Guest guest Posted July 20, 2005 Report Share Posted July 20, 2005 Dear vaishNavAs, In the present society of rationality(?) people often question the authenticity of religious scriptures for want of valid evidence in support of the views presented in them. This category of people in general are agnostic, if not atheistic. When an Astika presents vEdic knowledge in a forum, often we find the questions such as, ‘how can you guarantee the contents of the scripture’ or ‘how can one be sure about the book to be apaurushEya, anAdi and nityam’,…… Without hesitation an Astika immediately replies, ‘my teacher authorized the contents for me as they were authorized to him by his teacher, and so on so forth, until the first guru, SrImAn nArAyaNa’. Again the agnostic asks ‘how can you be so sure that any one of the teachers in this parampara has not lied?’ If one carefully analyse this line of arguments, one identifies the very nature of an agnostic is ‘to doubt’. Our answer to such philosophers of doubt is that, ‘how can you be ever sure of any thing when you doubt everything’, ‘when disbelief is the only thing in which you believe’. We further ask him 1. Device for us that fool-proof checking prototype beyond all doubts, if exist any, to meet the objections raised by an ideal (rational) agnostic. 2. Describe a basis for rejecting vEda as spurious. In case of either failure to provide any of the above, or an answer that doesnot concretely meet to refute vEda’s authenticity; your objection on vaidikAs remain baseless for the following reasons 1. you don’t know a formal method for yourself to authenticate eternal scriptures, even though theoretically it is possible to have them. In that case, your failure is due to your own disease of BLIND-disbelief. Further, you are even doubting those who don’t have your disease. 2. you may ask that even the spurious books may claim the same argument, for that we say, You can experiment on the history for the ancient presence of our scriptures of any available human civilization. Hence, our argument cannot be used by others. VEDAS ARE APAURUSHEYA (un-authored by any being), anAdi (have no beginning) and nityam (eternally valid). HENCE SANATANA (universal) Sarvam SrI krishNarpaNamastu. dAsOham, SriperumbUdUru vEnkaTa vinOd. __ Start your day with - make it your home page http://www./r/hs Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.