Guest guest Posted January 2, 2002 Report Share Posted January 2, 2002 Hi all, I've a basic query about horary astrology. Not many can disagree that planets and their positions are the principal cause of actions by us and around us, and of reactions and effects on and around us too. Having read the initial portions of the lovely Prasna Marga, what isn't very logically clear is how the time when a prasna is actually put to the astrologer is more important than when the prasna occurs to the native. In fact, the time of occurrence of the thought has no mention at all in PM !! It might occur to someone at 10 am to ask an astrologer about a business investment but due to various factors, he may not be able to meet his astrologer until 4pm. The prasna will still be based on what occurred to him at 10 am and not 4 pm, right? The principles of horary astrology have been time-tested and proven correct over and over again, which is why the logic behind what I've asked should make for interesting reading. I guess it'll be something along the lines of "Providence will ensure that you meet the astrologer and put your prasna at a time when planetary positions will provide the right answer, no matter when the thought in you occurred." Or is it? Warm regards, Ramapriya hubli Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2002 Report Share Posted January 3, 2002 Hare Rama Krsna Dear Ramapriya! This is a debatable topic and their is no consensus even among the stalwarts. Use it personally to see how it works. For me, when the person is putting the query to the astrologer, then only the person is destined to know the solution of his problems, hence the prasna time should be based on that. This is more than a pure science and more to do with the intuition and the karmic pattern of the individual putting the question. An astrologer who is very high in spirituality will find himself capable of giving the solution to any problem through prasna, whatever time, he choses to take!!!! :-) How could you know when the prasna has started conceiving and even how could you be sure that you have completely comprehended the problem/ issue. Hence you can never be sure when you have generated the pransa in your mind. The only way is to put it before and astrologer and you will now what exactly is botherig you. Regards Sarajit - "ramapriya_d" <ramapriya_d <vedic astrology> Thursday, January 03, 2002 12:38 PM [vedic astrology] A prasna on prasna > Hi all, > > I've a basic query about horary astrology. Not many can disagree that > planets and their positions are the principal cause of actions by us > and around us, and of reactions and effects on and around us too. > Having read the initial portions of the lovely Prasna Marga, what > isn't very logically clear is how the time when a prasna is actually > put to the astrologer is more important than when the prasna occurs > to the native. In fact, the time of occurrence of the thought has no > mention at all in PM !! > > It might occur to someone at 10 am to ask an astrologer about a > business investment but due to various factors, he may not be able to > meet his astrologer until 4pm. The prasna will still be based on what > occurred to him at 10 am and not 4 pm, right? > > The principles of horary astrology have been time-tested and proven > correct over and over again, which is why the logic behind what I've > asked should make for interesting reading. I guess it'll be something > along the lines of "Providence will ensure that you meet the > astrologer and put your prasna at a time when planetary positions > will provide the right answer, no matter when the thought in you > occurred." > > Or is it? > > Warm regards, > > Ramapriya > > hubli > > > > > > > > > > > ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... > > > > Your use of is subject to > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2002 Report Share Posted January 3, 2002 JAI GURUDEV. Dear Ramapriya, You can just try to corelate things to conception and deleviry. The thought of asking question or the inducement of urge or real question of the person may be similer to just conception and the time of consultation with the astrologer can be equated to time of delivery of the baby. Here what is more intrigueing is whether one should take i)the time of query by the consultee or ii)exact time when astrologer starts working on the query. Nowadays, compare to olden days scenario has completely changed. The astrologer might not attempt to analyse the query immidiately upon being approached and he may tell/he would preffer to work out at later time and tell the result. For my humble knowledge later (consideration of time) seems to be more reasonable. Have you ever thought that, at one point of time one might decide to go to an astrologer with regard to some query but to decide against it after few hours/days! Is this not reminds you of abortions! Hence Pundits might have realised that until the query has been put to the notice of scholarly brahmin, the question is not ripen. Mohan Hegde. - ramapriya_d vedic astrology Thursday, January 03, 2002 12:38 PM [vedic astrology] A prasna on prasna Hi all,I've a basic query about horary astrology. Not many can disagree that planets and their positions are the principal cause of actions by us and around us, and of reactions and effects on and around us too. Having read the initial portions of the lovely Prasna Marga, what isn't very logically clear is how the time when a prasna is actually put to the astrologer is more important than when the prasna occurs to the native. In fact, the time of occurrence of the thought has no mention at all in PM !!It might occur to someone at 10 am to ask an astrologer about a business investment but due to various factors, he may not be able to meet his astrologer until 4pm. The prasna will still be based on what occurred to him at 10 am and not 4 pm, right?The principles of horary astrology have been time-tested and proven correct over and over again, which is why the logic behind what I've asked should make for interesting reading. I guess it'll be something along the lines of "Providence will ensure that you meet the astrologer and put your prasna at a time when planetary positions will provide the right answer, no matter when the thought in you occurred."Or is it?Warm regards,Ramapriyahubli (AT) vsnl (DOT) comArchives: vedic astrologyGroup info: vedic astrology/info.htmlTo UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology-....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2002 Report Share Posted January 3, 2002 JAYA JAGANNATHA! Dear Ramapriya, Namaste. > Hi all, > > I've a basic query about horary astrology. Not many can disagree that > planets and their positions are the principal cause of actions by us > and around us, and of reactions and effects on and around us too. > Having read the initial portions of the lovely Prasna Marga, what > isn't very logically clear is how the time when a prasna is actually > put to the astrologer is more important than when the prasna occurs > to the native. In fact, the time of occurrence of the thought has no > mention at all in PM !! Well, the first thought is that the cause of actions is our previous actions, i.e. karma. The planets don't cause us to act, tehy just move universal forcas in a way to give us our karmic phala (fruits) and also an opportunity to make further decisions. The second thought is the question of which time to take for interpreting a Prashna chart. Well, if you read carefully, you will see a whole process delineated for finding the Prashna Arudha, i.e. the ascendat of the Prashna chart. This includes throwing chowries etc. (Astamangala Deva Prashna). So the actual chart is designed to be independent both from the time of putting and receiving the query. Of course it's implied that there was not such a big interwal between the two, i.e. the planets' position didn't change so much within that time. So by erecting the Prashna Arudha we have a specific chart for answering that query. > It might occur to someone at 10 am to ask an astrologer about a > business investment but due to various factors, he may not be able to > meet his astrologer until 4pm. The prasna will still be based on what > occurred to him at 10 am and not 4 pm, right? Yes, but according to the above, the Lagna will not depend on any of the two timings. Of course the Moon for example could change signs or Nakshatras within that interval, but then you should check which one fo the two positions will reflect the condition of the querist more graphically. Also don't forget about the Shakunas, which were used especially in doubtful cases to decide which answer is the correct. But all this needs a very good intuition (i.e. relationship with God). > The principles of horary astrology have been time-tested and proven > correct over and over again, which is why the logic behind what I've > asked should make for interesting reading. I guess it'll be something > along the lines of "Providence will ensure that you meet the > astrologer and put your prasna at a time when planetary positions > will provide the right answer, no matter when the thought in you > occurred." Yes, something like that. At any cost, especially for being able to correctly answer a Prashna, the astrologer should depend very much on the Almihgty. Yours, Gauranga Das Vedic Astrologer gauranga Jyotish Remedies: WWW.BRIHASPATI.NET Phone:+36-309-140-839 _______ Get your free @ address at Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.