Tagore, Wrong Assessment (to Manjunath)

[Guest guest]

Dear Manjunath,

 

> Another important comment that I made in my write up is > "4.In Shodashottary

dasha, Mercury – Venus is again not favorable > from health point of view.

Mercury as eighth lord and Venus as > maraka 7th lord will finally put an end

to his glorious career. Note > that both are in Rehnquist's tenth house and

hence he is not retired > yet."> > It is clear, using Shodashottary dasha, that

his end was coming. I > did not use the third level of this dasha. That would

have been the > clincher perhaps - to time this event even better.> > All the

conditional dasha books that I have read say that it takes > precedence over

Vimshottari.

 

I agree, with one reservation. In my experience, rare conditional dasas such as

Dwisaptati sama dasa, Chaturaseeti sama dasa, Sataabdika dasa etc work way

better than Vimsottari when applicable. But I have not found the same to be

true with not-so-rare conditional dasas.

 

For example, Shodasottari dasa is applicable in 50% horoscopes. It will be a

stretch to say that it takes precedence over Vimsottari dasa in half the

charts.

 

I found charts where Shodasottari dasa is applicable and works way better than

Vimsottari dasa. I have also found charts where Shodasottari dasa is

technically applicable and yet Vimsottari dasa works better.

 

I am confident that there are still some missing links in our understanding of

some conditional dasas. It is funny how things that should be crystal clear and

obvious to the common sense are obscured from our thinking until the right time

comes, when an important insight comes and one wonders why one never thought of

such an obvious thing!

 

We still need to discover a few missing links.

 

> Hence it is possible that Mer-Ven is

> the clear explanation than Mo-Mo. But it is after the fact and only > an

academic excercise now. But still I have learnt a lot from > analyzing the

horoscope of Rehnquist.

I am sure others learnt too! Thanks for all the nice work on this chart.

 

May Jupiter's light shine on us, Narasimha

-------------------------------Free Jyotish

lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.netFree Jyotish software

(Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.orgSri Jagannath Centre (SJC) website:

http://www.SriJagannath.org-------------------------------