Guest guest Posted June 25, 2001 Report Share Posted June 25, 2001 Namaste. First let me clarify my stand regarding respected BV Raman. His books had upto a certain point in time, used Lahiri Ayanamsa, as did everyone else. Then in his later books he naturally changed the ayanamsa. If you notice very carefully, he sometimes even uses Raman Ayanamsa for the graha positions and Lahiri for the Vimshottari Dasa?! This all becomes very confusing. The best example of this is Rabidranath Tagores horoscope, which he in his book; Notable horoscopes, used Lahiri Ayanamsa for the calculations. And yes its common knowledge of those devoted to Raman, that he used Lahiri Ayanamsa before. What happened afterwards only creates confussion to me. What must be stressed thou, was that he used Lahiri initially, and so should we. Later when we've grown with experience we can change it. Dear Jaan, i won't even try predicting anything on your chart until Dhira Krsna and I have finished the discussion on his chart. When we are done, please present your chart and question again. Best wishes, Visti. - jaan911 (AT) hotmail (DOT) com vedic astrology Monday, June 25, 2001 1:22 PM [vedic astrology] Re: psychic powers - Lahiri/ayanamsa puzzle Dear Visti,can i ask where you heard that Dr Raman never came forward with his ayanamsa?in a few of his books he has listed his ayanamsa for various yrs. i havent seen his ephemerises to comment but the appendices in some of his books do list his ayanamsa value.where did you get the information that he was using lahiri ayanamsa before? practically all his charts published in his books have been cast using of his own ayanamsa as far as i know, unless of course he went back and changed them and edited the comments to suit Raman divisional charts, i dont know of the dates where he might have changed the charts.if anyone is interested in a test , my own chart changes quite drastically depending on what ayanamsa you use.if anyone feels confident enough in their abilities or ayanamsa then feel free to make a comment on the following areas of the chart ..the key changes depending on ayanamsa are to education, work/social activities, aspitarions, sibblings, sexuality, relationships, people i associate with, inherent talent and spirituality.vimshottari dates change drastically also. i think vimshottari dasa can be used as the moon sign is sufficiently stronger than lagna.date of birth 11th october 1973place brunei, 4/56 N 114/55 Etime 20:38 ( 12:38 pm GMT) 8 hours east of gmtlagna should be taurus 4 to 7 degrees, navamsa lagna aquarius.depending on what ayanamsa you use the divisional charts gives totally different results especially the navamsa.are you up for it Visti? or anyone else?lovejaanvedic astrology, "Visti Larsen" <vlarsen@h...> wrote:> Dear Dhira Krsna, Namaste.> > BV Raman, never openly came forward with his Ayanamsa, only until later on> did people discover that he had shifted from Lahiri to a different Ayanamsa,> but he never stated its name nor why he had used it. The main point here is> that he had used Lahiri for a long time, and didn't tell anyone to use his> Ayanamsa. Now ponder why none of the astrologers taught and researching by> his side, used the so called; "Raman Ayanamsa".> > As for timing events as an example, this won't help anyone decide if the> astrologer doesn't have any predictive strength.> > Instead tell us why one event couldn't have happened using Lahiri Ayanamsa,> and why it could with yours.> > Make sure you use the relevant varga, and then we have ourselves a propper> discussion.> Best wishes, Visti.> ----- Original Message -----> Dhira Krsna (das) BCS (Radhadesh - B)> To: vedic astrology> Saturday, June 23, 2001 5:03 PM> Subject: [vedic astrology] psychic powers - Lahiri/ayanamsa puzzle> > > Dear Visti,> > Pranam.> > >Dear Dhira.> >On what basis have you taken an ayanamsa thats 2 degrees different from> >Lahiri?> >Isn't that stretching it abit too much?> > I don't think this is stretching too much, after all, BV Raman accepted an> ayanamsa which is 1 degree 27 different from Lahiri. BV Raman is an> experienced astrologer, why he differed from Lahiri that much? And there> is> also Ushi-shashi who takes an even greater difference of about 3 degrees> 37.> Well, with due regard to Ushi-sashi (btw, do you have info who is> Ushi-sashi?), I personally think that's far too off the reality, but I> accept this ayanamsa of mine on the basis of my personal experience. My> Vimsottari dasha just looks perfect like this.> > >I can barely find a 1 arc error in Lahiri!> > OK, let's have a puzzle to test our ayanamsa. With Lahiri, try to find out> what happened on May 14th 2001 at 1:30 am local time (coordinates of my> birthplace) TZ GMT +1 with 1 hour daylight savings, which resulted in the> activity on May 17th 2001 at 10 am.> > All attempts are welcome. Maybe others can also have a try?> > Your sishya,> Dhira Krsna dasa> > Sponsor> > > > Archives: vedic astrology> > Group info: vedic astrology/info.html> > To UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology-> > ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us .......> > || Om Tat Sat || Sarvam Sri Krishnaarpanamastu ||> > Terms of Service.Archives: vedic astrologyGroup info: vedic astrology/info.htmlTo UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology-....... May Jupiter's light shine on us .......|| Om Tat Sat || Sarvam Sri Krishnaarpanamastu || Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 26, 2001 Report Share Posted June 26, 2001 Dear Visti, Pranam. >As for timing events as an example, this won't help anyone decide if the >astrologer doesn't have any predictive strength. > >Instead tell us why one event couldn't have happened using Lahiri Ayanamsa, >and why it could with yours. Indeed, in regard to dasha periods, if one is a little skillful in jugglery, then one can explain any life event with any ayanamsa. However, I hope you do agree with me that for timing death, the Sun should be in trines to mrtyupada, A8. Then explain to me why on Nov. 14th, 1977, in Vrindavan, India at 19:25 Bhaktivedanta Swami could have left his body using the Lahiri ayanamsa? You can try with any lagna, Dhanus, Makara, Vrishika. Unless you accept that the time zone was quite different than what we generally accept and his lagna would have been Kumbha. Your sishya, Dhira Krsna dasa Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 28, 2001 Report Share Posted June 28, 2001 Dear Dhira Krsna. Your right. Did you know that conception also occurs when the Sun is in trines to Darapada? Actually there are some exceptions, and especially in the charts of saints, we shouldn't be to quick to time death. However the Sun's transit isn't excuse enough, to rectify a birthtime that much. Instead try to rectify the charts using other basic principles. I don't have Bhaktivedanta's chart, so i won't comment on why he died on that specific date, but i would like to see it nevertheless, as i have some ideas as to why it happened. We rarely get off that easy with timing events. Best wishes, Visti. Dear Visti,Pranam.>As for timing events as an example, this won't help anyone decide if the>astrologer doesn't have any predictive strength.>>Instead tell us why one event couldn't have happened using Lahiri Ayanamsa,>and why it could with yours.Indeed, in regard to dasha periods, if one is a little skillful in jugglery,then one can explain any life event with any ayanamsa.However, I hope you do agree with me that for timing death, the Sun shouldbe in trines to mrtyupada, A8. Then explain to me why on Nov. 14th, 1977, inVrindavan, India at 19:25 Bhaktivedanta Swami could have left his body usingthe Lahiri ayanamsa? You can try with any lagna, Dhanus, Makara, Vrishika.Unless you accept that the time zone was quite different than what wegenerally accept and his lagna would have been Kumbha.Your sishya,Dhira Krsna dasaArchives: vedic astrologyGroup info: vedic astrology/info.htmlTo UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology-....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.