-Pacific Security and a former member of Parliament. June 28,

2003

Atal Bihari Vajpayee is a seasoned and cultivated politician, who displays a

good grasp of current international trends as they change along the time-graph.

He is also an eminent realist, and does not let ideology or isms of any kind

cloud his vision.

His visit to China followed the defence minister's volte face on China's

strategic threats and bravura in daring a visit to a SARS-infected and

originating country. The prospect caught the imagination of people who imagine

the dawn of a new era of bhai-bhaism promising a cornucopia of economic

benefits to a nation already reeling under the dumping of cheap Chinese

manufactured goods, even to the extent of suffocating an ancient and indigenous

silk-industry.

It is useful to recapitulate a few strategic facts underlying the India-China

relationship which no trade agreements can wish away. Some were stated at a

seminar on Himalayan and National Security held in New Delhi recently addressed

by former members of the Indian Foreign Service, retired generals of the Indian

Army and other strategic thinkers.

It was generally agreed that no amount of cultural and economic agreements would

take away the unease stemming from an unsettled border between India and China

-- which is anomalous given China's acceptance of the MacMahon Line as the

border between her and Myanmar, and her border agreements with the then USSR.

Contrary to big brotherly reminders from Beijing that there is nuclear asymmetry

between China and India, this writer emphasised the doctrine of 'force de

frappe' as formulated by General de Gaulle. Even one nuclear bomb (India has

more) aimed at a strategic target constitutes a threat which can inflict

unacceptable damage to the enemy, and act as a deterrent. Hence China's

insistence on India's nuclear disarmament.

General J F K Jacob, Bangladesh hero and former governor of Punjab, raised three

fundamental points relating to the strategic situation along the Himalayas:

the ecological impact of Chinese plans to divert the rivers of Tibet for

irrigation purposes within China -- remembering that India's most important

rivers originate on the Tibetan side of the Himalayan massif. (Water has been

identified as is the most important strategic and economic asset of this

century, over which new wars are likely to be fought); all this will be

aggravated by thoughtless degradation of the Himalayan forest cover in southern

Tibet, Chumbi Valley, and other areas of the cis-Himalaya; the ominous creation

of ethnic imbalances in Tibet and Sinkiang -- ie, the Hanification of these

areas, superceding the local populations with whom there has been a manageable

if not friendly co-existence through most of history.

A K Ray, former Indian ambassador, recalled Lord Curzon's classical formulation

of India's security zone, which cannot be drawn along her national frontiers

but extend in the north beyond to the Tibetan glacis, which in India's

interest, should never be occupied by a hostile power.

China's hostile and threatening acts right up until the present are well-known

-- her massive support to Pakistan with conventional and nuclear arms and

industry, her dominance over Myanmar and naval activity in the Coco Islands in

the Bay of Bengal, her penetration into the Arabian Sea through Gwadar, her

building of a military airfield in Manually, and the China-Tibet railway,

enabling fast deployment of Chinese troops along the Tibetan border.

China refuses to recognise Arunachal Pradesh as part of India (the Sikkim affair

is a non-issue), and she possesses, thanks to Pakistan, part of Kashmir, apart

from Aksai Chin. Conversely certain Indian developments threaten China, such as

the emergence of a new, engagement-oriented Indian political class represented

by Atal Bihari Vajpayee and the National Democratic Alliance coalition, under

whose dispensation nuclear and missile developments have taken pace, with the

prospect of more nuclear testing if circumstances merit.

Indian missile defence, Indian engagement with Pakistani terrorism and

strengthening of democracy in Kashmir, a positive attitude towards the use of

coercive diplomacy as well as naval deployment in the Indian Ocean area are the

actions which are registering on the China-Pakistan mind which is inseparable.

US-India defence cooperation is a sign of the new, smart and strategic thinking

and policy action on both sides. Time is not on China's side, as Japan, India,

Australia, the US, Singapore, Philippines and others in Asia and the Middle

East see the value of fighting terrorism by military action, and the value of

building traditional as well as non-traditional alliances.

Another sign of the new times is that the US is allowing Israel to sell the

Phalcon airborne warning and control system to India but not to China. George W

Bush, unlike Bill Clinton, is not receptive to the business community and open

to Chinese economic blandishments. The Arrow-2 anti-missile system is also

being considered for supply to India. The Phalcon and the Arrow change the

military equation in Asia significantly.

Thus India's immediate strategic defence arc includes Tibet, Pakistan and

Myanmar, and hopefully the prime minister's visit, with India's growing

military and economic clout, will play a strong hand. China will have to take

India seriously if Vajpayee retains his strategic focus along with his

inimitable diplomatic flourish.

Professor Madhuri Santanam Sondhi is Director of the Institute for Asia-Pacific

Security and a former member of Parliament.

Discover your Indian Roots at - http://www.esamskriti.com, 700 pictures, over

140 articles.To mail - exploreindia (AT) vsnl (DOT) net, to Un write

back.Long Live Sanatan / Kshatriya Dharam. Become an Intellectual

KshatriyaGenerate Positive Vibrations lifelong worldwide.Aap ka din mangalmaya

rahe or Shubh dinam astu or Have a Nice DayUnity preceedes Strength Synchronize

your efforts, avoid duplication.THINK, ACT, INFLUENCE, to Un write

back.Create Positive Karmas by being Focussed, controlling senses, will power &

determinationNever boasts about yr victory and successKnowledge, Wealth,

Happiness are meant to be sharedBe Open Minded, pick up what yu like from the

world

 

Stop cribbing, ACTION is what the Indian scriptures talk aboutTake the battle

into the enemy camp, SET THE AGENDA, be proactiveIn an argument, no emotions,

be detached, get yr facts right, then attack with the precision of a missile