Question to all - Integrity of Jyotish Readings

[Guest guest]

Respected Members,

 

Generally once a horoscope is interpreted by an astrologer it is the

normal practise to go along with what has been said and try to

overcome those problems, but what happens if one astrologer says

something completely opposite of another astrolger? As astrological

advice can have a far-stretched affect on a persons life it is

necessary therefore to seek the advice of the consensus - a second or

third opinion even.

 

My horoscope details when interpreted by astrologers in the past have

always indicated a problem with getting along with people in terms of

relationships and so-forth, and have also termed me manglik, however

i have always felt that im actually a very kind hearted and nice

person to get along with then why do i always feel as if i cannot

relate to everyone properly, or shy away from certain social

situations. Astrologers have pedicted that because of my rahu-ketu on

the first-seventh house axis coupled with mars in the first house

would cause me a divorce. But i also have jupiter in lagna WITH the

Mangal and Rahu, so would that not be a positive affect on my

marriage?

 

 

Till now i have always accepted the fact that i will have marital

problems once i get married (as i am still single)and learned to cope

with the fact that marriage will not be heaven for me. However,

recently one astrolger said that i will have a happy marriage and

will not have anything like a divorce etc and it was said that all

other astrolgers have been incorrect in advising me so.

 

I respect all astrolgers advices, and understand that everyone will

have a different interpretation of events, However astrology cannot

be so far different that two people give such opposite views...or can

it?

 

So i therefore ask the opinion of everyone in this group to give me

the views of their interpretations and how such conclusions have been

reached.

 

I am a Leo Ascendant, with Mars/Rahu/Jupiter in lagna,

Mercury/Ketu in 7th house.

 

My details are:

Date of Birth: 05 February 1980

Time of Birth: 07:10 PM

place: London, UK

 

It will be interestin to know how astrologers can caste their views

on the different aspects in this chart! Many thanks- look forward to

the conclusion.

 

Warm Regards,

Shivani

[Guest guest]

Dear friend,

 

I think when analysis of chart is given along with reasons,

there will be no contradiction, even beginners can add and

improve their knowledge.

 

As regarding, human behaviour-

 

just think judiciously-

 

how would you react if

 

you get the same treatment

as you give to others.

 

Adding my comments in uppercase just below yours.

 

 

, "shivani_dass"

<shivani_dass> wrote:

 

> the first-seventh house axis coupled with mars in the first house

> would cause me a divorce.

 

NO THIS IS NOT TRUE, MARS IS THE MOST BENEFIC PLANET AND YOGA KARAKA

FOR LEO LAGNA.

 

 

But i also have jupiter in lagna WITH the

> Mangal and Rahu, so would that not be a positive affect on my

> marriage?

YES, IT WILL HAVE

YOUR RAHU IS A SERVANT OF THE SUN SIGN LORD

RAHU WILL PROVE MOST BENEFIC FOR YOU-

CONJUNCT 3 YOGA KARAKA-

YOGA KARAKA HOUSE- LAGNA- A FIRST RATE TRINE

YOGA KARAKA JUPITER

YOGA KARAKA MARS

>

>

> Till now i have always accepted the fact that i will have marital

> problems once i get married (as i am still single)and learned to

cope

> with the fact that marriage will not be heaven for me.

 

THERE IS NO SOUND BASIS OF YOUR NEGATIVE THINKINGS

 

However,

> recently one astrolger said that i will have a happy marriage and

> will not have anything like a divorce etc and it was said that all

> other astrolgers have been incorrect in advising me so.

YES, WHAT HE TOLD YOU IS JUSTIFIED AND REASONABLE AS EXPLINED ABOVE

SIMPLY PREDICTING BAD WITHOUT- REASONABLE ASSESSMENT IS NOT CORRECT.

 

 

JUST CHECK THE NEGATIVE RESULT OF KETU'S PLACEMENT IN 7TH HOUSE.

 

OTHEREWISE THERE IS NO FAULT IN YOUR CHART.

 

WITH BEST WISHES FOR A HAPPY AND PROSPEROUS MARRIED LIFE

 

Mandakini

--

for marriage related issues please visit

jyotimac

[Guest guest]

Dear Shivani,

 

It is frustrating, more so for the nativity, but also for astrologers

when they run into situations like these where there have been

discrepancies in the past as to the interpretation or more often

the 'weight of significance' given to a combination or factor, such

as KSY, Sade sati of shani, mangal dosh or the presence of rahu ketu

in ascendant/7th (often seen in the charts of individuals who have

been married for more than two decades despite problems, where others

with mahapurusha yoga or other benefic combinations in 1/7 have

parted company within months of holy matrimony!). This is rendered

more complicated when 2nd opinions are sought without the 2nd expert

being privy to the 1st expert's train of thought. There is also the

problem about not fully documenting the train of thought or factors

that lead to a 'prediction' or reading. This is not as easy as it

seems or is made out to be.

 

Individuals often confuse internet or discussion group snippets of

readings as being a properly done reading. The settings are

different, the purposes are different and the expertise varies from

individual to another. There is also the factor of the nativity

misinterpreting what was originally said or even written. Such can be

the overriding influence of dashas and transits at times that despite

getting a written reading, individuals have gone out to seek

gemstones that were not prescribed and getting into trouble or having

no effect whatsoever. Hence, over the years I have begun to see the

value in a properly done one-on-one reading with followup, as opposed

to what I call McJyotish (the fast-food trend in astrology).

 

Please do not misinterpret this as advice against internet jyotish,

but just so the expectations entertained by seekers become more

realistic, and jyotish does not mistakenly get the blame.

 

Wishing you success in the solution that you seek.

 

RR

 

 

, "shivani_dass"

<shivani_dass> wrote:

> Respected Members,

>

> Generally once a horoscope is interpreted by an astrologer it is

the

> normal practise to go along with what has been said and try to

> overcome those problems, but what happens if one astrologer says

> something completely opposite of another astrolger? As astrological

> advice can have a far-stretched affect on a persons life it is

> necessary therefore to seek the advice of the consensus - a second

or

> third opinion even.

>

> My horoscope details when interpreted by astrologers in the past

have

> always indicated a problem with getting along with people in terms

of

> relationships and so-forth, and have also termed me manglik,

however

> i have always felt that im actually a very kind hearted and nice

> person to get along with then why do i always feel as if i cannot

> relate to everyone properly, or shy away from certain social

> situations. Astrologers have pedicted that because of my rahu-ketu

on

> the first-seventh house axis coupled with mars in the first house

> would cause me a divorce. But i also have jupiter in lagna WITH the

> Mangal and Rahu, so would that not be a positive affect on my

> marriage?

>

>

> Till now i have always accepted the fact that i will have marital

> problems once i get married (as i am still single)and learned to

cope

> with the fact that marriage will not be heaven for me. However,

> recently one astrolger said that i will have a happy marriage and

> will not have anything like a divorce etc and it was said that all

> other astrolgers have been incorrect in advising me so.

>

> I respect all astrolgers advices, and understand that everyone will

> have a different interpretation of events, However astrology cannot

> be so far different that two people give such opposite views...or

can

> it?

>

> So i therefore ask the opinion of everyone in this group to give me

> the views of their interpretations and how such conclusions have

been

> reached.

>

> I am a Leo Ascendant, with Mars/Rahu/Jupiter in lagna,

> Mercury/Ketu in 7th house.

>

> My details are:

> Date of Birth: 05 February 1980

> Time of Birth: 07:10 PM

> place: London, UK

>

> It will be interestin to know how astrologers can caste their views

> on the different aspects in this chart! Many thanks- look forward

to

> the conclusion.

>

> Warm Regards,

> Shivani