Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Some Doubts on Astrology

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Hi Shiva,

The free will of an individual in a democratic society does

give one an opportunity to explore the intriguing details of the

untouched and unexplored experiences. Be it from casting your vote to

assuming a situation where one may land into. But yet you will cast

your vote to a person who you feel by your free will is the right

choice. Not because some astrologer told you to cast your vote to a

particular person only or otherwise if you dont then you will face

the consequences in the time to come. Let s take your questions one

by one

 

1. Assuming the predicament one finds into the chances of becoming a

doctor or an engineer are remote if you dont study hard even to clear

the entrance exam or pay for an NRI seat(if your father has lots of

money) even if you have the guidance of an astrologer who has read

the charts in detail and followed the principles properly.

 

2. Assuming the person is free to make decisions why in the world do

you think he will go to an astrologer, forget consulting an

astrologer. It is common sense if a person is free to make decisions

then consulting an astrologer is not his free decision when one

thinks that astrologer will be biased. So the question should be why

should one (who makes owns decisions) visit an astrologer.

 

3. Again the main use of astrologer is only served when one visits an

astrologer and uses his service. According to a person exhibiting his

free will(and only accepts unbiased opinion) what do think are the

chances of changing his free will and mindset that he will not cast

the vote at all(what has to happen, will happen) with one pre

condition he has got the name enrolled in the voters list.

 

4. Last but not the least can you predict from a persons birth chart

if this person will consult astrologer in his lifetime is quite

interesting. As to begin first of all, a birth chart is made by an

astrologer( nowdays we have lots of softwares also) so in a way there

is a light at the end of tunnel which you need to see. The fact is

anyone who is in the process of getting a birthchart made has in a

way consulted an astrologer. So you see if tomorrow you become an

astrologer and someone comes up with the same question in one of the

readings. The chances are 100 % yes as you are holding the birthchart

of the person which is a proof that your prediction is bound to be

true.

 

I hope that the above will also satisfy any other members of the

group who have a more generous attitude of analysing things with

their free will.

 

Gaurav

 

 

 

, "trialjig" <trialjig>

wrote:

> Hi group,

>

> I have been interested in astrology for sometime now and have done

> some preliminary reading, but not much. But i would like to ask you

> some opinions

>

> 1. Assuming the astrologer has read your chart in great detail and

> has spelled out a course of events, how much free-will is available

> to the person whose chart is read?

>

> For example, let us say a +2 student goes to an astrologer and asks

> what his profession is likely to be and the astrologer says : you

> will be in the field of medicine.... At this point, what are the

> chances of this person becoming a computer engineer??? Assume that

> the astrologer is using a well known system of astrology and he has

> read the charts in detail and followed the principles properly???

>

> 2. If a person is free to make his own decisions, why should he

> consult an astrologer, an astrolger then puts a bias on the

> decisions of the person.

>

> 3. If what has to happen, will happen then again what is the use of

> an astrologer?

>

> 4. I am guessing most people only visit an astrologer when they

have

> troubles, Can you predict from a persons birth chart if this person

> wil consult astrologer in his lifetime, if yes then during what

> times in his life????

>

> It would be great to know what people this about these...

>

> - Shiva

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Hi gaurav,

 

Interesting points, but let me clear something, on second readin i

guess my questions were not very clear

 

1. If a person has let us say 2 choices and he goes to an astrologer

and then the astrologer says choice 1 is better according your

charts, then Is this person's decision not biased(( not the

astrologer)) by fear of facing difficulties if he chose choice 2.

 

2. If what has to happen, will happen( irresepective of a person

going to an astrologer or not) then what is the use of going to an

astrologer?

 

3. My question was, can you tell by a person's birth chart, if he

will visit an astrologer? for this question it is like asking

randomly if a person is born on june 14 2004 in delhi, india at 12.00

noon, will he/she goto an astrologer in his lifetime

 

 

All 3 queries are independent and they are not the same person, i am

just asking these because i am still curious about role of astrology

in a persons life

 

 

-Shiva

 

 

, "gauravkom" <gauravkom>

wrote:

> Hi Shiva,

> The free will of an individual in a democratic society does

> give one an opportunity to explore the intriguing details of the

> untouched and unexplored experiences. Be it from casting your vote

to

> assuming a situation where one may land into. But yet you will cast

> your vote to a person who you feel by your free will is the right

> choice. Not because some astrologer told you to cast your vote to a

> particular person only or otherwise if you dont then you will face

> the consequences in the time to come. Let s take your questions one

> by one

>

> 1. Assuming the predicament one finds into the chances of becoming

a

> doctor or an engineer are remote if you dont study hard even to

clear

> the entrance exam or pay for an NRI seat(if your father has lots of

> money) even if you have the guidance of an astrologer who has read

> the charts in detail and followed the principles properly.

>

> 2. Assuming the person is free to make decisions why in the world

do

> you think he will go to an astrologer, forget consulting an

> astrologer. It is common sense if a person is free to make

decisions

> then consulting an astrologer is not his free decision when one

> thinks that astrologer will be biased. So the question should be

why

> should one (who makes owns decisions) visit an astrologer.

>

> 3. Again the main use of astrologer is only served when one visits

an

> astrologer and uses his service. According to a person exhibiting

his

> free will(and only accepts unbiased opinion) what do think are the

> chances of changing his free will and mindset that he will not cast

> the vote at all(what has to happen, will happen) with one pre

> condition he has got the name enrolled in the voters list.

>

> 4. Last but not the least can you predict from a persons birth

chart

> if this person will consult astrologer in his lifetime is quite

> interesting. As to begin first of all, a birth chart is made by an

> astrologer( nowdays we have lots of softwares also) so in a way

there

> is a light at the end of tunnel which you need to see. The fact is

> anyone who is in the process of getting a birthchart made has in a

> way consulted an astrologer. So you see if tomorrow you become an

> astrologer and someone comes up with the same question in one of

the

> readings. The chances are 100 % yes as you are holding the

birthchart

> of the person which is a proof that your prediction is bound to be

> true.

>

> I hope that the above will also satisfy any other members of the

> group who have a more generous attitude of analysing things with

> their free will.

>

> Gaurav

>

>

>

> , "trialjig" <trialjig>

> wrote:

> > Hi group,

> >

> > I have been interested in astrology for sometime now and have

done

> > some preliminary reading, but not much. But i would like to ask

you

> > some opinions

> >

> > 1. Assuming the astrologer has read your chart in great detail

and

> > has spelled out a course of events, how much free-will is

available

> > to the person whose chart is read?

> >

> > For example, let us say a +2 student goes to an astrologer and

asks

> > what his profession is likely to be and the astrologer says : you

> > will be in the field of medicine.... At this point, what are the

> > chances of this person becoming a computer engineer??? Assume

that

> > the astrologer is using a well known system of astrology and he

has

> > read the charts in detail and followed the principles properly???

> >

> > 2. If a person is free to make his own decisions, why should he

> > consult an astrologer, an astrolger then puts a bias on the

> > decisions of the person.

> >

> > 3. If what has to happen, will happen then again what is the use

of

> > an astrologer?

> >

> > 4. I am guessing most people only visit an astrologer when they

> have

> > troubles, Can you predict from a persons birth chart if this

person

> > wil consult astrologer in his lifetime, if yes then during what

> > times in his life????

> >

> > It would be great to know what people this about these...

> >

> > - Shiva

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Hi Shiva,

Perhaps you would have also taken my replies independently

then the answers would be more clear. Anyways, the answers what i

feel should be are here but they may differ from person to person

 

1. first of all, if an astrologer has suggested you to join an X

profession whereas you want to join Y, there is a reasoning behind

it. Without any reason he wont suggest any profession( we are talking

about good astrologers). The reason is simple it is for the benefit

of the individual. Everyone aims for the betterment in this world and

rightly should be. So the decision should be seen as a step towards

one `s betterment not being biased. And the simple reason is

experience and knowledge of the astrologer which you are relying upon.

 

2. The answer is we cannot change the bad time or the bad effects but

certainly can lessen the effects by consulting a good astrologer for

possible remedies. So you see the main aim is to develop a positive

frame of mindset and not remain closed in a room where one is

repeating the words what has to happen, will happen. Just remember it

is only and only by God`s grace that we can lessen the effects and

astrologer is just a medium.

 

3. Well the answer to this one can be given someone who is more

experienced than me perhaps Rohini ji would be a better person. As i

myself have never done such a prediction.

 

I think you have got your answers to some extent. All the best in

your quest.

 

Gaurav

 

, "trialjig" <trialjig>

wrote:

> Hi gaurav,

>

> Interesting points, but let me clear something, on second readin i

> guess my questions were not very clear

>

> 1. If a person has let us say 2 choices and he goes to an

astrologer

> and then the astrologer says choice 1 is better according your

> charts, then Is this person's decision not biased(( not the

> astrologer)) by fear of facing difficulties if he chose choice 2.

>

> 2. If what has to happen, will happen( irresepective of a person

> going to an astrologer or not) then what is the use of going to an

> astrologer?

>

> 3. My question was, can you tell by a person's birth chart, if he

> will visit an astrologer? for this question it is like asking

> randomly if a person is born on june 14 2004 in delhi, india at

12.00

> noon, will he/she goto an astrologer in his lifetime

>

>

> All 3 queries are independent and they are not the same person, i

am

> just asking these because i am still curious about role of

astrology

> in a persons life

>

>

> -Shiva

>

>

> , "gauravkom"

<gauravkom>

> wrote:

> > Hi Shiva,

> > The free will of an individual in a democratic society

does

> > give one an opportunity to explore the intriguing details of the

> > untouched and unexplored experiences. Be it from casting your

vote

> to

> > assuming a situation where one may land into. But yet you will

cast

> > your vote to a person who you feel by your free will is the right

> > choice. Not because some astrologer told you to cast your vote to

a

> > particular person only or otherwise if you dont then you will

face

> > the consequences in the time to come. Let s take your questions

one

> > by one

> >

> > 1. Assuming the predicament one finds into the chances of

becoming

> a

> > doctor or an engineer are remote if you dont study hard even to

> clear

> > the entrance exam or pay for an NRI seat(if your father has lots

of

> > money) even if you have the guidance of an astrologer who has

read

> > the charts in detail and followed the principles properly.

> >

> > 2. Assuming the person is free to make decisions why in the world

> do

> > you think he will go to an astrologer, forget consulting an

> > astrologer. It is common sense if a person is free to make

> decisions

> > then consulting an astrologer is not his free decision when one

> > thinks that astrologer will be biased. So the question should be

> why

> > should one (who makes owns decisions) visit an astrologer.

> >

> > 3. Again the main use of astrologer is only served when one

visits

> an

> > astrologer and uses his service. According to a person exhibiting

> his

> > free will(and only accepts unbiased opinion) what do think are

the

> > chances of changing his free will and mindset that he will not

cast

> > the vote at all(what has to happen, will happen) with one pre

> > condition he has got the name enrolled in the voters list.

> >

> > 4. Last but not the least can you predict from a persons birth

> chart

> > if this person will consult astrologer in his lifetime is quite

> > interesting. As to begin first of all, a birth chart is made by

an

> > astrologer( nowdays we have lots of softwares also) so in a way

> there

> > is a light at the end of tunnel which you need to see. The fact

is

> > anyone who is in the process of getting a birthchart made has in

a

> > way consulted an astrologer. So you see if tomorrow you become an

> > astrologer and someone comes up with the same question in one of

> the

> > readings. The chances are 100 % yes as you are holding the

> birthchart

> > of the person which is a proof that your prediction is bound to

be

> > true.

> >

> > I hope that the above will also satisfy any other members of the

> > group who have a more generous attitude of analysing things with

> > their free will.

> >

> > Gaurav

> >

> >

> >

> > , "trialjig"

<trialjig>

> > wrote:

> > > Hi group,

> > >

> > > I have been interested in astrology for sometime now and have

> done

> > > some preliminary reading, but not much. But i would like to ask

> you

> > > some opinions

> > >

> > > 1. Assuming the astrologer has read your chart in great detail

> and

> > > has spelled out a course of events, how much free-will is

> available

> > > to the person whose chart is read?

> > >

> > > For example, let us say a +2 student goes to an astrologer and

> asks

> > > what his profession is likely to be and the astrologer says :

you

> > > will be in the field of medicine.... At this point, what are

the

> > > chances of this person becoming a computer engineer??? Assume

> that

> > > the astrologer is using a well known system of astrology and he

> has

> > > read the charts in detail and followed the principles

properly???

> > >

> > > 2. If a person is free to make his own decisions, why should he

> > > consult an astrologer, an astrolger then puts a bias on the

> > > decisions of the person.

> > >

> > > 3. If what has to happen, will happen then again what is the

use

> of

> > > an astrologer?

> > >

> > > 4. I am guessing most people only visit an astrologer when they

> > have

> > > troubles, Can you predict from a persons birth chart if this

> person

> > > wil consult astrologer in his lifetime, if yes then during what

> > > times in his life????

> > >

> > > It would be great to know what people this about these...

> > >

> > > - Shiva

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Gaurav,

 

The answer to 3 is already there in item 3 in Shiva's posting! It

was a rhetorical question :-)

 

RR

 

 

 

, "gauravkom"

<gauravkom> wrote:

> Hi Shiva,

> Perhaps you would have also taken my replies

independently

> then the answers would be more clear. Anyways, the answers what i

> feel should be are here but they may differ from person to person

>

> 1. first of all, if an astrologer has suggested you to join an X

> profession whereas you want to join Y, there is a reasoning behind

> it. Without any reason he wont suggest any profession( we are

talking

> about good astrologers). The reason is simple it is for the

benefit

> of the individual. Everyone aims for the betterment in this world

and

> rightly should be. So the decision should be seen as a step

towards

> one `s betterment not being biased. And the simple reason is

> experience and knowledge of the astrologer which you are relying

upon.

>

> 2. The answer is we cannot change the bad time or the bad effects

but

> certainly can lessen the effects by consulting a good astrologer

for

> possible remedies. So you see the main aim is to develop a

positive

> frame of mindset and not remain closed in a room where one is

> repeating the words what has to happen, will happen. Just remember

it

> is only and only by God`s grace that we can lessen the effects and

> astrologer is just a medium.

>

> 3. Well the answer to this one can be given someone who is more

> experienced than me perhaps Rohini ji would be a better person. As

i

> myself have never done such a prediction.

>

> I think you have got your answers to some extent. All the best in

> your quest.

>

> Gaurav

>

> , "trialjig"

<trialjig>

> wrote:

> > Hi gaurav,

> >

> > Interesting points, but let me clear something, on second readin

i

> > guess my questions were not very clear

> >

> > 1. If a person has let us say 2 choices and he goes to an

> astrologer

> > and then the astrologer says choice 1 is better according your

> > charts, then Is this person's decision not biased(( not the

> > astrologer)) by fear of facing difficulties if he chose choice 2.

> >

> > 2. If what has to happen, will happen( irresepective of a person

> > going to an astrologer or not) then what is the use of going to

an

> > astrologer?

> >

> > 3. My question was, can you tell by a person's birth chart, if

he

> > will visit an astrologer? for this question it is like asking

> > randomly if a person is born on june 14 2004 in delhi, india at

> 12.00

> > noon, will he/she goto an astrologer in his lifetime

> >

> >

> > All 3 queries are independent and they are not the same person,

i

> am

> > just asking these because i am still curious about role of

> astrology

> > in a persons life

> >

> >

> > -Shiva

> >

> >

> > , "gauravkom"

> <gauravkom>

> > wrote:

> > > Hi Shiva,

> > > The free will of an individual in a democratic society

> does

> > > give one an opportunity to explore the intriguing details of

the

> > > untouched and unexplored experiences. Be it from casting your

> vote

> > to

> > > assuming a situation where one may land into. But yet you will

> cast

> > > your vote to a person who you feel by your free will is the

right

> > > choice. Not because some astrologer told you to cast your vote

to

> a

> > > particular person only or otherwise if you dont then you will

> face

> > > the consequences in the time to come. Let s take your

questions

> one

> > > by one

> > >

> > > 1. Assuming the predicament one finds into the chances of

> becoming

> > a

> > > doctor or an engineer are remote if you dont study hard even

to

> > clear

> > > the entrance exam or pay for an NRI seat(if your father has

lots

> of

> > > money) even if you have the guidance of an astrologer who has

> read

> > > the charts in detail and followed the principles properly.

> > >

> > > 2. Assuming the person is free to make decisions why in the

world

> > do

> > > you think he will go to an astrologer, forget consulting an

> > > astrologer. It is common sense if a person is free to make

> > decisions

> > > then consulting an astrologer is not his free decision when

one

> > > thinks that astrologer will be biased. So the question should

be

> > why

> > > should one (who makes owns decisions) visit an astrologer.

> > >

> > > 3. Again the main use of astrologer is only served when one

> visits

> > an

> > > astrologer and uses his service. According to a person

exhibiting

> > his

> > > free will(and only accepts unbiased opinion) what do think are

> the

> > > chances of changing his free will and mindset that he will not

> cast

> > > the vote at all(what has to happen, will happen) with one pre

> > > condition he has got the name enrolled in the voters list.

> > >

> > > 4. Last but not the least can you predict from a persons birth

> > chart

> > > if this person will consult astrologer in his lifetime is

quite

> > > interesting. As to begin first of all, a birth chart is made

by

> an

> > > astrologer( nowdays we have lots of softwares also) so in a

way

> > there

> > > is a light at the end of tunnel which you need to see. The

fact

> is

> > > anyone who is in the process of getting a birthchart made has

in

> a

> > > way consulted an astrologer. So you see if tomorrow you become

an

> > > astrologer and someone comes up with the same question in one

of

> > the

> > > readings. The chances are 100 % yes as you are holding the

> > birthchart

> > > of the person which is a proof that your prediction is bound

to

> be

> > > true.

> > >

> > > I hope that the above will also satisfy any other members of

the

> > > group who have a more generous attitude of analysing things

with

> > > their free will.

> > >

> > > Gaurav

> > >

> > >

> > >

> > > , "trialjig"

> <trialjig>

> > > wrote:

> > > > Hi group,

> > > >

> > > > I have been interested in astrology for sometime now and

have

> > done

> > > > some preliminary reading, but not much. But i would like to

ask

> > you

> > > > some opinions

> > > >

> > > > 1. Assuming the astrologer has read your chart in great

detail

> > and

> > > > has spelled out a course of events, how much free-will is

> > available

> > > > to the person whose chart is read?

> > > >

> > > > For example, let us say a +2 student goes to an astrologer

and

> > asks

> > > > what his profession is likely to be and the astrologer

says :

> you

> > > > will be in the field of medicine.... At this point, what are

> the

> > > > chances of this person becoming a computer engineer???

Assume

> > that

> > > > the astrologer is using a well known system of astrology and

he

> > has

> > > > read the charts in detail and followed the principles

> properly???

> > > >

> > > > 2. If a person is free to make his own decisions, why should

he

> > > > consult an astrologer, an astrolger then puts a bias on the

> > > > decisions of the person.

> > > >

> > > > 3. If what has to happen, will happen then again what is the

> use

> > of

> > > > an astrologer?

> > > >

> > > > 4. I am guessing most people only visit an astrologer when

they

> > > have

> > > > troubles, Can you predict from a persons birth chart if this

> > person

> > > > wil consult astrologer in his lifetime, if yes then during

what

> > > > times in his life????

> > > >

> > > > It would be great to know what people this about these...

> > > >

> > > > - Shiva

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Hi Shiva,

So you see now that some questions do also reveal the

answers. Thanks Rohini ji....

 

Gaurav

 

 

, "rohiniranjan" <rrgb@s...>

wrote:

> Gaurav,

>

> The answer to 3 is already there in item 3 in Shiva's posting! It

> was a rhetorical question :-)

>

> RR

>

>

>

> , "gauravkom"

> <gauravkom> wrote:

> > Hi Shiva,

> > Perhaps you would have also taken my replies

> independently

> > then the answers would be more clear. Anyways, the answers what i

> > feel should be are here but they may differ from person to person

> >

> > 1. first of all, if an astrologer has suggested you to join an X

> > profession whereas you want to join Y, there is a reasoning

behind

> > it. Without any reason he wont suggest any profession( we are

> talking

> > about good astrologers). The reason is simple it is for the

> benefit

> > of the individual. Everyone aims for the betterment in this world

> and

> > rightly should be. So the decision should be seen as a step

> towards

> > one `s betterment not being biased. And the simple reason is

> > experience and knowledge of the astrologer which you are relying

> upon.

> >

> > 2. The answer is we cannot change the bad time or the bad effects

> but

> > certainly can lessen the effects by consulting a good astrologer

> for

> > possible remedies. So you see the main aim is to develop a

> positive

> > frame of mindset and not remain closed in a room where one is

> > repeating the words what has to happen, will happen. Just

remember

> it

> > is only and only by God`s grace that we can lessen the effects

and

> > astrologer is just a medium.

> >

> > 3. Well the answer to this one can be given someone who is more

> > experienced than me perhaps Rohini ji would be a better person.

As

> i

> > myself have never done such a prediction.

> >

> > I think you have got your answers to some extent. All the best in

> > your quest.

> >

> > Gaurav

> >

> > , "trialjig"

> <trialjig>

> > wrote:

> > > Hi gaurav,

> > >

> > > Interesting points, but let me clear something, on second

readin

> i

> > > guess my questions were not very clear

> > >

> > > 1. If a person has let us say 2 choices and he goes to an

> > astrologer

> > > and then the astrologer says choice 1 is better according your

> > > charts, then Is this person's decision not biased(( not the

> > > astrologer)) by fear of facing difficulties if he chose choice

2.

> > >

> > > 2. If what has to happen, will happen( irresepective of a

person

> > > going to an astrologer or not) then what is the use of going to

> an

> > > astrologer?

> > >

> > > 3. My question was, can you tell by a person's birth chart, if

> he

> > > will visit an astrologer? for this question it is like asking

> > > randomly if a person is born on june 14 2004 in delhi, india at

> > 12.00

> > > noon, will he/she goto an astrologer in his lifetime

> > >

> > >

> > > All 3 queries are independent and they are not the same person,

> i

> > am

> > > just asking these because i am still curious about role of

> > astrology

> > > in a persons life

> > >

> > >

> > > -Shiva

> > >

> > >

> > > , "gauravkom"

> > <gauravkom>

> > > wrote:

> > > > Hi Shiva,

> > > > The free will of an individual in a democratic

society

> > does

> > > > give one an opportunity to explore the intriguing details of

> the

> > > > untouched and unexplored experiences. Be it from casting your

> > vote

> > > to

> > > > assuming a situation where one may land into. But yet you

will

> > cast

> > > > your vote to a person who you feel by your free will is the

> right

> > > > choice. Not because some astrologer told you to cast your

vote

> to

> > a

> > > > particular person only or otherwise if you dont then you will

> > face

> > > > the consequences in the time to come. Let s take your

> questions

> > one

> > > > by one

> > > >

> > > > 1. Assuming the predicament one finds into the chances of

> > becoming

> > > a

> > > > doctor or an engineer are remote if you dont study hard even

> to

> > > clear

> > > > the entrance exam or pay for an NRI seat(if your father has

> lots

> > of

> > > > money) even if you have the guidance of an astrologer who has

> > read

> > > > the charts in detail and followed the principles properly.

> > > >

> > > > 2. Assuming the person is free to make decisions why in the

> world

> > > do

> > > > you think he will go to an astrologer, forget consulting an

> > > > astrologer. It is common sense if a person is free to make

> > > decisions

> > > > then consulting an astrologer is not his free decision when

> one

> > > > thinks that astrologer will be biased. So the question should

> be

> > > why

> > > > should one (who makes owns decisions) visit an astrologer.

> > > >

> > > > 3. Again the main use of astrologer is only served when one

> > visits

> > > an

> > > > astrologer and uses his service. According to a person

> exhibiting

> > > his

> > > > free will(and only accepts unbiased opinion) what do think

are

> > the

> > > > chances of changing his free will and mindset that he will

not

> > cast

> > > > the vote at all(what has to happen, will happen) with one pre

> > > > condition he has got the name enrolled in the voters list.

> > > >

> > > > 4. Last but not the least can you predict from a persons

birth

> > > chart

> > > > if this person will consult astrologer in his lifetime is

> quite

> > > > interesting. As to begin first of all, a birth chart is made

> by

> > an

> > > > astrologer( nowdays we have lots of softwares also) so in a

> way

> > > there

> > > > is a light at the end of tunnel which you need to see. The

> fact

> > is

> > > > anyone who is in the process of getting a birthchart made has

> in

> > a

> > > > way consulted an astrologer. So you see if tomorrow you

become

> an

> > > > astrologer and someone comes up with the same question in one

> of

> > > the

> > > > readings. The chances are 100 % yes as you are holding the

> > > birthchart

> > > > of the person which is a proof that your prediction is bound

> to

> > be

> > > > true.

> > > >

> > > > I hope that the above will also satisfy any other members of

> the

> > > > group who have a more generous attitude of analysing things

> with

> > > > their free will.

> > > >

> > > > Gaurav

> > > >

> > > >

> > > >

> > > > , "trialjig"

> > <trialjig>

> > > > wrote:

> > > > > Hi group,

> > > > >

> > > > > I have been interested in astrology for sometime now and

> have

> > > done

> > > > > some preliminary reading, but not much. But i would like to

> ask

> > > you

> > > > > some opinions

> > > > >

> > > > > 1. Assuming the astrologer has read your chart in great

> detail

> > > and

> > > > > has spelled out a course of events, how much free-will is

> > > available

> > > > > to the person whose chart is read?

> > > > >

> > > > > For example, let us say a +2 student goes to an astrologer

> and

> > > asks

> > > > > what his profession is likely to be and the astrologer

> says :

> > you

> > > > > will be in the field of medicine.... At this point, what

are

> > the

> > > > > chances of this person becoming a computer engineer???

> Assume

> > > that

> > > > > the astrologer is using a well known system of astrology

and

> he

> > > has

> > > > > read the charts in detail and followed the principles

> > properly???

> > > > >

> > > > > 2. If a person is free to make his own decisions, why

should

> he

> > > > > consult an astrologer, an astrolger then puts a bias on the

> > > > > decisions of the person.

> > > > >

> > > > > 3. If what has to happen, will happen then again what is

the

> > use

> > > of

> > > > > an astrologer?

> > > > >

> > > > > 4. I am guessing most people only visit an astrologer when

> they

> > > > have

> > > > > troubles, Can you predict from a persons birth chart if

this

> > > person

> > > > > wil consult astrologer in his lifetime, if yes then during

> what

> > > > > times in his life????

> > > > >

> > > > > It would be great to know what people this about these...

> > > > >

> > > > > - Shiva

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...