Is KP Vedic Astrology?

April 24, 2002

OHM SHRI RAGAVENDRAYA NAMAH

JAYA JAGANNATHA

Namaste Venkateswara Reddy,

Thanks for your concern about the SJVC teaching.

We, at SJVC, do not teach or approve the KP system. But, at the same time we do

not stop the students who wants to learn such new fields. It is up to the

students to do the research and come to his own conclusion.

As per the report of Mr.Dasgupta, they generally discussed about the KP methods

with other topics. As long as they do not present any theories or topics about

KP here in the list, it is OK. If they are analysing the validity of KP with

respect to Vedic Astrology, it is acceptable.

So, let us not ponder more on this topic and drop it here.

Thanks

Solai Kannan

venkateshwara_reddy

[venkateshwara_reddy ]23 April 2002 10:35 PMTo:

sjvcSubject: [sjvc] Is KP Vedic Astrology? (was Re: 2nd meeting

proceedings, mumbai chapter)Dear members, I have seen PandiTa Sanjay postings on

Varahamihira/Vedic-Astrology e-groups, saying that KP is not Vedic Astrology.

How come we, the members of SJVC are mixing the traditional with

Tamasik/Rajasik stuff?Shri Krishma Murthy critised Vedic Astrologers of yore in

his teachings based on Rasi and Navamsha(I am not sure about whether he isaware

of shodasa varga). Anyway, Jyotisha Guru-s of SJVC will lead to right path.Best

Regards,Venkateswara Reddysjvc, "j.k. dasgupta" <dga@b...> wrote:>

MessageRespected Sanjayji, Solaiji, other Gurus and all list members,> > With

your blessings we started our 2nd meeting at the house of Dr. Ramchandani

(Anushaktinagar, Chembur). As Solaiji pointed out, it was the auspicious day of

Ram Navami. The diiscussion started at about 4.30 pm and continued upto 8.30 pm.

It was an excellent and very friutfull evening we passed together. For sure,

this is the best way to learn and clear each other's doubts and one life may

not be sufficient to learn even a tip of the subject. > > The following persons

were present,> > 1. Dr. Ramchandani (BARC, Mumbai) - He is a neuclear scientist

and a member of " vedic astrology" discussion group. He is studying

astrology since a long time and have a very good knowledge of KP system.> 2.

Dr. Ramakrishnan (BARC, Mumbai)- He is also a neuclear scientist. He has done

research on KP system and also written a book on the application of KP system

on various charts. He distributed complementary copies of his book to each of

us. We are all greatfull to him for this.> 3. Aswin (Pune)> 4. Viswanadhan

(Mumbai)> 5. Praveen Agarwal (Mumbai)> 4. J.K. Dasgupta (Mumbai)> > Nandan

Chakravarty and Aruna Kawad could not attend as they were preoccupied with work

and they intimated the same.> > We started with meditation, followed by

discussions on,> > * AK, how to find Istadavata and Palanadevata in the chart.>

* Discussion on the chart of Aswin on his career prospects.> * General

discussion on KP method.> * General discussion on KSY and KAY> * General

discussion on analysis of siblings from D3 chart> * General discussion on

functinal benefic and malefics> > It was decided that the next meeting will be

held on 12.05.2002, sunday at the same place. Any subsequent change will be

intimated to the list. We shall discuss our charts in details on proffession /

career prospects, relations between D1, D9 & D10 vargas and any other related

topics.> > Details of the discussions are submitted below. There were some

questions from the perticipants - which have been shown in BOLD CAPITAL words.

We seek guidance from the gurus and experienced list members on those.> > AK,

ISTADEVATA AND PALANADEVATA:> > 1. Praveen Agarwal> AK venus is in Aries

navamsa. Sun is in 12th house from it. So Ista is Shiva.> Mars is in the 6th

house from AmK in navamsa. So his Palanadevata is Kartikeya/Scanda or Lord

Hanuman> > 2. Aswin> AK is Rahu and presently he is running Rahu mahadasa. 12th

from karakamsa is Virgo -empty. So Ista is denoted by mercury. He is in 1st

drekana. so his Ista is Lord Rama.> In navamsa 6th from Amk is Leo, having sun

and jup there.Jup is more advanced - so he indicates palanadevata. Jup

indicates Guru. He is actually a devotee of Shirdhi Saibaba.> > DOUBT-1: >

CHARAKARAKA REPRESENTED BY ISTADEVATA SHALL LEAD THE NATIVE TO ISTA. BUT WHO

WILL LEAD THE NATIVE TO PALANADEVATA? IN HIS CASE MERCURY IS CHARA MATRIKARAKA

AND IT IS HIS MOTHER WHO FIRST TOOK HIS TO SAI BABA TEMPLE. DOES IT HAVE ANY

SIGNIFICANCE?> > 3. Dr. Ramachandani> AK is Jup in Gem (D9). Ra (5d) and Sat

(14d) is in 12 th from karakamsa. Sat is more advanced so Narayana is

Istadevata. > AmK is Mercury in Sag (D9). 6th from Amk in navamsa also Taurus.

So his Ista and Palanadevata are same.> > 4. Viswanadhan> AK is Sat. In navamsa

12th from karakamsa is Scorpio which is empty. So Mars lord of scorpio indicates

Ista and Kartikeya/Scanda or Lord Hanumana is his Ista. And Mars is in Navamsa

lagna Sag with Jup & Sat.> > DOUBT-2:> WHEN THERE ARE MORE THAN ONE PLANET IN

12TH FROM KARAKAMSA, PLANET HAVING MAXIMUM LONGITUDE INDICATES ISTA. BUT WHEN

12TH FROM KARAKAMSA IS EMPTY AND THE LORD IS AT ANOTHER HOUSE WITH OTHER

PLANETS (AS IN THIS CASE) - DOES THE SAME RULE APPLY? OR AS A GENERAL RULE, IF

12TH FROM KARAKAMSA IS EMPTY - ITS LORD ONLY BE CONSIDERED?> > Amk is Jup and

in navamsa Sun is at 6th from it at Taurus. Sun i.e Shiva should be his

Palnadevata. > > DOUBT-3> SUN IS IN ENEMY HOUSE AND LORD OF TAURUS, VENUS IS IN

WATERY SIGN CANCER - HAVING RASHI DRISTI ON TAURUS. WHAT SHOULD BE THE EFFECT?

WILL THE PALANADEVATA WILL REMAIN THE SAME - AS SUN IS IN ENEMY HOUSE?> > 5.

J.K. Dasgupta> AK is Jup in Gem in nanamsa. 12th from it Taurus empty. Lord is

Venus. It is also having rashidristi on Taurus. So Ista is Mahalaksmi.> Amk is

Sun in Gemini and 6th from it is Libra. Again Libra is empty. So lord Venus

indicate Palandevata and here Istadevata and Palanadevata is same.> > CAREER

PROSPECTS OF ASWIN:> > Birth data is,> DOB: 18.03.1975> TOB: 12.20 pm> Patna,

Bihar> > Aswin is MBA and was working in a software firm in Pune. He lost his

job on 31.10.2001 during his Ra-Sa-Ve period. Div charts were not available. So

detail discussion could not be done. But it was seen in general that,> 1. He is

running AK mahadasa since 5.6.1995, Rahu is debilated in 6th. So in general the

pereiod is difficult for him> 2. Venus is in Ketu star and Ketu is placed in

12th house debilated.> > So Ve sub-sub created problem from him.> Another thing

was observed that Ketu is in 12th house with Moon (2d 50m, nearing deep

exaultation ). During Moon mahadasa he was in hostel away from his home. > In

general it was opined that his next Ra-Sat-Mars dasa starting from 27.05.2002

should give him a job as Mars - as Mars is in Moon nakhsatra and Mars and Moon

are in trine to each other. A job away from his present place (even outside

India) might be possible. More detail discussions on this will be taken up

during next meeting.> > GURUJI AND OTHER LEARNED LIST MEMBERS MAY PLEASE

COMMENT ON THIS.> > We all are looking forward to our next meeting on

12.05.2002> > With humble regards,> > jk dasgupta> > ps: Aswin, Viswanadhan and

Praveen: Please see if I have missed somethingYour use of is

subject to the

April 24, 2002

Respected Solaiji,

Pranam. That is exactly what we tried - to find how KP is related with

traditional vedic astrology. In fact, both of the scientists also eagerly

followed our discussions on AK, ista etc. and expressed interest in knowing the

traditional system. I have handed over print outs of Sanjaiji's article on

Istadevata to them. It was a good opportunity of exchanging our little

knowledges.

Regards,

jk dasgupta