Tagore, Wrong Assessment (to Pradeep)

[Guest guest]

Dear Pradeep,

 

> >>>> Thus, Mercury and Sun are both strong marakas. Mercury-Sun> >>>antardasa

makes more sense to me than Mars-Rahu.> > If we are using this variation of

Vimshottari,Mercury/Sun is more> suitable.

> But then the question is whether Vimshottari from janma nakshathra can>

explain Ayur related or not?I feel it is possible.Then Rahu/Kuja is a> better

candidate over Guru/Guru.

 

Irrespective of the ayanamsa used, one can find many charts in which the

strongest maraka's dasa as per normal Vimsottari dasa does not kill. If one

uses weak points to justify a planet's marakatwa, 6 out of 9 planets can be

justified in every chart.

 

However, if one uses the most appropriate variation of Vimsottari dasa, almost

always the strongest maraka's dasa brings death!

 

I am sure most Jyotishis will agree that 7th lord Mercury in 2nd with ownership

of 22nd drekkana and 64th navamsa is the strongest maraka in Tagore's chart. If

you are getting his death in Jupiter dasa or Rahu dasa, you are simply not using

the best dasa for longevity matters in his chart.

 

BTW, why is Rahu a strong maraka in this chart? He owns 12th and occupies 10th.

By his aspect on 2nd, he becomes a weak maraka. Mercury, Sun, Venus anmd Mars

are all much stronger marakas than Rahu.

> Thanks a lot for the rest of the mail and explanations.I have never> ruled

out the importance of conditional dashas.> But i strongly feel,predictive

experience using normal dasha,is a> precondition,before attempting

conditional.Because Phalita includes> all Phalas,and the general indications

shlould be visible.

 

General dasas, in the event of the applicability of conditional dasas, show

events vaguely. Out of the 5 or 6 planets that are qualified to give an event,

a second tier or third tier candidate may give a result sometimes. It is easy

to explain after the fact, but not easy to predict. When the correct

conditional dasa is used, the result is given by the one of the top (tier one)

candidates. It is easier to predict.

 

Using an applicable conditional dasa to make a prediction is akin to connecting

100 dots to make a picture, while using Vimsottari dasa in the same chart to

make the same prediction is akin to connecting only 10 dots to make the same

picture. Learning to connect 10 dots to make a picture can never be a

"precondition" to learning to connect 100 dots to make the same picture. If one

has enough intuition to guess the picture from 10 dots, one does not need to

learn guessing it from 100 dots. The latter should be the first step rather

than the former!

 

In my view, one can learn Jyotish principles faster if one uses the most

applicable nakshatra dasa in a chart. By sticking to normal Vimsottari dasa,

people lose the sense of which planet is the best candidate to give an event

and which planet is a tier 2 or tier 3 candidate. Students learn to mix up

strong and weak candidates.

 

Parasara taught all those dasas for a reason!

 

May Jupiter's light shine on us, Narasimha

-------------------------------Free Jyotish

lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.netFree Jyotish software

(Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.orgSri Jagannath Centre (SJC) website:

http://www.SriJagannath.org-------------------------------