Official Ramakanta vs. IRM discussion thread

[Guest guest]

Dear Yaduraja Prabhu, PAMHO. AGTSP!

 

 

What is the purpose of your last text? Do you want to prove something with

it? Is it an attempt to prove your point a)? IMHO, it was a waste of time.

 

If you see a contradiction in my words, then you misunderstood me. I will

not write that I contradicted myself because I did not. Seeing

contradictions in my words is not a proof of your position.

 

 

You publicly accused me to have claimed that ISKCON existed before it

existed:

 

> I just have the issue of whether ISKCON existed before it existed to reply

> to, a challenge you made which is again a complete waste of time so far as

> I can see. (Yaduraja, Feb 2, 2006)

 

I request you to retract that accusation and apologize.

 

 

You publicly incorrectly stated:

 

> ... but claimed the conclusion we drew from those facts was wrong.

> (Yaduraja, Feb 8, 2006)

 

I request you to retract that statement and replace it with a correct

statement.

 

 

You publicly incorrectly claimed that I clearly agree that ISKCON’s gurus

are proven to be authorised representatives of God:

 

> Most people in the world do not accept ISKCON’s gurus are proven to be

> authorised representatives of God, yet clearly you do. (Yaduraja, Feb 8,

> 2006)

 

I request you to retract that claim and apologize.

 

 

On Feb 9, 2006 I asked you to quote the statement you want me to retract.

But you did not answer. Do you really know what you are you talking about?

 

 

I asked you for a proof of the deliberate act by Srila Prabhupada that set

him up in the position of the sole diksa guru for ISKCON. You then presented

a 'proof' like this (not literally): "In September 1966 Srila Prabhupada

conducted initiation ceremonies with the result that in July 1966 he became

the sole diksa guru for ISKCON" or "The proof that Srila Prabhupada set

himself up in the position of the sole diksa guru for ISKCON in July 1966 is

because 2 months later he conducted initiation ceremonies". How can an act

have an effect two months before that act? Please explain that.

 

 

On what day did Srila Prabhupada set himself up in the position of the sole

diksa guru for ISKCON?

 

 

ys Ramakanta dasa