Guest guest Posted August 9, 2003 Report Share Posted August 9, 2003 Dear Anna, I have read your mail.. You have your way of studing jyotish and I have mine. Lets agree to disagree. I have nothing more to add. Thank you again for your kind words. Cheers !!! Ash , "N.Anna" <anmar@a...> wrote: > Dear Ash, > How did you arrive to the conclusion that I do nor consider yogas, position relevance etc..is - I know that each bindu stands for certain relevant factor in the chart- you missed that from my message- I clearly state what you stated in your message, in my first sentence. Not to depreciate your point /it's good to hear that, repeated/ but I've considered that self-explanatory- points do not come from nowhere., it's clear. Read my message again, please. > > I said: "I see that you consider difference of one bindu point btw houses > important- in qualitative terms, it perhaps is important- but in > judging, for example dynamic side of it, like transits, it doesn't > seem that 1 point makes much difference- is that your impression > too, or not?" > And-Why shouldn't I dwell on application?- that's the major purpose of studying. You cannot set 'my priorities'can you?- besides, application is ultimate goal of majority of Jyotishi /the same is in most areas/. It's easy to jump to conclusion, I've experienced that myself, many times, and apologized, when noticed that I missed something in arriving to a conclusion. So I will try to explain this further: > > In absence of better term I use 'qualitative' aspect, and that implies what you re-explained: it is relevant HOW the point was 'earned'- > I asked about another aspect HOW MANY, and it's obviously another focus of potential research that should be done: if you want to see relevance of certain events, manifestation of transit, and to CORRELATE house-bindus with events, manifestations, you will not dwell on HOW the points were derived, because it is DIFFERENT Issue. BOTH are relevant, depending on the focus of the research. > > I appreciate knowledge, no matter where it comes from- truth is one, anyway. I am not fundamentalist, I'll read and get to know different points of view and then choose on my own- AV issue attracted my interest because R. Houck made a good point in his book Digital Astrology- you obviously had your own way that led you to the same issue- both ways came to the same point. Just wanted to explain my stand point, and that is we need both types of researches /and bibliography, writings, if available- one among them is R.Houck's book-Why not??? He also gave useful information on how bindus are arrived at, in simple, easy to understand way, so I would recommend this reading to you/ > At the moment I have transit Saturn in my low bindus 12th house- I will let you know how that works, from this point of view. And members will contribute so we'll have research on the List- I had that in mind too- Group resources are great. > > Thanks for starting this on the Lists, again. > > Anna > > > - > ashsam73 > > Saturday, August 09, 2003 12:51 PM > [sJC: Achyuta Gurukul] Achyuta Gurukul] Achyuta Gurukul] Achyuta Gurukul] Re: Achyuta Gurukul] AV > > > Dear Anna, > Before you dwelve into the application lets clarify what a bindu > means. A bindu is casted by a planet if it favours or else its a > rekha. > Now my quesiton to you is... > > You have asked.. does 1 bindu make a difference... > > Let me ask u this.. does is make a difference if Moon is in 4th from > Guru and case 2 is if Moon is in 6th from Guru.. > > I think in the above 2 case a bindu would change between Guru and > Moon.. think about it.. and tell me if it makes a differnce in a > chart.. > > Then go on to think if a planet that has given a bindu means it > favouring yog.. and a difference of 1 bindu would mean that lagna or > 1 of 7 grahas is now not favouring if a bindu reduces.. > > Basically you have changed the position of planet.. and bindu is > like showing if that relation or yog is favourable or not.. if not > then it gets a rekha... > > Then go on to think about its placement in div charts.. and the > Asktakavarga of that divisional chart... > > etc etc... > > 1 bindu makes a huge difference.. just like a few minutes can make > a huge difference in twins... > > Ashtakavarga is not just basic.. there its very involved. and the > enitre system of asktakavarga is based on transits.. and relative > positioning of planets with respect to each other and lagna... > > The system I follow is not in any book out there.. I have not read > Richard Houcks book so I do not know.. > > Each and everything has a deep meaning... > > Cheers !!! > Ash > > , "N.Anna" <anmar@a...> wrote: > > Dear Ash, > > > > I've been on the same line of thought- you formulated dilemmas > very effectively. SAV can tell us so much in a simple way- > > I see that you consider difference of one bindu point btw houses > important- in qualitative terms, it perhaps is important- but in > judging, for example dynamic side of it, like transits, it doesn't > seem that 1 point makes much difference- is that your impression > too, or not? > > malefic transit through low bindus houses line-up can be very long > and difficult - but do you take bindus for the house in general, or > bindus of particular planet in particular house that it's transiting? > > R. Houck used the later to prove the point. > > /Digital Astrology/ > > You seem to prefer former- yes research is needed. > > Thanks for starting this. > > Anna > > > > - > > ashsam73 > > > > Saturday, August 09, 2003 10:03 AM > > [sJC: Achyuta Gurukul] Achyuta Gurukul] Achyuta > Gurukul] Re: Achyuta Gurukul] Another case of great career > > > > > > Dear Visti, > > I shall append my answers and question in CAPS. I am using the > web > > ro answer so I do not have access to different color. > > > > > > , "Visti Larsen" > > <balabhadra@j...> wrote: > > > > > > |Vyam Vyasadevaaya Namah| > > > Dear Ash, > > > My good friend, comments below. > > > Best wishes > > > Visti > > > --- > > > Sri Jagannath Center: http://.org > > > Bhagavad Purana: http://www.srimadbhagavatam.org > > > iTRANS 99 Font: http://www.omkarananda-ashram.org > > > - > > > ashsam73 > > > > > > Friday, August 08, 2003 11:40 PM > > > [sJC: Achyuta Gurukul] Achyuta Gurukul] Re: Achyuta > > Gurukul] Another case of great career > > > > > > > > > Dear Visti, > > > > > > I may not have explained myself clearly.. When we get SAV > points > > of > > > 12th house and 11th house etc we are considering all planets > in > > > relation to each other based on their BAV and finally we > cast > > the SAV > > > and then we get totals for the house. I know you know this > part. > > > > > > Visti: Yes. > > > > > > Now if one has 3 planets in 2nd house then as per BAV scheme > > ONLY if > > > Guru is in 11th from Shani it will not give its bindu other > than > > that > > > Each and every planet will contribute to the 11th house. I > > think > > > this part also we had discussed in detail. > > > > > > Visti: In the future we need to make this more detailed > with > > writeups. > > > > > > Now after doing all that we got the points of 12th house and > > 11th > > > house. If more planets are in 2nd house they will > contribute to > > 12th > > > house and if ALONG with that other planet are not supporting > > 11th > > > house i.e. making its bindus more than 12th basically we are > > > automatically conidering so many yogs then there will be > debt. > > > > > > I did check the BAV for Shani and Mars. They help planets > in > > 6th > > > from them except if Sun is in 6th from Shani. > > > > > > Visti: Yes Sambandha is important as you pointed out. > However > > you have looked at the natural charachteristics of Mars and > Shani to > > support the 6th from there placement - This knowledge can be > used to > > understand Mars and Shani's Bindus. > > > > ASH : I THINK WHEN THE MAHARISHI GAVE THE ASHTAKAVARGA I.E > > BHINASHTAKAVARA I.E THE DISTRIBUTION OF BINDUS OF EACH PLANET > AND IT > > ALSO TELLS US WHY A PLANET IS A NATURAL MALEFIC OR A BENEFIC. > FOR > > EXAMPLE WE KNOW THAT GURU IS THE GREATEST BENEFIC AND THE > MAHARISHIS > > HAVE ALSO GIVEN 59 BINDUS TO GURU TO DISTRIBUTE AND IF I > MAY "CAST A > > FAVOURABLE BINDU" A PLANET. SIMILARLY SHANI AND MARS ONLY HAVE > 39 > > BINDUS AND WE KNOW THAT THEY "GENERALLY" ARE MALEFIC. SO IT > > INDIRETLY USES ALL THE THINGS. IN TIME I WILL DO MORE RESEARCH > BUT > > THE ENTIRE ASHTAKAVARGA SYSTEM IS BASED ON RELATIVE POSITIONING > OF > > PLANETS W.R.T. EACH OTHER AND ALSO THE BIGGEST THING IS > > FROM "LAGNA". THAT IS WHY ASHTA-KAVARGA. 7 GRAHAS > AND "LAGNA". > > I THINK YOU HAD ASKSED THIS QUESION ABOUT "LAGNA". > > SO ALL THESE THINGS ARE AUTOMATICALLY CONSISERED WITH RELATION > TO > > LAGNA. > > > > I THINK IF U REALLY FOCUS AND JUST OBSERVE THE BAV OF ALL > PLANETS U > > CAN START TO SEE WHY FOR EXAMPLE PLANETS IN 7TH FROM VENUS > REDUCE > > THE EFFECT OF VENUS.. MEANING.. VENUS CAN NEVER GET FULL 8 > BINDUS IF > > THERE IS ANY PLANET IN 7TH FROM IT... > > > > IF U ALSO KEENLY NOTICE MOSTLY ALL PLANETS CONTRIBUTE TO THE > UPCHAYA > > STHANS... OR HOUSE OF GROWTH... I GUESS IF U REALLY GET DOWN TO > IT.. > > U CAN REALLY UNDERSTAND HOW THOSE DOTS COVER SO MUCH .. > SAMBANDHA, > > YOGS LIKE GAJ KESARI.. ANAPHA, SUNAPHA ETC ETC... ALL YOGAS THAT > ONE > > DOES INDIVIDUALLY IS ALL CONSIDERED INCLUDING THEIR CONTRA > (WHICH I > > THINK TAKES STUDENTS SO MUCH TIME TO UNDERSTAND CAUSE > INADVERTENTLY > > THEY CONSIDER ONE PART AND FORGET TO CONSIDER THE CONTRA AND I > HAVE > > SEEN THIS SO FREQUENTY DONE WITH UNDERSTANDING NEECH BHANGA > > YOG..) ... ONLY SOME YOGAS THAT ARE NOT COVERED LIKE PLACEMENT > OF > > VENUS IS PERTICULAR NAKSHATRA AND 4:10 ETC > > > > EVEN IF YOU SEE KAL SARPA YOG.. USING ASHTAKAVARGA YOU CAN AT A > > GLANCE SEE WHY A PERSON CAN HAVE AN EXTENEDED PERIOD OF > DIFFICULTY.. > > > > LET ME EXPLAIN.. > > > > KAL SARPA YOGS OR EVEN KAL AMRIT YOG OR FOR THAT MATTER EVEN > GRAH > > MALIK YOG IS CAUSE WHEN PLANETS ARE ON ONE SIDE OF RAHU AND > KETU.. > > SO BASICALLY ONE SIDE OF THE HOROSCOPE IS HEAVIER.. AND IF U > STUDY > > THE SAV POINTS U WILL FIND THAT ONE SIDE HAS MORE THAN 28 POINTS > AND > > SINCE THERE ARE ONLY 337 BINDUS TO DISTUIBUTE ITS GOING TO > REDUCE > > SOME OTHER HOUSE... SO WHEN SUN OR MALEFICS TRANSIT OVER HOUSES > > HAVING LOW SAV OR HAIVING ANY ZEROS.. WILL DEFINITELY CAUSE > > TROUBLE.. AND IF THERE IS SIGN AFTER SIGN HAVING LOW POINTS THEN > > THOUSE PERIODS WILL BE PROLONGED.. AND THE TUNNEL WOULD SEEM > MUCH > > LONGER BEFORE THE NATIVE CAN SEE SOME HOME OR RAY OF LIGHT... > > > > AV IS A WONDERFUL TOOL IF UNDERSTOOD WELL.... OBVIOUSLY TO BE > USED > > WITH A FULL SYSTEM.. LIKE WHAT I USE WITH KRUSHNAS ASHTAKAVARGA > > SYSTEM WHERE IN ALL THESE THINGS ARE CONSIDERED DIRECTLY OR > > INDIRECLY.. > > > > > > > > Instead see how Mars and Shani are affecting the 6th from > Lagna, > > as thats where the debt arises. > > > > > > For Mars also helps mostly all planets in 6th from them > except > > for > > > Shani. > > > > > > This you can see from their BAV. But when we finally check > the > > SAV > > > which is a sum total of all these individual things we come > to a > > > conclusion that 12th bhava has more bindus than 11th > > so "expense" > > > will be more than "income" > > > > > > If to check when this debt will come or when will this > native be > > out > > > of debt that is another topic... > > > > > > Similarly look at this case.. Shani in 12th and 11th points > much > > > higher than 12th.. then shani aspects 2nd, 6th and 9th house > and > > such > > > a person based on "Natural" quality of shani will not worry > > about > > > spening money.. now if 11th points are more than 12th then > we > > can > > > combine the 2 and say that whatever expense this person has > will > > be > > > and can be met.. now that does not mean that in some antra > in > > some > > > mahadasha this person will not have debt.. but some other > antra > > will > > > clear it... Such a shani can also not give sleep or person > wakes > > up > > > late at night but if such a shani is with more bindus then > it > > will > > > boost the 9th house etc etc.. here we are combining natural > > natures > > > with yogs etc.. I think these are different questions... > one is > > to > > > do with quality and other to do with timing... > > > > > > I hope you understand what I had tried to say. > > > > > > Visti: Yes. > > > > > > I did not understand what you had said here.. you said Mars > will > > > remove debt quicky.. here are u looking at the antar dasa of > > Mars to > > > remove debt i.e. timing or are you looking at just mars in > > general > > > without considering other planets ? > > > > > > Visti: When looking at the results of planets we must > > consider their natural charachteristics on a house. Mars will > not > > cause debt as its too tight with money. Shani will cause debt. > > Jupiter will try to bring more money. In this mannor we > understand > > the natural charachter of each graha. > > > > ASH : THIS I THINK U ARE FINDING FROM KAL PURUSHA CHART AND > > CONSIDERING KARAKS (WHAT I CALL KARAKS ARE 8TH HOUSE LORDS FROM > THE > > HOUSE UNDER CONSIDERATION). > > > > SO FOR DHAN ITS 2ND HOUSE AND 8TH FROM 2ND HOUSE IS NATURAL 9TH > > HOUSE AND WHICH IS GURU.. SO GURU CONTROLS THE HEALTH OF > KUTUMBA, > > WEALTH ETC.. (NOT TALKING OF ALL THE INDIVIDUAL THINGS SHOWED BY > 2ND > > HOUSE). > > > > SIMILARLY MERCURY IS THE NK FOR INCOME OR 11TH HOUSE AND ALSO > 6TH > > LORD FOR AUTHORISING INCOME (JOB). (8TH FROM 11TH HOUSE).. I > THINK > > > > > > > > > > > > Sooo... when we apply this to the various bhavas we can > > immedietely state from the quality of Argala (and AV > subsequently as > > they are linked), what the exact effect on a Bhava will be. > > > > ASH : I THINK AV IS A COMPLETE TOO AND ENCOMPASES ALL THE > THINGS. > > WHEN I GET SOME TIME I WILL DO A RESEARCH.. BUT I CHECK > INTERVENTION > > ETC USING BINDUS FOR EXAMPLE.. > > > > AS PER YOUR EXAMPLE.. MARS IN 3RD HOUSE.. (KEEPING ASIDE THE > LAGNA > > RISING AS THAT CAN CHANGE THIGNS A LOT). > > > > BUT JUST TO SHOW YOU THE DEAPTH OF AV.. CONSIDER 2 CASES OF MARS > > > > 1) MARS IN 3RD WITH > 4 BINDUS > > 2) MARS IN 3RD WITH < 4 BINDUS. > > > > SUCH A MARS WILL ACT VERY DIFFERENT OBVIOUSLY.. AS MARS IS A > GENERAL > > MALEFIC SO WE "GENERALLY ASSUME" THAT MARS WILL HAVE LESS THAN 4 > > BINDUS AS IN MOST CASES IT GENERALLY HAS THAT.. BUT IN SOME > CASES IT > > DOES HAVE MORE THAN 4 BINDUS. THIS IS ONLY POSSIBLE WITH OTHER > > PLANETS BEING IN CERTAIN COMBINATIONS AND ONLY IN CERTAIN > > COMBINATIONS FROM MARS AND "MARS FROM LAGNA". SO HERE WE HAVE > > CONSIDERED SO MANY THINGS AT A SHOT. > > > > NOW USING 4:10 RELATIONSHIP.. SUCH A MARS WITH LESS THAN 4 > BINDUS > > WILL MAKE THE 4TH HOUSE FROM IT DO ITS WORK... NOW IF SUCH A > MARS IS > > IN SCORPIO THEN IT ALSO HAS 4TH DRISTI.. SO IT WILL INCREASE THE > > EFFECTS OF THE 6TH HOUSE.. THESE THINGS ARE SUBTLE AND NOT TO BE > > CONSIDERED FOR TIMING BUT QUALITY.. I THINK U ALSO USE ARGALA > FOR > > JUDGING QUALITY AND NOT FOR TIMING .. I MAY BE WRONG ON THIS > ONE.. > > > > ON THE CONTRARARY IF SUCH A MARS IS WITH MOR BINDUS THEN IT WILL > > HELP THE 12TH HOUSE I.E. PLANES IN 10TH FROM IT.. I THINK THIS > > PRINCIPLE IS ALSO USED TO FIND ARUDHA LAGNA .. I.E. 4:10 .. IF A > > PLANETS ARUDHA FALLS IN LAGNA OR 7TH FROM IT THEN U EITHER USE > 4TH > > OR 10TH POSITION... > > > > SO BASICALLY MY POINT BEING THAT ALL THESE THINGS ARE USED > > INDIRECTLY AS AV IS A COMPLETE TOO IF USED AS A FULL SYSTEM... > NOT A > > PART... I WIL LEAVE IT TILL HERE.. WE CAN TAKE UP THE > COMPARISION OF > > HOW ARGALA IS CONSIDERED IN AV IN ITS BAV.. AND DISCUSS THAT > RATHER > > BRAIN STORM ON IT... > > > > > > > > I.e. Shani's Argala on the 4th house will not be auspicious. > > Reason; 4th house shows happiness and Moon is the natural > indicator > > of happiness, which Shani is innimical towards. Hence Shani will > > cause sorrow and shock if it has Argala on the 4th house. > > > > ASH : THATS JUST ONE PART OF IT.. WHAT IF SUCH A SHANI HAD 3 > > BINDUS ... IT WILL MAKE THE 4TH HOUSE FROM ITSELF DO THINGS FOR > IT.. > > OR IF THERE IS A PLANET IN 4TH FROM IT.. WITH GREATER THAN 4 > BINDUS > > THEN SUCH A SHANI WILL BECOME VERY VERY POWERFUL FOR ALL > HOUSE... SO > > IT IS NOT ... > > > > HERE IS AM TALKING OF SHANI GIVING VERY GOOD RESULTS FOR ALL > HOUSES > > (APART FOR LEO AND VIRGO LAGNA WHERE SHANI IS 6TH LORD) THEN IT > WILL > > GIVE OVERALL HAPPINESS.. BUT THIS IS FOR TIMING .. I THINK U ARE > > LOOKING AT QUALITY... AND I AM TALKING ONLY OF ANTRA IS > VIMSHOTTARI > > DASA STARTING FROM MOON.. (SO THAT READERS ARE NOT CONFUSED). > > > > I THINK YOU ARE TALKING OF "FEELING" AND I AM TALKING > OF "TIMING". > > > > VISTI, DOES ARGALA AFFECT TIMING OF EVENTS DIRECTLY ? OR DOES > ARGALA > > OR INTERVENTION HAVE AN EFFECT ON "HOW THINGS FEEL" ? > > > > > > > > Now in BAV distribution, the points are distributed without > > consideration of the grahas placement with regards to the Lagna. > > Points are distributed but theres no change in the distribution > > based on individual placement... this we need to deduce on our > own, > > as you said with the individual grahas placement. > > > > > > That means that the resultant SAV for a bhava (really a > rasi) > > cannot be the final determinor for the natives extent of > debt/gains, > > as it merely shows potentiality - bindu or seed. I.e. where > growth > > can occur. The nature of this growth is deduced from the BAV and > > PAV, as not all grahas will give the same results in say - 10th > > house. > > > > > > The point is - which of Mars or Shani has the strongest sway > > over the 6th house. If Mars does then the debts will be removed > very > > quickly. > > > > > > If we agree on the above, then we must consider the > following; > > > 1. Should we consider the individual BAV's of Mars and Shani > on > > the Rasi of the 6th from Lagna and compare? > > > > ASH : THESE THINGS ARE CONSIDERD. IF 6TH HOUSE'S SAV IS HIGH > THEN > > PERSON GETS GOOD SOCIAL STATUS.. IF 12TH IS HIGHER THAN 11TH > THEN > > EXPENSES ARE MORE THAN INCOME.. IF 10TH HOUSE POINTS ARE MORE > THAN > > 11TH THEN PERSON HAS TO WORK HARDER FOR HIS MONEY... > > IF POINTS IN 3:6:10:11 ARE IN ASCENDING ORDER .. PERSON HAS GOOD > > DARING TO DO BUSINESS AND GETS VERY HIGH AUTHORITY.. AND WILL BE > > SUCCESSFUL IN BUSINESS AND OWN VENUTRE... SO THESE THINGS ARE > ALL > > CONSIDERED. EVEN THE BASIC.. VISTI.. ASHTAK-VARGA.. LAGNA + 7 > > GRAHAS.. MAHARISHIS HAVE THOUGHT OF IT ALL .. LOL > > > > > 2. Should we consider the BAV of Jupiter (dhana karaka) > only, > > and see the effects of Mars and Shani on the 6th from Lagna. > > > > ASH : EACH AND EVERY THING HAS A MEANING.. I THINK SOMEONE HAD > ASKED > > IN THE PAST.. WHAT IF THERE IS ONE BINDU DIFFERENCE... IT MAY > NOT > > MAKE MUCH DIFFERENCE... AND THAT WAS ABSURD !!! CAUSE A CHANGE > OF 1 > > BINDU CAN CHANGE VARIOUS YOGS AS A PLANET OR THE PLANET ITSELF > FROM > > LAGNA HAS CHANGED.. AND WHEN THAT HAPPENS LOTS OF THINGS GET > > AFFECTED.. WHO KNOWS.. A PERSON MIGHT HAVE HAD A GAJ KESARI YOG > AND > > NOW IT HAS DURUDHARA YOG.. WHO KNOW... OR MAY CAUSE A ZERO IN > SAV > > AND WHEN MALEIFICS TRANSIT IT COULD CAUSE HAVOC.. I MEAN AS YOU > > SAID.. GURU IS NOT ONLY DHAN KARAK.. ITS ALSO KARAK FOR 5TH > HOUSE > > AND ONE OF THE THINGS OF 5TH HOUSE IS PUTRA.. SO IF GURU IS > GIVING A > > ZERO TO 2ND OR 10TH HOUSE OF 9TH HOUSE THEN THE PERSON MIGHT NOT > > HAVE ANY CHILDREN.. OR NO HAPPINESS FROM IT.. OR IF SUCH A GURU > IS > > IN 6TH LORDS SIGN IN SAPTAMASA THEN IT MAY DENY IT.. ETC ETC.. > SO > > YES WE NEED TO CHECK SAV FOR EACH AND EVERY PLANET AS EACH AND > EVERY > > BINDU HAS A STORY TO TELL... > > > > > > > > Forget Dasa's for now. > > > > ASH : YES .. IT WILL GET TOO COMPLICATED.. > > > > > > CHEERS !!! > > ASH > > > > > > Thanks for this discussion... its stimulating... > > > > > > Thanking you, > > > Cheers !!! > > > Ash > > > > > > > > > > Sponsor > > > > > > > > > > > > [Om Kleem Krishnaaya Jagannathaaya namah] > > Send a blank mail > > To : - > > To : > > > > Terms of > Service. > > > Sponsor > > > > > > [Om Kleem Krishnaaya Jagannathaaya namah] > Send a blank mail > To : - > To : > > Terms of Service. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.