To Mukund Desai / public predictions

[Guest guest]

Dear Mukund and Nrsma

 

I think Mukund raises an interesting point . From what I have seen public

predictions even by the big name astrologers such as K N Rao , Sanjay Rath ,

Nrsma Rao , , Chakrapani have a fairly mixed and limited record .

I haven't seen a vedic astrologer who performs at such a level that they would

sew seeds of doubt in a hardened skeptic .

 

My experience is that the best jyotish comes out when the astrologer is just

using the divine science to help others rather than making public predictions

or solving puzzles. I have seen people come stressed to a Vedic astrologer who

then produces a masterful and accuarate reading . But the same astrologer

flounders when trying to predict the course of public events .

 

I suspect it is the way of the creator to keep us humble.

 

Nicholas

Narasimha P.V.R. Rao

vedic astrology

Monday, December 29, 2003 5:23 AM

[vedic astrology] To Mukund Desai

Namaste Mukund,

 

> I've even heard Sanjay talk about some "family jyotish > secrets he learned

from grandpa kashinath" that he is NOW opening up > to the public.--what mumbo,

jumbo.

 

Dude, nobody is forcing you to learn anything. You have no business calling it

"mumbo, jumbo". Sanjay did indeed teach gems from tradition that are not

available anywhere else. Examples are Tithi Pravesha and Kashninatha Hora

chart.

 

If you are overwhelmed by this and want to believe that this knowledge is not

worth learning, please walk away instead of bad-mouthing us. It is quite

uncivil to call it "mumbo, jumbo" just because you suddenly feel so.

 

BTW, Sanjay's grandpa is Pt. Jagannath Rath. Kashninath ji is his paternal uncle.

> And, the reality is that NO ASTROLOGER including the great ones like > Sanjay,

KN Rao, Braha, Huock (deceased), Rohini Ranjan can make an > accurate

prediction. -- Ya, they are all VERY GOOD at post-> moterm,i.e. associating

events (after they've happened) to planetary > combinations; howeve, none can

make an accurate prediction or even > dare to make predictions as the

probability of failing is extremely > high and they know it. -- Just take the

case of Sachin Tendulkar, if > you ask one of these great astrologers, ALL will

come up with some > planetary excuse for his recent faliures; however, no-one

accurately > predicted his faliure (before the fact), in-fact, Narshimha

predicted > a GOOD score for Sachin. > > Mukund

 

In a message on this list in September 2002, you wrote the following (you addressed me as "PVR"):

 

"PVR, you're are a true guru. What intrigues me is that how can you predict

stuff about my wife (that too 3rd) from MY CHART? And all of these prediction

about a wife from a husbands chart is accurate—you have never seen my wife's

chart before making this prediction. Thanks for everything, hope you keep

helping people for many more years to come."

 

Please check the following message for the quotes:

 

Your mail:

 

vedic astrology/message/17857

 

The above message was posted by you and hence you have the right to delete it in

the archives. In case you do so, readers can access your mail above quoted in my

reply at:

 

vedic astrology/message/17860

 

Now you claim that no astrologer can actually "make an accurate prediction".

This is unfair at best and childish at worst.

 

Several members, including me, solved 'blind puzzles' on this list and made

public predictions, several times successfully. Sometimes, some of us made

predictions to members (or their friends), which were confirmed later. If you

allow some failures to color your vision and make a sweeping statement such as

what you made above, it only demonstrates how immature and/or confused you are.

 

Just contrast the quote I gave from Sept 2002 and the sweeping generalization

you wrote above! How can somebody so "intrigued" by "accurate" predictions

about "my wife (that too 3rd) from MY CHART" say that "none can make an

accurate prediction" about the whole astrologer community? I hope your

inconsistency is due to immaturity and lack of clarity of thinking, rather than

dishonesty, insincerity or any kind of vindictiveness.

 

I most certainly do not want credit that I do not deserve. If my knowledge is

incomplete and a prediction goes wrong, I am humble enough to accept failure

and patient enough to study more and keep trying. But, your attack on me and

the entire community is unjustified.

 

May Jupiter's light shine on us,

PVR Narasimha Rao

Archives: vedic astrologyGroup info:

vedic astrology/info.htmlTo UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank

mail to vedic astrology-....... May Jupiter's light

shine on us ....... To visit your group on the web, go

to:vedic astrology/ To from this

group, send an email to:vedic astrology Your use

of is subject to the

 

 

---Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.Checked by AVG anti-virus system

(http://www.grisoft.com).Version: 6.0.556 / Virus Database: 348 - Release Date:

26/12/2003