Guest guest Posted April 9, 2003 Report Share Posted April 9, 2003 --- Velukkudi Krishnan <velukkudi wrote: > "Velukkudi Krishnan" <velukkudi > "Nallan Chakravarthy Nappinnai" <nappinnai_nc > RE: Nappinnai > Wed, 9 Apr 2003 10:59:09 +0530 > > Dear Smt Nappinnai, > You have a valid doubt. There are several ways to explain this. > 1. In the words of Sri Parasara Bhattar Bhoodevi and Nila devi are > like the > shadow and kinkaras of Sri Devi . Rangaraja stavam Purva 63 > lakshmIm...chAyAmiva and dEvi tvAmanu nIlayA saha...They are like > flowers > and chandan to Sridevi. So an attribute of Nila has to necessarily be > in Sri > Devi also. It is common to glorify one of the qualities in each > personality. > For example kindly refer to the III prakaranam of Acharya Hrdayam > which you > have. Alwar experiences Souhardam with Ranganatha, Vatsalyam with > Venkatesa, > Paresatvam with Polindu ninra piran and so on. That does not mean > that > Ranganatha does not have Paresatvam or vatsalyam. All the attributes > are > inseparable with every form. Importance is attached to some in every > form. > Bhattar in the vishnu sahasranama commentary says 'Krishnavatara > quality is > Asruta vatsalyam" The quality for Rama is sousIlyam. That does not > mean > other avataras do not have this quality. All the qualities are for > Sri Devi > and in fact Brahmam finally. They are distributed and glorified for > easier > understanding and anubhavam. Take your example of vyuha vasudeva - > sankarshana - aniruddha - and pradyumna are said to have two > qualities each > of gnana bala iswaya virya sakti tejas. That does not mean the > others do > not possess the other qualities. > 2. The kinkaras of Brahmam divide their duties. Sri Devi requests him > to > pardon the surrender's papas. BhUdevi a step above hides the papas > from him. > Nila devi excels as she is the one who took birth in a community in > the > lower strata - she does not know anything called papa. > 3. All three are mentioned in the vedas and purvacharya sri sooktis. > hrIsca > tE lakmIsca patnyou ... ' there are two "ca" used here. One ca is > enough to > count Lakshmi and BhUdevi. The additional ca is for nIla dEvi. Swami > MMunigal in Arti prabandham says vadivArum mAmalarAl valavarugum > mattrai > maNmagalum Aymagalum idavarugum iruppa naduvaga vIttrirukkum > nAranan...It is > interesting to note that nIla dEvi is always identified with ayar > madamagal > unlike Sri and BhUdevi. This is because - the daughter of kumbha (the > brother of yasoda) was known as nIla only. Pramanam ..."nIlA nAmA ca > kanya > sA rUpa oudArya gunAnvitA..." nappinnai was a name coined by > probably > alwars. The name is only "pinnai". Nal is added to glorify as she was > the > only one who took birth amonst the down trodden. Alwars have used > "pinnai" > in many places .. pinnai manAlA.. thOli sEr pinnai poruttu. > 4. Sri Ramayanam - valmiki gives examples for the greatness of > Dasarathas > three wives. bala kanda - tasya bhAryAsu tisrushu hrI srI > kIrtyupamAsu ca.. > hrI for patience and so bhUdevi, srI for wealth and so SridEvi, kIrti > for > glory and so nIla dEvi. > 5. nIlO varNa: asti asyA: iti nIla - the definition shows that her > name is > derived from Her colour. In caraka samhitA nIla is very important as > a > medicinal plant . This may be indigo plant. > 6. It is popularly known that krishna to marry nappinnai tamed 7 > vrshabha. > Bhagavan to enjoy an atman , catches hold of two horns, papa and > punya, and > breaks them. The seven vrshbhas are garbha janma balya youvana jara > marana > naraka. He kills/ tames these seven and gets releases the atman from > the > clutches of this samsara to be in eternal bliss with Him. Pramanam : > tiruviruttam taniyan vyAkyanam .. karuvirutta kuzhi nIttapin. > > There are many more to add. I would write to you later when time > permits. > I always prefer to keep the mails private since I am unable to follow > links > in the groups. I may not be able to reply for weeks which would spoil > the > decorum of the group. Regards. > > > Nallan Chakravarthy Nappinnai [nappinnai_nc] > Tuesday, April 08, 2003 7:21 PM > Velukkudi Krishnan > Re: Nappinnai > > > Sri: > Srimathe Ramanujaya nama: > Dear Sri Velukkudi Krishnan swami, > Salutations to you. It is my bhAgyam to receive a reply > from you despite your busy schedule. Thanks very much for the > explanation. Still I didn't not catch one point. You said nILAdevi is > the one who keeps PerumAL under control thro' her bhOgam. SO what > about Sriramavatharam? Was not perumAL in control? Why this is > applied only in krshnavatharam? Is it due to the vyUha vAsudeva? > I will be indebted to you if you can clarify this point. All I have > with me is the plain text of NDP,sundara kANdam,nitya anusandhAnam, > AH,SVB, mumukshuppadi,thathvatraya(with SS Iyengar's translation), > BG(van buitenan's translation of Emperumanar's gita bhAShyam). > Lot of bhAgavthAs had doubts about this name and sent me mails too. > With your permission,if you don't mind,I will forward your reply to > ramanuja group. Once again my kOti namaskArangaL and mangaLAshAsanams > to you and your family. > > AzhvAr EmperumAnAr JIyar thiruvadigaLE sharaNam > kUraththAzvAn thiruvadigaLE sharaNam > NC Nappinnai ===== sakrdhEva prapannAya thavAsmIthi ca yAcathE | abhayam sarvabhUthEbhyO dhadhAmyEthath vratham mama || VR.VI.18.32 sarvaDharmAn parithyajya mAm Ekam sharaNam vraja | aham thvA sarvapApEbhyO mOkshaiShyAmi mA suca: || BG.18.66 Tax Center - File online, calculators, forms, and more http://tax. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.