To Chandrashekhar: Where exactly is the challenge?: Astrological... your

[Guest guest]

Dear Chandrashekharji,

Although I can clarify further, I think the original drift of my

argument has been lost. So I will simply reiterate it to refocus the

discussion if any remains: I specifically want to caution against

creating and falling for astrological challenges based on the outcome

of events based on MANIPULATED natural law. My stance is actually

more liberal towards Jyotish than yours (as far as this argument

evidences, that is). If you maintain that all principles must be

valid exactly as they are and must cover all future manipulated

possibilities then if someone froze an embryo for 70 years and then

proceeded to have a natural childbirth, you would be forced to admit

that the principles are incorrect simply because there is no

scriptural basis for this possibility. On the other hand, using my

stance, it is possible to view Jyotish principles as still being

correct, just NOT APPLICABLE directly in such manipulated cases. I

hope you see the difference. It is not that the people born of those

cases are not subject to the laws of karma. They still are, in

exactly the same way as everyone. Simply that in a sense, their

physical birth times, adhana times, nisheka times have been

artificially toyed around with to not reflect their karmic birth

times, adhana times, nisheka times.

 

Sundeep