(No subject)

[Guest guest]

Sri:

Srimathe Ramanujaya nama:

Dear Ramesh,

Accept my pranams. Tiru ArAdhana kramam was introduced and

systematised by Sri MaNavALa mAmunigaL(based on EmperumAnAr's samskrt

work). Sri Ramanuja is the AcArya for both kalais and hence it

perfectly makes sense to chant "sarva dhEsha" by both kalais.

On the other hand,the "nama: srishaila" invokes Sri

ShailEsha or TiruvAymozhi PiLLai,who was the AcArya of Sri Periya

Jeeyar. TiruvAymozhi PiLLai is in the lineage of TennAcAryas and VK's

AcArya lineage is different. So, obviously VKs would/may not chant

"nama: srishaila nAThAaya". Anyways I have not listened to their

sARRumuRai chanting(except once). So I do not remember this thaniyan

being chanted by them as I was busy chanting TK sARRumuRai within my

heart. But Sri TCA Venkatesan has put this thaniyan in VK sARRumuRai

sampradayam also. May some learned devotee would explain whether or

not it is really chanted by VKs.

 

AzhvAR EmperumAnAr JIyar thiruvadigaLE sharaNam

NC Nappinnai

 

 

ramanuja, "S.RAMESH SAMPATH" <sramesh@o...>

wrote:

> Dear Bhagavatas

>

> Adiyen is from Muscat Iyengar's group. I have got a doubt about

sathumurai

> kramam of Thenkalai & Vadakalai Sampradayam.

>

> In the Tenkalai sathumurai kramam, we chant

> 'sarva desha dasa kaleshva vyahatha parakrama

> ramanujarya divyagna varthatham abi varthamam'

> which was made by Periya Jeer (swami Manavala Mamunigal) which is

also

> chanted by vadakalai sampradayam

>

> However there is another verse in the same sathumurai kramam of

Thenkalai

> made by Periya Jeer (swami Manavala Mamunigal)

> 'nama srisaila nathaya kunthi nagara janmane

> prasadha labda paramaprapya kainkarya saline'

> which is not chanted by vadakalai.

>

> Adiyen has got a very little knowledge in our sampradayam. However

if

> anyone can clarify on this doubt, I will be thankful.

>

> Thanks

>

> S. Ramesh

> '