vimsottari-dasha applicible to divisional charts?

[Guest guest]

Dear members,

 

Vimshottari dasha is calculated on the basis of the Moon's position in rashi

chakra and thus there is a relation between the two.

 

Is there a good reason (scripturally or logically) why vimshottari dasha is

related to the planets in the navamsa, dasamsa etc.?

 

For example, if one is in the Sun dasha, and Sun is a certain house of the rasi,

we can be sure that issues related to that house will come up during that

period. But if the Sun is in a certain house in the navamsa, will that house

influence the nature of that dasha?

 

Or should we approach the divisional charts with separate dasha systems, such as

Narayana dasha? It seems logical to me that every divisional chart needs a

separate division of dashas...

 

Ivar

[Guest guest]

Dear Ivar,

There are different opinions on the subject and some do apply the

Dashas to D- Charts. Others, like me, prefer to find out the effects of

the dasha lord, with reference to various D-Charts and its own

intrinsic strength/weakness and apply the Vimshottary dasha to arrive

at predictions.

Chandrashekhar.

Ivar Verploegh wrote:

Dear members,

 

Vimshottari dasha is calculated on

the basis of the Moon's position in rashi chakra and thus there is a

relation between the two.

 

Is there a good reason (scripturally

or logically) why vimshottari dasha is related to the planets in the

navamsa, dasamsa etc.?

 

For example, if one is in the Sun

dasha, and Sun is a certain house of the rasi, we can be sure that

issues related to that house will come up during that period. But

if the Sun is in a certain house in the navamsa, will that house

influence the nature of that dasha?

 

Or should we approach the divisional

charts with separate dasha systems, such as Narayana dasha? It seems

logical to me that every divisional chart needs a separate division of

dashas...

 

Ivar