Evaluation of Sources of Strength for Narayana Dasa for D10 - a second look

[Guest guest]

Namaste Visti,

thank you in advace for your help here and patience, yet after reviewing the rule again

and again something does not fit right, and would like to revisit the rule

again... please take a look at my logic and see if it holds water.

 

If you compare Rule 4 ( page 22 ) of Narayan Dasa to the instructions given in

Upadesa Sutras (pg 198-199) you will see a discrepency in who we discussed

applying the rule for our earlier emails below and hence my confusion on what

the application of therule,

That is:

1.Upadesa sutra pg 198 , 2.3.9 gives sign strengh D>F>M - and does not mention

the placement of the sign's lord. Just as Rule 4 of Narayan Dasa pg. 22.

2. Upadesa Sutra then goes on to 2.3.10 and says IF BOTH SIGNS ARE UNOCCUPIED

then the sign whose lord becomes the AK is stronger - this equates to rule 5

of Narayan Dasa book pg. 22.

POINT here is that if RULE 4 did infact consider the lords of signs that were

unoccupied, there would be no need for Rule 5. if No AK applies then going

to Rule 6 makes perfect sence becaue you established a sign with no planets,

neither sign is the owner of the AK, so now it's time to evaluate the LORD of

the signs and their degrees.

 

Let me know what you think of the logic... my concern is simple, we are implying in rule 4 ( pg 22)

that we evalute the lords of empty signs before its time to do so.

 

Pranams,

 

Frank in Austin [fschmidt (AT) austin (DOT) rr.com]

Saturday, April 20, 2002 4:26 PMsjvcSubject: RE:

[sjvc] Narayana Dasa for D10

Namaste Visti,

Let me be sure there is not an oversight on my part...

1. I am evaluating Cancer v.s Capricorn - Neither rasi has a Graha in it...

2. I took rule four to evaluate IF both had equal number of planets, then evaluate

the sign by Dual > Fixed> Movable.

IF I am correct, you are suggesting that to LOOK where the Rasi lords reside and evaluate

them, ( then) by Dual > Fixed> Movable.

Is this your assessment?

IF so , I am not reading the rule(s) correctly...

 

Regards and Pranams.

Visti Larsen [vlarsen (AT) hotmail (DOT) com] Sent:

Saturday, April 20, 2002 1:10 PMsjvcSubject: Re: [sjvc]

Narayana Dasa for D10

Vyam Vysadevaya Namah

---------------------------

Dear Frank,

I believe Rule 4, is related to the position of the lord of the signs.

In this case Cancer, lorded by Moon in a dual sign becomes stronger.

 

Best wishes, Visti.

-

Frank in Austin

sjvc

Saturday, April 20, 2002 8:50 PM

[sjvc] Narayana Dasa for D10

Om asato maa sadgamayaTamaso maa jyotir gamayaMrityor Amritam GamayaOm Shanti Shanti Shantiye

Namaste,

Can Someone provide me with some guidance.

I am calculating the Narayan Dasa for D10 chart ( shown below)

I have calculated the Maha Dasa periods ( below), and am on Antardasa

Periods. I am using the rules from Sanjayji's book ( Narayan Dasa)

and am perplexed ( stuck) with the following:

1. First Maha dasa Period = Pisces

A. Antaradasa dasa rule: * example

-. determine the the stronger of the dasa sign (Pisces)and the 7th

from it ( Virgo) - Pisces is stronger due to 2 graha's residing in Pi.

-. Determine the sign occupied by its lord ( Guru)

and this will be the starting Antardasa for Pisces ( its order is

based upon odd or even sign of Sc,

and in this case it's even, so the the order is

anti-zodiacally or Sc, Li, Vi, Le, Cn, Ge, etc)

2. NOW my quandary: Next Maha dasa is Cancer, which is stronger Cn or Cp?

A. Antaradasa rule

-. Determine the stronger between dasa sign ( Cn) and

7th from it ( Cp).

a. Both signs are without Graha's so which is stronger?

Use Source of strength rules:

Rule 2 , First source of strength ( pg21- Narayan Dasa book)

Neither have planets.

Rule 1, Second Source of Strength - aspects of Guru or Buddhi.

Since Guru is in Sc, he gives Rasi drist to both Cn and Sg.

Neither sign gets aspected by Buddhi.

Rule 3 , First Source of Strength - If the sign has equal number

of planets ( NO) then consider planet's status ( exalted, Moola,

swakshetra, etc) - NOPE.

Rule 4, First source of strength - Dual stronger than Fixed, and

Fixed strong then movable; Both are Movable so still equal.

Rule 5,6,7,8 First source of strength, do not seem applicable?

b. UNLESS for Rule 6, I look at the Rasi LORDs ( Chandra and

Sani - and determine their degrees and which one is more advanced ?

Chandra is 15Ge29 and Sani is 11Li20. So Chandra is stronger - IS THIS A

CORRECT ASSESSMENT?

 

Please advise if possible...thank you

 

Natives birth info:

July 17, 1952Time: 15:22:30Time Zone: 6:00:00 (West of

GMT)Longitude: 87 W 40' 25"Latitude: 41 N 54' 10"

 

D1 Chart+--------------+|AL |Jup

|Moo HL | || | | | ||

| | | || | | |

|| | | |

||-----------+-----------------------+-----------|| |

|Sun Mer || | |Ven Ket ||

| | || | |

|| | | ||-----------|

Rasi |-----------||Rah | |Mnd Glk ||

| | || |

| || | | || |

| ||-----------+-----------------------+-----------||

|Asc |Mar GL |Sat || | |

| || | | | || |

| | || | | |

|+--------------+

D10

 

+--------------+|Sun Mar |Mnd |Ven

|Moo Rah || | | | || |

| | || | | |

|| | | |

||-----------+-----------------------+-----------|| |

| || | | ||

| | || | |

|| | Dasamsa | ||-----------|

|-----------|| | D-10 | ||

| | || | |

|| | | || |

| ||-----------+-----------------------+-----------||Mer

Ket |Jup GL |Sat HL |Asc ||Glk AL | |

| || | | | || |

| | || | | |

|+--------------+

 

Narayan Maha Dasa for d10

Sign

Ruler

Odd footed: zodiacalEven Footed: Anti-zodiacal

Distance to lordIn Rasi - forwd or anti- zodiacal

First CycleLength of Dasa

Running Totalyrs i.e. up to age

Year from July 17th,1952Year ending

Notes

Pisces

Guru

E

4

4

4

1956

 

Cancer

Chandra

E

1

1

5

1957

 

Scorpio

Ketu*

O

2

2

7

1959

Ketu exalted

Sag

Guru

O

11

11

18

1970

 

Aries

Mangla

O

11

11

29

1981

 

Leo

Ravi

E

5

5

34

1986

 

Virgo

Buddha

E

9

9

43

1995

 

Capricorn

Sani

E

4

4

47

1999

Sani exalted

Taurus

Sukra

O

12

12

59

2011

Venus in own house

Gemini

Buddha

O

6

6

65

2017

 

Libra

Sukra

O

7

7

72

2024

 

Aquarius

Rahu*

E

9

9

81

2033

Rahu exalted

Your use of

is subject to the