Who is Plagiarising from whom?

[Guest guest]

Dear Mukundji,

 

I cannot and do not want to comment about Sanjay or the website.

But I was just wondering the number of books that have plagiarised

from ancient books of India.

 

Does plagiarising mean using the same order of words, or does it mean

using the same information? Isn't converting Sanskrit to English

plagiarism? People buy english books not because they are fascinated

by the English in the books. It is because of the rules of

prediction. Information and words are two different things. The

latter are just a means to convery the former. Which do you think is

more important?

 

Thanks & Regards,

Manu

 

 

 

 

 

vedic astrology, "monmuk111" <monmuk111>

wrote:

> Dear Gentlepeople:

>

> I noticed something interesting while browsing some Vedic astrology

> websites and would like your input on this. I saw a prediction on a

> website that is identical to the one that Sanjay did for me. So I'm

> trying to figure out who is plagiarising from whom?

>

> Let's define the meaning of "plagiarising" first. Plagiarising

means

> stealing the literary work of someone else and calling it your own.

>

> Here is a prediction related to Rahu located in the 6th house taken

> from a website www.vedic astrology.i12.com:

>

> "Rahu produces great sustaining power when placed in the Sixth

house.

> Every physical impediment is mysteriously removed, success in

> temporal endeavours is assured, and diplomatic skill is developed

to

> a considerable extent. You may not have much idealism in life and

may

> even keep undesirable company. Your strength, wisdom, valour and

> conscience are stable. This Rahu denotes destruction of the

> adversary. Gain of wealth, knowledge, vigour. No gain through

uncles.

> Wealth through foreign leader type; You may be a hero, handsome,

> intelligent, respected, well-known. If well-aspected, all the evils

> fade away.

> A strong Rahu indicates vehicular wealth. Progeny to uncle denied;

or

> daughters only. Rahu in Sixth House promotes health and strength,

> trusted employees, favours service, fortune through paternal

> relatives; some income or employment. Benefit through prosperous

> uncles aunts. Strong and brave. Radical, affluent, with conveyance.

> Jewellery, wealth and fortune. Robust health. This Rahu indicates

an

> unstable mind of the father and maternal uncle. You are patient,

> tolerant, prosperous. Rahu is in 6."

>

> Now, here is a prediction related to Rahu located in 6th house that

> Sanjay did for me:

>

> "Rahu in the sixth house in Aries: Rahu produces great sustaining

> power when placed in the sixth house. Every physical impediment is

> mysteriously removed, success in temporal endeavors is assured, and

> diplomatic skill is developed to a considerable extent. You may not

> have much idealism in life and may even keep undesirable company.

You

> will feel the allure of unethical, disrespectful or forbidden

> activities. Your strength, wisdom, valor and conscience are stable.

> This Rahu denotes destruction of the adversary. Gain of wealth,

> knowledge, vigor, and no gains through uncles. Wealth through a

> foreign leader or foreigners, increases longevity, prosperity and

> indicates that you are of noble birth, but may become a debauch.

You

> may be a hero, handsome, intelligent, respected, and well known.

> Since it is well aspected by the Moon, all the evils fade away. A

> strong Rahu indicates wealth of vehicles. Either uncle or the

native

> maybe denied progeny or may have daughters alone. Rahu promotes

> health and strength, trusted employees, favors service, fortune

> through paternal relatives; some income or employment. Benefit

> through prosperous uncles aunts. Danger from service in army or

navy

> and professions of Mars should be avoided. Rahu makes you strong

and

> brave, radical, affluent, with conveyance, jewelry, wealth and

> fortune. This Rahu indicates an unstable mind of the father or

> maternal uncle. You may be infirm, imbecile but there will be an

> absence of enemies, making you friendly and full of riches. You are

> patient, tolerant and prosperous. Although you sometimes pass

through

> periods of anxious uncertainty, you finally attain your goal. You

are

> not much respected by society, yet have all the conveniences anyone

> can hope for."

>

> Both these writeups are VERBATUM and both are INDENTICAL. Now, I

have

> immense confidence in Sanjay as I have interacted with him a lot

over

> the past 2 years so it appears that this Website may be

plagiarising

> Sanjay's work, if so, this website should be censured in some way.

> OR, both Sanjay and the Website are plagiarising from somewhere

else.

>

> Plagiarising in India is a way of life; however, plagiarising in

the

> US is illegal--I remember two students were expelled from my

> university for plagiarising while I was studying. Moreover,

> plagiarising is outright unethical.

>

> I'm hoping Sanjay comes up with an explanation for this OR other

> members close to Sanjay has some explanation for the obvious

> plagiarism listed above. Thanks

>

> Mukund