rasi and bhava chakra confusion

[Guest guest]

Dear sirs

kindly see this interesting case.

IT is found in a chart of scorpio Lagna mars and

jupiter is placed in 8th sign in gemini.moon is placed

in ascendent.So traditionally lord of 5th house

jupiter is placed in 8th house and lord of 9th house

mars is placed in lagna.But it is found bhava madhya

of 4th house falls in pisces and 8th house falls in

cancer.Jupiter in sripati bhava chakra becomes lord of

4th house and is deposited in 7th house.In 10th sign

in leo venus,saturn and mercury is deposited.Mercury

becomes a natural malefic planet as it is associated

with saturn and as bhaba madhya of no house falls in

gemini and 10th house falls in virgo it

becomes lord of 10th house as per sripati deposited in

10 bhava.Now as per parashara a naturaral malefic

(here mercury) when becomes lord of kendra becomes

temporal benefic.

Saturn again should have been benefic as lord of 4th

bhava but it is found that 2nd and 3rd bhava madhya

falls in capricon and aquarius.

from this positions what should be the deductions :-

GENERAL

1)jupiter lord of 5th bhava (benefic)in 8th bhava(bad

for 5th bhava)

2)Moon lord of 9th(benefic) bhava in lagna(benefic)

but debilated( good for 1st and 9th bhava)

3)mercury lord of 8th and 11 th bhava ( malefic) in 10

bhava ( damaging 10th bhava)

4)Saturn lord 4TH BHAVA(BENEFIC) in 10th bhava ( good

for 4th and 10 th bhava)

OR

AS PER SRIPATI

1)Jupiter lord of 4th bhava(malefic kendrapati) in 7th

bhava( bad for 7th but good for 4th)

2)Moon lord of 8th bhava in 1st(bad for 1st)

3)Mercury lord of 10th bhava(benefic) in 10th(benefic)

4)Saturn lord of 2nd and 3rd bhava(malefic) in 10(bad

for 10 th bhava.

Results to be produced by the respective planets in

their mahadasa and antra along with other results.

Female horoscope

date of birth : 19-9-1977

time : 11:50 am

Place : calcutta,India

Time Zone : +5hrs 30mins

Kindly solve my confusion