RE: visti om

[Guest guest]

Dear Sudeep,

 

I cannot comment on all your other points as I do not have clarity on them but

your first point about charging money is clear to me. I do not know Pt. Rath or

his predictions/talent/knowledge. I am trying to respond to "Should Astrologer

not charge money??"

 

Any specialist be it Doctor or lawyer can charge money for professional

services. When they are rendering you the services they are not your teachers

but just advisors.

 

Any specialist should be willing to publish or share knowledge, without any

conditions that are monetary. This is when you are learning from him. This is

an Ideal condition but you can critize anybody of lack of knowledge when they

charge money. If a professor at MIT or Stanford charges money to teach me, I

cannot say they are less knowledgeable than they are. This cannot be a point

for "lack of knowledge" accusation.

 

Regards,

Rohit

sudeep suri [vaudeva99 ] Sent:

Sunday, August 15, 2004 8:58 PMvedic astrologySubject:

[vedic astrology] visti om

VISTI

I AM NOT DEFAMING HIM I AM JUST GIVING AND EXPRESSING MY VIEWS.

1)FIRSTLY IN YOUR EMAIL YOU MENTION RATH TRIED TO HELP ME: HOW DID HE HELP ME?

FIRST HE WANTED ME TO DEPOSIT X AMOUNT OF RS IN HIS ABN AMRO ACCOUNT ONLY AFTER

THE MONEY WAS DEPOSITED HE TOUCHED MY HOROSCOPE AND GAVE ALL RIDICU;LOUS

PREDICTIONS. DR MANCANDA(MY NEIGHBOUR) A RENOWED CARDIOLIGIST OF INDIA CHARGES

ONLY 500/- FOR A VISIT BUT HE SAVED MY FATHERS LIFE. RaTH CHARGES MONEY FAR

MORE IN EXCESS OF THIS AND GIVES BULL SHIT. IF HE WAS INTERESTED IN HELPING ME

THROUGH JYOTISH HE SHOULD LEAVE IT TO THe CLIENT TO GIVE GURU DAKSINA NOT HAVE

MONEY DEPOSITED IN HIS ABN AMRO BANK BEFORE HAND.

2) yOU SAY HE IS WRONG ONLY IN MY CASE : WELL THIS IS A STANDARD BULL SHIT GIVEN

BY ASTROLOGERS IN INDIA.COME TO DELHI AND I WILL INTRODUCE YOU TO PEOPLE AND

VERY POWERFUL PEOPLE OF INDIa HEAR FROM THEIR MOUTH RATHS ABILITY TO PREDICT.I

KNOW ASTROLOGY COME TO DELHI MEET WITH SENIOR PEOPLE WHO HAVE PRESSED ME TO DO

JYOTISH FOR MONEY BUT I HAVE NEVER DONE IT, I HAVE HELPED PEOPLE FREE OF COST

WITH JYOTISH BOTH IN INDIA AND CANADA BUT I HAVE NEVER DONE IT FOR MONEY

BECAUSE MY DIVINE GURU HAS PROBHITED THAT A SPIRITUAL SADHAK SHOULD NOT DO

JYOTISH FOR MONEY.

3) you say be gone

WELL JYOTISH IS A INDIAN TRADITION.YOGA IS A INDIAN TRADITION. IT IS YOU

FOREINERS WHO HAVE DISTORTED OUR DIVINE SCIENCES,YOU WHITE FELLOWS FIRST

DIVIDED OUR COUNTRY AND NOW YOU DISTORT OUR HOLY SCIENCES FOR DOLLARS AND YOU

HAVE THE CHEEK TO TELL ME BE GONE. IT IS YOU WHO SHOULD BE BE GONE. GET OUT AND

LEAVE JYOTISH ALONE.IT IS OUR HERITIGAGE FROM THE RISHIS NOT SOMETHING WE

BORROWED FROM DENMARK SO GET OUT.

OM