Guest guest Posted March 16, 2001 Report Share Posted March 16, 2001 Brother Mani <<The Lord does not eat! He "accepts" an offering made out of love and reverence.>> Mani, it seems to me that you do not know Him. You are just guessing that He does not eat cos that is your perspective. If you get more close to Him, you will be amazed of His Personality. He not only accepts and eats but He steals as well. He is called sometimes, the Supreme Thief. One day a brahman was cooking for God in His parents house and when you cook for God, nobody is allowed to even taste the food until it is offered to God. But this time the Lord was playing the role of being a human baby and living with His parents. The Lord knowing about the devotion of His brahman, played a trick on him by stealing the food before being offered. The poor brahman saw his endeavours frustrated and had to cook again but everytime, the Lord came and eat the food before being offered. At the end the brahman was crying in frustration and then the Lord disclosed His "credentials" to him and told him " do not worry cos I am the one that you intended to satisfy with your cooking" <<As the Avatars Rama and Krishna he could not have been a strict vegetarian. Many (Rig)Vedic sacrifices demand animal sacrifice, which then was prasada! >> My dear Watson, meat is never prasadam. That is why Lord Budha came. The vedic literature recommends animal sacrifice for certain rituals and in order to give the soul of the sacrificed animal a higher body. But the vedas never recommends a systematic slaughter of animals. When Lord Budha came, many people were killing animals with the excuse that it is recommended in the scriptures. Therefore, Lord Budha told people the ahimsa principle, the compassion to animals to stop them killing those indefense animals. One day, someone asked Srila Prabhupada why Christ eat meat and SP said "He can eat the whole world if he wants". And in another occassion, SP said that a guru like Christ has to act according to age, time & circumstances and when he gave fish to people, they were in danger of starvation and were fisher-people, used to eating fish no mangoes. You mention how horrible it was to eat meat for the first time in your life. Krishna also does not like to eat meat at all, & i do not think of anybody capable of forcing Him to do so. On the other hand, from a different dimension we can see things in a different context. I heard that a british gentleman was walking beside the Ganges and observed from 10 yards distance, how this Aghori (heavy left hand tantric) was eating from a human corpse washed out on the bank. This gentleman lost his britishness and shouted HOY. The aghori looked at him like looking at a headless chicken and threw a piece at him from the corpse. However, when the chunk of meat was flying at mid air, it became flowers. <<The truly vedic community was a semi-nomadic, hunting was an essential part of life:>> Perhaps in times of natural cataclisms but if that is the case then why we have shilpa shastra and ayurveda in the vedas?. Vedic civilization comes from higher authorities to lower. At the beginning of every Manu, Manu has the vedic code to give to the human population. In those codes we have the book of Manu, which is the Law Book; Shilpa shastra, which has the instructions on how to build cities, palaces, temples, wells, roads, markets etc; ayurveda, giving remedial measures to cure diseases and how to prevent them. A nomadic culture does not need the knowledge of urbanization as given in Shilpa shastra. In fact, the king is not allowed to spend money in parties until the last of his citizens is well fed, dressed, housed and protected. << the king regularly went on hunting expeditions to feed his people.>> More exactly to practice his skills as a warrior, cos as a soldier, a king has to kill in some circumstances like wars or a murderer. <<Rama and Krishna were Kshatriyas - non-vegetarian.>> There are vegetarian ksatriyas as well. <<There are some proteins that the human body requires, which can only come from animals.>> Who says that? i have been a lacto vegetarian for 31 years and i feel well, except for a bad back from time to time which is not related. And my son Nimai is 19 and he never touches meat, in fact he can not even walk in front of a butcher shop. He is healthy as well. Of course, there are some people that require eating meat cos their bodies have some problems. In fact ayurveda recommends ceratain meat for illnesses. But like onions and garlic, they are like medicine and we should not abuse the comsumption of medicines when they are not required. <<Milk and milk-products can supply these. Also soya-beans. Soya beans were not known till a few decades ago and their cultivation is still limited.>> A real leader should order an investigation on those alternative products. But Srila Prabhupada said that we are not against eating meat, we are against killing animals. He said that due to karma many people like the taste of meat (we are not talking here about people in need due to certain malfunctions in their system) and that they can continue eating meat but only after the animal had a natural death. He said that if people stops killing cows for a while, in a couple of years, cows will start to die naturally and then people could eat them if so they wish. Slaughter houses are dynamic centers of sin, polluting the subtle energies around and making people MAD. <<Substitutes for meat are found easily in the United States and in the UK, but not elsewhere. I have to drive 40 miles to get Tofu! - Living near Berlin! Others in Germany may have to drive much further.>> I am sorry to hear of your problems. <<J.C. Bose demonstrated that plants have "feelings" like animals. They have no mouths to cry out! The guy who invented the "lie-detector" showed that plants "remember" and react to love and hate! Plants have a multiple life. If you eat one pea you have hurt the plant, the pod, the pea - each twice and if you cook or chew on the pea it is a total of 7 times. You kill an animal only once!>> Yes, killing vegetables is as bad as killing animals but we are talking about karma, akarma and vikarma. This week a lady told me that she thought that karma is always bad. I had to explain that karma in Sanskrit (i am not an expert but i like to meditate in the words) means activities in general which always cause a reaction. Karma are activities prescribed by the shastras and the shastras (Bhagavad Gita) says that if we offer to Krishna (God) with love and devotion, a leaf (vegetables), fruit, water (milk) or grains, the reaction incurred is nullified and we give a chance to the souls in that food to achieve a higher body in their next life. On the other hand, akarma is the refusal of following prescribed instructions and vikarma is any activity which goes against sanctions, like killing indefense animals. The reaction to karma, akarma and vikarma is different. <<Being a vegatarian does not make you any better morally.>> Truth, Hitler was a vegy and killed millions. The butcher of the corner of the street is very charitable. Srila Prabhupada said that what is the point of being a vegetarian if we do not have brains, he said that a pigeon is a vegetarian but it has a pigeon's brain. <<The inclusion of onions and garlic as taboo foods has nothing to do with vegetarianism, but may be based on some ayurvedic knowledge.>> Onions & garlic are medicine but tamasic in nature. In fact, onions appeared on the grounds where the blood of the first cow killed by Mr Kali, fell. <<Jains in India - if strict - do not eat any "roots" like potatoes or carrots, for pulling them out from the earth could kill creatures in the soil! Many of our vegetables were unknown in vedic times and even the names we know are not really certain!>> Vegetables are vegetables here or in China, i love them. India may have wheat, mexico has sweet corn, China has rice, Africa has other grains. Grains are very important for the disemination and sustenance of humanity. Grains are the vehicle for the souls to reincarnate, very important indeed. <<Agriculture was limited and only certain "naturalfruits of the eart" were known.>> No doubt that archeologists are going to start to tell us a different story now that they are examining DNA from prehistoric places. In our days we have thousands of especies of eatable vegetables but we can only reach the commercial ones which are comparatevely few. <<In Africa I have found many things like Mangoes, bananas, egg-plant,okra etc. growing in abundance, but hardly palatable.>> Maybe cos they do not plant them on the proper muhurtas. <<To transfer vedic food habits into our times is only a guessing game!>> No, the British have their table manners but the Italians have the food and both eat. vedic food habits means to eat vegetables, grains, fruit and milk products. We can find them in almost every country. <<Logically speaking there is only one article of food which can be considered as non-destructive: the unfertilized egg! And perhaps milk, if more than the calf can consume.>> That is if you can call an egg food. "the unfertilized egg!" is just the menstruation of the chicken. Sorry guys if i put you off. And regarding milk, the vedas says that it is the best food for humans but unfortunately in our days it is tampered with lots of chemicals. In 1989 i developed hay fever which used to send me to bed during the summer time. I heard that milk may cause it, cos of the rubish that they put in it, hormons, vacinations etc. I stop it and every year i get less and less hey fever. I eat other milk products except milk, unless i get the real milk which is not often. <<It is the attitude that counts. There is a story of Kannappa. He was a hunter and every day he offered the meat he had hunted to Siva. Once he came with a very large deer on his shoulder, had to keep hold of it with both hands. The Siva Linga had a face and its right eye started to bleed. Kannappa, since his hands were not free, put his foot on the bleeding eye to stop the bleeding. Siva appeared at once and gave him moksha. It was an act of love that was rewarded.>> Yes, the intention is the all important but Krishna will not accept rubish. That is why there are different departments in this cosmic manifestation. For example, Krishna has nothing to do with mundane sex. It is mother Durga that is in charge of that department. By giving us this material bodies, she (our dear mother) knows what is better for us and the body becomes interacted with other bodies according to our karma. <<Janardhana, the Feeder of all, has manifested himself in so manay ways to feed us. He has invented a system of re-cycling, by which every body becomes the food of another Even the shit of one body is food fo another!>> I hope that i do not have to do it. <<WHATEVER WE EAT, WE MUST THANK JANARDHANA FOR HAVING MANIFESTED AS OUR FOOD! Lamb or legume, we must express our thanks to it for having lived to feed us!>> Well, shamans in mexico say that what you eat is going to eat you sooner or later. And they thank the protector of the animal killed. God does not live in our prison and therefore is not responsible for our sins. On the other hand, we should offer vegetarian food to God to purify our senses and life. <<Further we must understand the allegory in the mythology. The Mura story is meant for kids! It does not justify or explain anything, serves only to REMIND!>> Kids love it and i am a big kid. <<The grain is harvested and stored. How can mura live in it only when consumed on ekadasi?>> How can we live in a disused house?. we just take over if we want. <<wher can he live otherwise? It only says that consoming grain on ekadasi is NOT RECOMMENDED!>> Remember that grains are the only place for mura to hide during ekadasi days. A friend from India told me that people says that if you open a coconut during the 8th tithi, you will find fungus in it. Therefore people do not open coconuts during those days. I have no taste it but i think that there is some truth in it. <<The consumption of grain is in itself a very doubtful matter: the human body is not "designed" for eating grain. It is like a pig: its natural food is meat, roots, fruits and vegetables, but not grass or derivatives. Many allergic roblems are connected with eating grain! >> I got lost in the mexican mountains and i lost energies. i found a village (2 huts) and a lady gave me 2 tortillas which gave me energies to walk for another 2 hours. In mexico, we were sick of the gringos coming to tell us what to eat. They said (in the 60's) that our basic food of tortillas, beans and chillis were analized in laboratories and that they do not provide enough food. We never listen to their BS. However, in the 70's the gringos found that they made a mistake. They were analizing the food separately but when combined they found that it had evrything the body needs. And regarding trhe allergies coming from grains, it must be all the chemicals that farmers put on them. <<No time was a "golden age">> Too long ago to remember but i believe that we have seen golden ages before and that we are in one now but we do not have the eyes to see it yet. Thanks Mani natabara gjlist- Your use of is subject to Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.