Tithi Ashtottari

[Guest guest]

Namaste Waldemar,

 

You pay attention to what you read!

 

I had implemented antardasas this way 3 years back, when Sanjay

taught me TP and TA dasa. I had implemented it in consultation with

Sanjay and both of us have been using the software during this time.

 

However, when I referred Sanjay's latest book, I did see what you

mentioned. Clearly there is a discrepancy here. Let me get this

clarified by him and change my tutorial and software if needed.

 

Thank you very much for paying attention and bringing this to my

attention!

 

May Jupiter's light shine on us,

Narasimha

 

> Dear Narasimha,

>

> Your article about TP chart & Tithi Astottari dasa is great.

However, for

> count of antardasa you are not following exactly the teaching of

Sanjay in

> its "Vimshottari and Udu dasa's". You wrote:

>

> "Antardasas start from the planet after dasa lord and go in the

order of

> dasas. For example, in Saturn dasa, the first antardasa will be

that of

> Jupiter. Antardasas will go as Jupiter, Rahu, Venus, Sun, Moon,

Mars,

> Mercury and Saturn."

>

> S.Rath write for antardasa in Ashtottari dasa (p.179):

> "since Ketu is the governor of the Ashtottari dasa, the antardasa

shall be

> reckoned in the reverse to established practice" and

> "the first antardasa is of the planet preceding this" following by

an

> example

> "for Sun dasa, the first antaradasa is Venus, next of Rahu, next of

Jupiter

> and so on".

> For Tithi Ashtottari he writes (p.187):

> " the dasa, antardasa and other sub-periods as well as their order

is

> exactly the same as the Ashtottari dasa"

>

> Is yours opinion different from this statement?

>

> With best regards

>

> Waldemar

[Guest guest]

Namaste Waldemar,

 

One more word on the same thing:

 

In the same book by Sanjay ("Vimsottari dasa"), a little after your

quote on subperiods in Ashtottari dasa, he gives examples. Go through

the calculations and you will see that he is actually using the

approach I mentioned.

 

For example, take the native of the following birthdata:

 

April 20, 1971

Time: 16:20:00

Time Zone: 5:30:00 (East of GMT)

Longitude: 79 E 35' 00"

Latitude: 18 N 00' 00"

 

Sanjay used him as "Ashtottari Case 1". He gave the mahadasa

calculations as:

 

"Table 37: Astottari dasa –Case-1

Ashtottari Dasa Maha Dasas:

Jup: 1967-09-02 (17:36:28) - 1986-09-02 (14:27:15)

Rah: 1986-09-02 (14:27:15) - 1998-09-02 (16:10:24)

Ven: 1998-09-02 (16:10:24) - 2019-09-03 (01:25:54)

Sun: 2019-09-03 (01:25:54) - 2025-09-02 (14:11:21)

Moo: 2025-09-02 (14:11:21) - 2040-09-02 (10:41:07)

Mar: 2040-09-02 (10:41:07) - 2048-09-02 (11:53:00)

Mer: 2048-09-02 (11:53:00) - 2065-09-02 (20:18:32)

Sat: 2065-09-02 (20:18:32) - 2075-09-03 (09:54:21)"

 

Then he wrote: "he had traveled abroad for higher studies during

Jupiter antardasa in Rahu dasa Mar-1995 to Apr-1997".

 

If you take antardasas in Rahu dasa as Jupiter, Saturn, Mercury,

Mars, Moon, Sun, Venus and Rahu, then Jupiter antardasa would start

in Sept 1986 and NOT in Mar 1995. Clearly Sanjay wasn't following the

procedure he mentioned at the beginning of the chapter. If Sanjay got

Jupiter antardasa in Mar-1995 to Apr-1997, he definitely took the

antardasas in Rahu dasa to be Venus, Sun, Moon, Mars, Merc, Sat, Jup

and Rahu (presumably he was using my software). This is exactly what

I have taught.

 

In any case, I will get this clarified and make changes in the

tutorial and the software if needed.

 

May Jupiter's light shine on us,

Narasimha

 

> Namaste Waldemar,

>

> You pay attention to what you read!

>

> I had implemented antardasas this way 3 years back, when Sanjay

> taught me TP and TA dasa. I had implemented it in consultation with

> Sanjay and both of us have been using the software during this time.

>

> However, when I referred Sanjay's latest book, I did see what you

> mentioned. Clearly there is a discrepancy here. Let me get this

> clarified by him and change my tutorial and software if needed.

>

> Thank you very much for paying attention and bringing this to my

> attention!

>

> May Jupiter's light shine on us,

> Narasimha

>

> > Dear Narasimha,

> >

> > Your article about TP chart & Tithi Astottari dasa is great.

> However, for

> > count of antardasa you are not following exactly the teaching of

> Sanjay in

> > its "Vimshottari and Udu dasa's". You wrote:

> >

> > "Antardasas start from the planet after dasa lord and go in the

> order of

> > dasas. For example, in Saturn dasa, the first antardasa will be

> that of

> > Jupiter. Antardasas will go as Jupiter, Rahu, Venus, Sun, Moon,

> Mars,

> > Mercury and Saturn."

> >

> > S.Rath write for antardasa in Ashtottari dasa (p.179):

> > "since Ketu is the governor of the Ashtottari dasa, the antardasa

> shall be

> > reckoned in the reverse to established practice" and

> > "the first antardasa is of the planet preceding this" following

by

> an

> > example

> > "for Sun dasa, the first antaradasa is Venus, next of Rahu, next

of

> Jupiter

> > and so on".

> > For Tithi Ashtottari he writes (p.187):

> > " the dasa, antardasa and other sub-periods as well as their

order

> is

> > exactly the same as the Ashtottari dasa"

> >

> > Is yours opinion different from this statement?

> >

> > With best regards

> >

> > Waldemar