Official Ramakanta vs. IRM discussion thread

[Guest guest]

Posted by Yaduraja on Jan 12, 2006:

 

Dear Ramakanta Prabhu,

PAMHO, AGTSP,

You write:

 

> Don't waste time trying to find contradictions in my statements.

 

If I ignore your self-contradictions then I may as well ignore you

completely since they tend to be quite fundamental to your position. There

is no need for me to reply at all if that’s how you want to play things

since, on past performance, sooner or later you will defeat yourself.

 

Last time you contradicted yourself over your star piece of evidence I had

to keep pointing out your self contradiction for two whole weeks before you

finally admitted it and changed your position to match what you now say is

what you really meant. Had I not bothered to point out your

self-contradiction then your stated position would still not match what you

now claim you meant So you should be grateful to me for helping you to say

what you mean, rather than what you don’t mean. But you don’t sound very

grateful at all.

 

> Generally, if you see a contradiction, then you misunderstood me.

 

No, I have understood your words perfectly, just as last time, which you

admitted. It is past experience that you misstate your position, not that I

misunderstand what you write.

 

 

So do you agree you have contradicted your stated position?

 

 

If you look on the home page you will see dozens of people, including the

GBC and various ‘gurus’ who have all tried to defeat our position, and all

ended up contradicting themselves, each other or both. So you are in good

company.

Best wishes

Ys

Yadu