To PVR: A TP D-60 confusion reg. your stmt (Twin Problem & Shastyamsa)

[Guest guest]

Dear PVR,

I started looking at TP charts the moment you said that most of your

accurate predictions in the past 3 or so years were based on TP. I

searched the archives and was examining some posts when I came across

your statement:

 

 

> D-60 can be used even in Tithi Pravesha charts (annual lunar

return

> charts), when the birthtime is known very accurately. D-60 of a TP

> chart may not show past life (what is "past life" relative to a

> year's chart?), but it does show the karma to be experienced

during

> the year, as a result of sanchita karma.

 

 

This statement bewilders me, and as I understand it, it seems wrong.

Do I understand correctly when I assume that sanchita karma is

accumulated karma of THIS lifetime? If so, then the D-60 of a TP

chart cannot possibly show it, or at least cannot show the WHOLE of

it. This follows from the following reasoning extrapolated from

basics given by Sanjay Rath - that we do have some amount of free-

will in each lifetime (otherwise Remedies wouldnt work either). So

the karma you accumulate in this lifetime is inherently NOT

predictable at the beginning of the lifetime - it depends on free-

will decisions you yet havent made. However, the TP chart for every

year of life can be calculated at birth (since the ephemeris can be

calculated well into the future), cant it? So, it logically follows

that either there is no free will or the D-60 of a TP chart cannot

show the accumulated karma of this lifetime. To be fully consistent

with this limited free-will concept the only options possible are:

 

1) The D-60 of a TP chart of year X shows the QUANTUM of previous

birth karma to be experienced in year X.

 

2) The D-60 of a TP chart of year X shows the quantum of previous

birth karma + non-free-will karma of THIS lifetime to be experienced

in year X.

 

Free-will karma cannot be estimated by ANY deterministic procedure at

birth, otherwise it wouldnt be "Free". For that reason, it seems to

me that the ONLY possible chart that can show completely currently

accumulated karma is a Prasna chart, because the time of placement of

Prasna cannot be known until you place it. The WHOLE of accumulated

karma to be experienced in year X cannot be estimated in the D-60 of

a TP chart, unless THIS life's karma is never experienced in this

life itself.

 

Is my understanding correct? Please clarify.

 

Sundeep