To Sudarsan: Saturn's Tarnsit to Gemini-A doubt

[Guest guest]

I am sure Narasimhaji will respond, but from a purely astronomical

point of view the motion of any planet with te Sun is not linear but

is more of an elliptical orbit. So it would be a case of 2 elliptical

equations getting combined, which are in no way linear. It will at

least be a second order (or higher) equation of motion.

Respected gurus can please correct me if I am wrong.

Viraj

 

vedic astrology, "sudhar_srinivasan" <sudhar108>

wrote:

> Hare Rama Krishna

>

> Dear Guru Narasimha,

>

> Thank you once again for your comments.Since the Earth-Saturn-

transit

> relationship is non-linear, is it safe to assume that the positions

> relative to Earth are arrived at by the combination of Two linear

> relationships, i.e,

> 1)Relationship of Earth with the Sun PLUS

> 2)Relationship of Saturn with Sun.

>

> Again this is assuming that the relationships with Sun are Linear.I

> thought this would be the intuitive alternate route.

>

> Appreciate your comments if time-permits.

>

> Yours

>

> Sudharsan

>

> Jaya Jagannatha

>

>

>

vedic astrology, "pvr108" <pvr@c...> wrote:

> > Dear Sudharsan,

> >

> > (1) Yes, geocentric positions are to be used.

> >

> > (2) There is no consensus between the followers of vakya

siddhantas

> > and drik siddhanta. People following vakya siddhanta (esp some

> > Tamils) use approximate formulas for planetary positions. Most

> > people, including the asthana siddhanti of reverred Kanchi

peetham,

> > follow drik siddhanta and use the refined planetary models given

by

> > the latest observatories.

> >

> > In addition, ayanamsa can change Saturn's transit dates by a few

> > months. But, the impact is little this time due to the fast

motion.

> > Whether you use Lahiri ayanamsa or Krishnamoorthy ayanamsa or

Raman

> > ayanamsa, Saturn's transit is in July (July 22nd, 21st or 5th).

> >

> > But people following vakya siddhanta can be off by a lot more.

> >

> > (3) BTW, you cannot take the position on a date and derive the

> > position of another date using a linear formula (i.e. 30 deg per

> 2.5

> > years). The motion is nonlinear. Period.

> >

> > (4) As Jupiter (life force) becomes exalted and later Saturn

> > (depression) leaves exalted Rahu (materialism) in the second

house

> > (wealth) in the natural zodiac, markets should most likely start

to

> > get out of troubled waters. This is a transit to look forward to.

> >

> > May Jupiter's light shine on us,

> > Narasimha

> >

> > > Dear Narasimha Guru,

> > > Thank you. Yes the temple I referred to uses the Vakhya

> Siddhanta,

> > I

> > > was referring to the Titunallaru Sanishwara temple.Your

comments

> > have

> > > raised a few more questions/doubts,

> > >

> > > 1)Since we are on Earth wouldnt it be more suitable for us to

use

> > the

> > > effects of Saturnine transit based on its forward, retrograde ,

> > slow

> > > and fast movements?

> > >

> > > 2)How do the Jyotisha who use the Vakhya Siddhanta and those

that

> > use

> > > the Drik Siddhanta establish consensus?

> > >

> > >

> > > Regarding the markets,an upward swing would be very

> welcome.Equity

> > > analysis is my line of work and these two years have been the

> > > toughest yet.

> > >

> > > I really appreciate your taking the time to deal with my

> > questions.I

> > > am a novice who is still plagued by many doubts /questions.

> > >

> > > Jaya Jagannatha

> > >

> > > Sudharsan