Guest guest Posted February 22, 2006 Report Share Posted February 22, 2006 Friends, I have often read ,seen and experienced over these years that people , both astrologers and the jathaks are afraid of above planets. More than the gullible public, it is the ill informed and illread Adhe adhure so called Jyotishacharyas wanting to make a fast buck are to blame. Many times in the past, I have raised the question of having a fresher look at Karakatwa of planets. I had taken the case of Jupiter being given divine portfolios of many things whereas in actuality, Jupiter tends to destroy the bhava it occupies. Rahu-Ketu give best Computer engineers but are treated with Tuchhakaara .And in the same manner, Mars gives some of the best administrators but is looked at with fear. Each planet has its plus and minus Gunas. Shall we discuss these here? Tatvam-Asi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2006 Report Share Posted February 22, 2006 Dada, I thought you would never ask!! Of course we should discuss it. "Discuss" to some these days has become reduced to 'confrontation' and side swipes -- sad as it may be but discussion is really something to be done without emotions. Given the narrow unidimensional reality of internet this can prove to be a challenge as has been demonstrated time and again. My apologies for venting my frustrations! Frustrated as I too am about what you alluded to -- I have begun to appreciate, mistakenly perhaps, that this karmic drama is more complex than it is made out to be. All -- nativities, acharyas E07, acharyas E-07, etc are all important to complete the script. The basic truth we all believe in is that the Universe is fair and just. It all works out in the end, speedbumps notwithstanding and if one persists, on the internet for instance, as in the other reality that hosts the internet, arpanet whatever one wants to address it as -- constancy is the key. I have read what you posted in this mayavini nagri of internet now for a few years and the message has been constant, for sure. So, qudos for persistence coming obviously through a strong belief in the truth as you see it, no matter what. Please allow the ant to express his perspective but what I see is that planets are multidimensional. They are like the computer games with multiple levels of difficulty, complexity. The player chooses through their actions and levels and at what point of Karma Kurriculam they are at, the manifestation, perspective and expression of a given planet. Karaka consideration for instance gives some insight into that. Karaka, for instance atmakaraka using the charakaraka scheme would not automatically mean the means of expression or experience of self. I have great difficulty about separating the Jaimini considerations from Parashara considerations as some jyotishis insist must be separated. Some planet like mars, direct and somewhat reckless of personal consequences would not be switching hats, and playing the parashari role one day and jaimini role the other day! Simply ridiculous concept regardless of where it is coming from. On the other hand, depending on the recipient, the role of the karaka would change. The prime minister of a country would behave differently with the press, with his opponents, his caucus, his wife in public, his wife in private, his infant child, his teenager child, and the same child when he is an adult (and there have been prime ministers who have been PMs that long to see their children grow up while still being PMs!). The point I am trying to make through a real world analogy, an anthropomorphic human example is that like us humans in this mayavini world, akin to a theatre stage, the planets also have similar nuances and roles. The astrological framework, afterall, is supposed to image the worldly reality -- hence its ability to reflect (pun natural and unintended) the drama that the soul was supposed to play on this worldly stage. To cut to the chase -- karakatwa of a plaent must not be considered in isolation but alongwith its other roles and the resultant considered when pronouncing a verdict, a signature interpreted. Multifactorial consideration, a blend, a melange of ingredients just as some of your beautiful, tasteful recipes at your website has such a close parallel to astrology and astrological readings. Cooking, Chemistry and astrological guidance -- have such a lot in common that it cannot be accidental! RR , "om_tatsat_om" <om_tatsat_om wrote: > > Friends, > > I have often read ,seen and experienced over these years that people , > both astrologers and the jathaks are afraid of above planets. > More than the gullible public, it is the ill informed and illread Adhe > adhure so called Jyotishacharyas wanting to make a fast buck are to > blame. > Many times in the past, I have raised the question of having a fresher > look at Karakatwa of planets. > I had taken the case of Jupiter being given divine portfolios of many > things whereas in actuality, Jupiter tends to destroy the bhava it > occupies. > Rahu-Ketu give best Computer engineers but are treated with > Tuchhakaara .And in the same manner, Mars gives some of the best > administrators but is looked at with fear. > > Each planet has its plus and minus Gunas. > Shall we discuss these here? > > Tatvam-Asi > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2006 Report Share Posted February 22, 2006 Dear Omtasat ji, Most of the indications that come out of some books relating to these three planets (viz) rahu,sani and mars have been depicted as such.As a result irrespective of where ever these planets are located and influenced through (PAC) by other plants,there is some tendency to ignore and hand over fixed views and rush for remedies for malific results . Even as you pointed Rahu facilitates for many things including for marraige,getting children and brings recognition and instills spirit of competitiveness and combative skills.Ofcourse all these considerations must ahve credence to the position of rahu in the chart and to influence those apart from normal karakatwas.Infacts though these are basic,I fell often they get transposed and tend to behave with reference to location and sign. Mars no doubt being an energy planets makes super cops,generals and also administrators.Mars/kuja/Angaraka as popularly known gets identified with krura swabhava(like Sun) and the tag of malefic character gets appended.It is certainly not correct to characterise as such to give only bad effects. Saturn as such the master that brings values and ever willing to bring changes reforms is rverred and respected for wrong reasons.If one is determined willing to strain and swet,saturn helps and rewards. may be we need to bring in some harmony while making judgements.it is not that always brings only good to life and all other become troublesome.Infact this demarcation in several cases does not stand to the test of reality.During dasa of saturn,most of the person succeed and flourish in studies,make also a happy beginning for employment and join their partners etc. probably our approach for the knowledge science like jyotish needs a review and refinement .This is possible only when we do not stretch the topics like sadesati,kendradhipati yoga and all othe yogas too far.This is time we put more attention on the chart and drill them to find and come out how planets changed their behavious and promote the human perspectives Krishnan om_tatsat_om <om_tatsat_om wrote: Friends, I have often read ,seen and experienced over these years that people , both astrologers and the jathaks are afraid of above planets. More than the gullible public, it is the ill informed and illread Adhe adhure so called Jyotishacharyas wanting to make a fast buck are to blame. Many times in the past, I have raised the question of having a fresher look at Karakatwa of planets. I had taken the case of Jupiter being given divine portfolios of many things whereas in actuality, Jupiter tends to destroy the bhava it occupies. Rahu-Ketu give best Computer engineers but are treated with Tuchhakaara .And in the same manner, Mars gives some of the best administrators but is looked at with fear. Each planet has its plus and minus Gunas. Shall we discuss these here? Tatvam-Asi SURRENDER JOYFULLY TO THE WILL OF THE ULTIMATE DIVINITY AND RELISH THE TASTE OF ABSOLUTE BLISS. Vedic astrology Astrology chart Astrology software Visit your group "" on the web. Brings words and photos together (easily) with PhotoMail - it's free and works with Mail. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 22, 2006 Report Share Posted February 22, 2006 Dear Krishnan ji, Good post! One comment though on your example of saturn dasha and in general -- It is important to note and makes a big difference even jyotish neophytes would admit and must have observed. The age at which the dasha operates! Saturn dasha happening during teenage would have such a different expression than the same dasha towards the end of life. In fact, realistically speaking, if groups of individuals are examined, most tend to have similar experiences in general, despite different dashas and rulerships and so on. It is always the 'exceptions' to the rules that tend to attract our attention, make good "copy" in general and are the ones picked up and described and discussed by authors and article writers, the modern teachers! Most students of such forums of instructions, though would be required to meet the general public, which somehow does not get discussed in instructional material for the most part. I think they should be included more and not just the exceptions. Imagine, if a doctor were trained only about rare diseases and exceptional syndromes, when the rubber hits the road or more appropriately when the stethoscope hits the chest, these doctors may find it difficult to diagnose a commonplace congestion of chest or asthma or something like that. And of course each time a celebrity is discussed there is the cloud of confusion around their birthdata -- like I noticed in some forum recently where they are discussing Sri Ravishankar ji (Art of Living)'s chart. RR , vattem krishnan <bursar_99 wrote: > > Dear Omtasat ji, > Most of the indications that come out of some books relating to these three planets (viz) rahu,sani and mars have been depicted as such.As a result irrespective of where ever these planets are located and influenced through (PAC) by other plants,there is some tendency to ignore and hand over fixed views and rush for remedies for malific results . > Even as you pointed Rahu facilitates for many things including for marraige,getting children and brings recognition and instills spirit of competitiveness and combative skills.Ofcourse all these considerations must ahve credence to the position of rahu in the chart and to influence those apart from normal karakatwas.Infacts though these are basic,I fell often they get transposed and tend to behave with reference to location and sign. > Mars no doubt being an energy planets makes super cops,generals and also administrators.Mars/kuja/Angaraka as popularly known gets identified with krura swabhava(like Sun) and the tag of malefic character gets appended.It is certainly not correct to characterise as such to give only bad effects. > Saturn as such the master that brings values and ever willing to bring changes reforms is rverred and respected for wrong reasons.If one is determined willing to strain and swet,saturn helps and rewards. > may be we need to bring in some harmony while making judgements.it is not that always brings only good to life and all other become troublesome.Infact this demarcation in several cases does not stand to the test of reality.During dasa of saturn,most of the person succeed and flourish in studies,make also a happy beginning for employment and join their partners etc. > probably our approach for the knowledge science like jyotish needs a review and refinement .This is possible only when we do not stretch the topics like sadesati,kendradhipati yoga and all othe yogas too far.This is time we put more attention on the chart and drill them to find and come out how planets changed their behavious and promote the human perspectives > Krishnan > > om_tatsat_om <om_tatsat_om wrote: > Friends, > > I have often read ,seen and experienced over these years that people , > both astrologers and the jathaks are afraid of above planets. > More than the gullible public, it is the ill informed and illread Adhe > adhure so called Jyotishacharyas wanting to make a fast buck are to > blame. > Many times in the past, I have raised the question of having a fresher > look at Karakatwa of planets. > I had taken the case of Jupiter being given divine portfolios of many > things whereas in actuality, Jupiter tends to destroy the bhava it > occupies. > Rahu-Ketu give best Computer engineers but are treated with > Tuchhakaara .And in the same manner, Mars gives some of the best > administrators but is looked at with fear. > > Each planet has its plus and minus Gunas. > Shall we discuss these here? > > Tatvam-Asi > > SURRENDER JOYFULLY TO THE WILL OF THE ULTIMATE DIVINITY AND RELISH THE TASTE OF ABSOLUTE BLISS. > > > > > > > Vedic astrology Astrology chart Astrology software > > > > > > Visit your group "" on the web. > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > > > > > Brings words and photos together (easily) with > PhotoMail - it's free and works with Mail. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.