Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Class Chanting

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Sat Nam,

I have been teaching for 9 years and have finally run into the following

situation. I am starting up a class through the YMCA and the director is very

worried that Kundalini Yoga may conflict w / their Christian principles. I

have explained things, but she wants No Chanting. I realize the teachings

should not be altered to get the desired effects, but was thinking about

omitting any chanting until the students (and perhaps the director) released

some of their blocks and became more comfortable with it. I thought I could

tune in silently, and ask that they concentrate on their own souls, or say a

short prayer silently, to ask for Gods protection and grace.

Anyone with such experience? Your comments would be greatly appreciated.

Peace,

John

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello! I had to mention that my husband worked for the YMCA in WA state

about five years ago. At that time he was exploring sikhism and started

wearing a turban and legally changed his name to Dharam Dev Singh. He

worked childcare for them at an offsite location. The children and their

parents really liked him and asked lots of questions about yoga and deeper

questions about death and such. At one point he was called to a meeting

with the director, and as he sat down the first thing she said to him is,

"I'm an atheist". He was soon fired from that job, just a week or two after

he started wearing the turban (and announced we were having a baby). He had

been directed to not answer any questions from the children of a personal or

spiritual nature, but to "redirect" their questions. Apparently their is

some variance in the principles of those who run the YMCA!

 

As far as not chanting, I don't know. It would certainly bother me as a

teacher, I would feel very much, if not too- censored. But I can see your

thinking of maybe your class helping that block to work out over time. I

guess it is a judgment call of how much non tolerance is too much. I've run

into that a little bit with a class I will be starting soon. When the woman

who manages the studio I will be teaching in was writing up my class

description she would not say that there was any chanting involved because

she thinks people would not want to come. She has been doing her job

awhile, so maybe she is right- I don't know, but I intend to include the

usual chanting anyway. It seems weird to me, though. I guess people

confuse the concept of chanting with singing. I have always felt they were

different. I may feel nervous singing in front of a group by myself, but I

would not feel nervous chanting. I guess that is just where I am at. I

just plan to stress that it is the vibration and feeling the chanting

produces that is more important that the melody.

 

Anyway, good luck with working out this challenge!

 

Sat Siri Akal,

 

Love Always,

 

littlebird Leslie

aka Guru Chiter Kaur

 

PS, How is all chanting non-christian? I'm sure a good argument can be made

about the universiality of God and names of God. But, perhaps this director

would not be open to such a discussion. Personally, I don't see much

difference between chanting the rosery or chanting japa, but I have never

been attached to any christian mode of thinking either. Oh, well...

 

>

> Slapla8352 [slapla8352]

> Monday, January 08, 2001 7:45 AM

> Kundaliniyoga

> Class Chanting

>

>

> Sat Nam,

> I have been teaching for 9 years and have finally run into the following

> situation. I am starting up a class through the YMCA and the

> director is very

> worried that Kundalini Yoga may conflict w / their Christian

> principles. I

> have explained things, but she wants No Chanting. I realize the teachings

> should not be altered to get the desired effects, but was thinking about

> omitting any chanting until the students (and perhaps the

> director) released

> some of their blocks and became more comfortable with it. I

> thought I could

> tune in silently, and ask that they concentrate on their own

> souls, or say a

> short prayer silently, to ask for Gods protection and grace.

> Anyone with such experience? Your comments would be greatly appreciated.

> Peace,

> John

>

>

>

>

>

> "OUR DESTINY IS TO BE HAPPY"

> - Yogi Bhajan

>

> You can UNSUBSCRIBE from this list at the eGroups Member Center

> (My Groups), or send mail to

> Kundaliniyoga-

> NO UNSUBSCRIBE REQUESTS TO THE LIST PLEASE!

> WEB SITE: kundalini yoga

>

> KUNDALINI YOGA ON-LINE TRAINING. Details from

> kundalini yogaclasses.html

>

> Sponsored by YOGA TECHNOLOGY - Practical books on Kundalini Yoga,

> Meditation, Chakras, Womens' Empowerment. Meditation & Mantra CDs.

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dear John:

 

A friend of mine teaches in a (very) Mormon community, and she ran

into similar issues when she started. She went out of her way to

explain that although she is Sikh, KY is not a religion, but a

discipline, like martial arts, and that chanting is simply an aspect

of the discipline, like breath or posture, and that the chanting is

functional, changing brain patterns and neurochemistry through

vibration and stimulation of the upper palate - and is, therefore, a

necessary aspect.

 

She also pointed out that people of all faiths practice KY, and that

it only furthers their interest in and pursuit of spiritual matters,

regardless of belief or religion.

 

She stuck with providing the teachings as normally taught, and has

built up a very large teaching practice. She is well loved and

respected in her community.

 

Whatever you decide to do, I wish you much success!

 

All blessings,

Sadhant

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kundaliniyoga , "littlebird108"

<littlebird108@e...> wrote:

>

>

> Hello! I had to mention that my husband worked for the YMCA in WA

state

> about five years ago. At that time he was exploring sikhism and

started

> wearing a turban and legally changed his name to Dharam Dev Singh.

He

> worked childcare for them at an offsite location. The children and

their

> parents really liked him and asked lots of questions about yoga and

deeper

> questions about death and such. At one point he was called to a

meeting

> with the director, and as he sat down the first thing she said to

him is,

> "I'm an atheist". He was soon fired from that job, just a week or

two after

> he started wearing the turban (and announced we were having a

baby). He had

> been directed to not answer any questions from the children of a

personal or

> spiritual nature, but to "redirect" their questions. Apparently

their is

> some variance in the principles of those who run the YMCA!

>

> As far as not chanting, I don't know. It would certainly bother me

as a

> teacher, I would feel very much, if not too- censored. But I can

see your

> thinking of maybe your class helping that block to work out over

time. I

> guess it is a judgment call of how much non tolerance is too much.

I've run

> into that a little bit with a class I will be starting soon. When

the woman

> who manages the studio I will be teaching in was writing up my class

> description she would not say that there was any chanting involved

because

> she thinks people would not want to come. She has been doing her

job

> awhile, so maybe she is right- I don't know, but I intend to

include the

> usual chanting anyway. It seems weird to me, though. I guess

people

> confuse the concept of chanting with singing. I have always felt

they were

> different. I may feel nervous singing in front of a group by

myself, but I

> would not feel nervous chanting. I guess that is just where I am

at. I

> just plan to stress that it is the vibration and feeling the

chanting

> produces that is more important that the melody.

>

> Anyway, good luck with working out this challenge!

>

> Sat Siri Akal,

>

> Love Always,

>

> littlebird Leslie

> aka Guru Chiter Kaur

>

> PS, How is all chanting non-christian? I'm sure a good argument

can be made

> about the universiality of God and names of God. But, perhaps this

director

> would not be open to such a discussion. Personally, I don't see

much

> difference between chanting the rosery or chanting japa, but I have

never

> been attached to any christian mode of thinking either. Oh, well...

>

>

Sat Nam Littlebird,

Thank you for you responce to my post.

I decided to continue with the classes and silently tuning in myself

as I have the students focus on their 'inner' spirit and to humble

themselves before God. I will teach meditations that don't include

mantras,for now, like segmented breathing, and may break them in

with mantras that are in English.

Its good to know that other teachers run up against the same

obsticles.

(And thank you too, Pam!)

Sat Nam,

John- Dev Atma Singh

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...